5 ms·
To summarize more concisely, American citizens living abroad must pay taxes with their time and with their personal information rather than with their dollars o
by logfromblammo 12y ago
To summarize more concisely, American citizens living abroad must pay taxes with their time and with their personal information rather than with their dollars or foreign currency.
The issue at hand that induces an increasing number of dual citizens to drop their American citizenship is that the U.S. government is supposedly forbidden from both prying into the private affairs of individuals and from compelling involuntary servitude, yet it does so on a massive scale with respect to its citizens living abroad.
These people are often paying more in tax to their local sovereign authority than they would if resident in one of the United States, and would thus owe no money to the U.S. even if they earned 100 times more. They are not trying to avoid the expense of taxes. They are trying to avoid the annual ordeal of stripping naked before their distant federal overlords in a humiliating ritual designed to show that they are guilty of no crime, absent any individualized suspicion of wrongdoing.
They should enjoy the presumption of innocence that the U.S. is compelled by its foundation law to extend, and be able to keep their private affairs private until there is enough specific evidence that a crime has been committed to issue specific warrants. The federal U.S. government has instead been acting as a bully and an ass, with no discernable goals other than to demand obedience and enforce compliance, for far too long.
They can tax foreign-domiciled citizens as much as they like, for now. Rather than question that here, I would very much like to remove their ability to levy their onerous information reporting requirements on those people and upon the foreign persons that would very much like to do business with them without some nosy busybody rudely inserting himself into the transaction to interfere.
When people who supposedly represent our interests act in such a fashion, it reflects extremely poorly upon the nation as a whole. While foreign entities currently tolerate the behavior, it is only because they lack more viable alternatives.
But beyond the behavior, those expatriates have firsthand knowledge of how other nations operate their taxation systems. And they know that the U.S. system is almost always worse when measured by the scale and complexity of the paperwork. There is no particular technical reason why it is that way. But every time a reform is proposed, the media narrative magically transforms it into an issue about money and fairness rather than transparency, privacy, simplicity, efficiency, or any of the other standards that show it to be a colossal failure when compared with any other modern economy on the planet.
It really is very embarrassing to think that my Big Brother not only watches me in my every waking moment, but he also preemptively beats up every single one of my friends in the schoolyard, just to ensure that I can't even have a moment's peace on a sleepover.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoIf you live in a low income tax country like HK, Singapore, or Switzerland, AND you make over $100K a year, you have to actually pay money to the US government. This is where the housing deduction comes in useful.