5 ms·
As an interface designer Plan9 have always fascinated me yet I found it incredible hard to find many other designers who were into it's concepts. I always love
by ThomPete 12y ago
As an interface designer Plan9 have always fascinated me yet I found it incredible hard to find many other designers who were into it's concepts.
I always loved the "everything is an object" approach and in a better world this not NeXT or Windows would be our underlying principle.
- mercurial 12y agoYou may be interested in wmii [1], a tiling WM which is inspired by Plan 9 and uses 9P. 1: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wmii http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wmii
- burke 12y agoI love wmii. It's the primary reason I resent OS X.
- scott_karana 12y ago> I love wmii. It's the primary reason I resent OS X. Huh? What's the relationship?
- __float 12y agoPresumably the fact that you're tied into using Apple's window manager. But that's really loose and I don't totally understand why it merited being mentioned either, haha.
- TheZenPsycho 12y agoOSX fundamentally doesn't support robust tiling window managers. they exist only as a pale shadow of the real thing.
- scott_karana 12y agoIsn't that the same case as Windows, BeOS, Android, iOS, PalmOS, etc?... I was wondering why OSX was explicitly called out.
- _delirium 12y agoOSX has a larger userbase of Plan9 fans, I think, including a number who run plan9port on it (Rob Pike has said that he uses such a setup). So the bits that you can't get Plan9-ish might rankle someone. Windows isn't any better, but there aren't many people trying to make Windows feel anything like Plan9 in the first place, so nobody's too disappointed about it.
- rcarmo 12y agoMoom is pretty handy, though.
- cmiller1 12y agoYou can run any linux window manager directly on os x... of course you're stuck running only *nix programs then
- girvo 12y agoTrue, but Amethyst[0] comes pretty close for my personal taste. [0] https://github.com/ianyh/Amethyst https://github.com/ianyh/Amethyst
- glhaynes 12y agoPresumably it's a sort of sideways/backhanded almost-compliment to OS X: it works well enough comparatively that its plusses overwhelm its negatives for the commenter. But, they still wish it supported more flexibility; and the fact it doesn't (and yet its plusses nevertheless still compare favorably enough to its minuses that the commenter continues to use it) leads to a sort of feeling of dissatisfaction and resentment.
- burke 12y agoYes, exactly. I mostly love OS X in that it gives me nearly everything I love about Linux with almost none of the hassle. The window management story is terrible though. Wmii really clicked for me, and OS X really pales in comparison on that front.
- ThomPete 12y agoVery interesting thank you!
- dbdr 12y agoInterestingly, i3wm is designed as a successor to wmii and explicitly decided to avoid the Plan 9 aspect. [1] Does someone have examples of cool things you can do in wmii thanks to this? [1] Google Tech Talk about i3: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QnYN2CTb1hM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QnYN2CTb1hM (this question at 15:30)
- pjmlp 12y agoOS/2 Presentation Manager and SOM tried it. Oberon also had quite nice concepts, specially version 3 with Gadgets.
- mhd 12y ago> I always loved the "everything is an object" approach Which sadly isn't at all what Plan9 does, in the usual "worse is better" way of Unix. Objects would allow a bit more versatility than the "everything is a file, usually one with plain UTF-8 text" approach. (And actually, Windows is closer to an object world with COM, as evidenced by e.g. the core model of PowerShell) Of course, an object-model has a hard time when the rest of the world and the net is talking in files, you're also much more likely to create a walled garden. As for simplicity, I can understand that regarding systems like Smalltalk (or possibly lisp machines), although Oberon serves as a prime counter-example here. It did inspire the Acme editor, and here you can see that if your basic text model is objects, not just a byte-stream, some extensions are easier to do (different fonts, syntax highlighting, widgets). And yes, I'm aware that the usual response to that was and is "you don't need that". Milages obviously do vary.