5 ms·
It's interesting that even during the height of the recent Gaza war Israel maintained the Internet connections to Gaza. May increased communication and venture
by ars 12y ago
It's interesting that even during the height of the recent Gaza war Israel maintained the Internet connections to Gaza.
May increased communication and ventures like the article mention bring Gazans the democracy they desperately need.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pavlov 12y agoAre you sure that the Internet connection to Gaza goes through Israel? I would have assumed that it's via Egypt instead, as Gaza has a land border there as well.
- hrasyid 12y agoYeah and the Egyptian regime is more interested in providing internet to Gazans than Israel? Actually, I'm curious, how does Gaza get its internet? Any source/reference mentioning this?
- aidos 12y agoThe wikipedia page [0] claims that there are 4 ISPs providing internet in Gaza. I believe that in the case of electricity, Israel is obliged to provide power to the region under international law (since they control its borders). [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaza_Strip http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaza_Strip
- smcl 12y agoNot to get too political\opinionated but Israel does not have a particularly strong reputation for respecting international laws regarding Palestine (West Bank or Gaza) which makes it even more surprising if they continued to supply power.
- ars 12y ago> which makes it even more surprising if they continued to supply power. You don't understand Israel at all. It would be surprising if they didn't supply power. Israel doesn't hate Gazans, they just want Gazans to stop attacking them. They pulled out of Gaza to give them less of a reason to hate Israel, but that didn't work. Israel has little interest in giving them a country, it is true. But not because they want to deny them a county but because they don't think it will help. After all pulling out of Gaza did not help - in fact it made it worse. Israel doesn't care about the UN because the UN is utterly obsessed with Israel, and essentially they don't consider the UN legitimate in this regard because of that obsession. Most of the world considers the UN a joke for exactly this reason (plus things like allowing known human right abusing countries to chair human rights commissions).
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- frozenport 12y agoDoes this change your opinion?
- JupiterMoon 12y agoDidn't Israel bomb the power station in Gaza?
- Smokey28 12y agoWhich is now up and running a shocking 46 weeks ahead of schedule. Don't believe everything you read.
- JupiterMoon 12y agoNot sure I follow you logic here. Because something got repaired then it is OK that it was smashed in the first place? Can you clarify?
- ars 12y ago> Actually, I'm curious, how does Gaza get its internet? As I said, it's via Israel. Same with phone service and postal mail.
- JupiterMoon 12y agoIndeed everything enters or leaves via Israel...
- pete_b 12y agoEygpt also has a blockade at its border with Gaza. Must be something to do with the terrorists that run Gaza, and were voted in by the populace.
- aidos 12y agoI'm going to downvote you because my sarcasm meter isn't functioning properly this morning and your comment is going to end up derailing a useful piece on a promising new startup culture in Gaza.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ars 12y agoIt's extremely easy to keep Israel from bombing Gaza: Don't launch rockets at Israel. Now presumably not all the residents of Gaza want to kill Israel, but enough do, and the rest suffer because of them (and because of the leaders they chose in their one and only election).
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- aidos 12y agoLook, I have very strong views on the subject. It's the political area I've delved deepest into in my life. I've read untold articles and numerous books on the subject. This is not the time or place for raising the political issues. I'm keeping my political opinions out of it on this forum and I wish everyone else would have the good sense do the same. If there's ever an article about Gaza on the front page of HN it's removed within a couple of hours because people start banging on about politics. I could quite happy argue about it all day long, but not here, and not now.
- waps 12y agoAll online articles seem to indicate it goes through Israel : http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/11/20/israel-gaza-internet_n_2159407.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/11/20/israel-gaza-interne... But the problem for the internet in the Gaza strip is not Israel: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamization_of_the_Gaza_Strip#Music_and_Internet http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamization_of_the_Gaza_Strip#... Now please keep in mind that "democratization" won't help. Over half of Gazans want this (and want to kill people who try to fix it - that seems to be what sharia ("the path of islam") demands). Democracy will make it worse. There seems to be a huge misconception here. On a large scale, and on average (NOT talking about any individuals here, just "average" human behavior), people who have been hurt don't want help. They don't want to help. They want to hurt others in the same way they were hurt. People who were beaten by their parents, on average, beat their children. People who come out of abusive homes in general, are abusive spouses. People who live in violence, become violent. This makes sense if you consider what algorithm the human mind must be running. One quickly arrives at the conclusion can only be an imitation algorithm (ie. what you do is copied from a past experience of what you saw someone else do), probably coupled with reinforcement learning and generalization mechanisms. This of course means something really, really bad for places like the Gaza strip. Left to their own devices, they will only sink deeper into their obsession, and become ever more abusive and restrictive until they literally start dying or at least completely stagnate. There is no way out that doesn't involve blowing up their state, and going against the wishes of the large majority of their population. Not, of course, the way Israel is doing that.
- ars 12y agoYes, I'm sure. I would assume the connection is monitored, but it is not censored. (There is censoring done internally though.) Egypt is not as technological as Israel, plus the border with Gaza is very very far from anything much in Egypt. It would take a lot of effort to bring Internet there. Israel also provides phone service to Gaza, both via lines to local towers and via towers located in Israel. People assume Egypt helps Gaza, but even in the Mubarak days they really didn't care about them much at all - just lip service. And certainly not today. They are not much different from the rest of the Arab world in this regard.
- pavlov 12y agoThanks for the reply, interesting information!
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- beloch 12y agoI'd be surprised if Israel would permit Palestine to build network infrastructure crossing the border to Egypt. First, Israel is deeply suspicious of any construction projects in Palestine to the point of rigidly controlling imports of materials as prosaic as concrete. Underground tunnels for telecommunications, especially those crossing the border to Egypt, would be strictly verboten. Second, it's in Israel's interests to supply Gaza with as much of their communications needs as possible. Internet, cable TV, cellular communications, etc.. If they have a branch similar to the NSA this makes monitoring much easier. Also, if it ever proves strategically advantageous, they have the ability to disrupt all these channels of communication and deny them to their enemy. (That they haven't so far during conflict suggests they do monitor communications.) If Israel simply refused to provide these services Palestinians would find ways to obtain them that Israel would not control and may find more difficult to monitor.
- blisterpeanuts 12y agoConcrete can be (and has obviously been) used to build infiltration tunnels under the border. If the Gazans were not building tunnels, and in general were not engaged in provocative acts such as firing rockets across the border, there's no limit to the trade and investment that could be happening between the two regions. The sea coast could be a billion dollar resort; the Gazan labor force could be productively employed; and the farms and greenhouses could be growing tons of items for consumption and export. This woman's enterprise, established under the sparsest of conditions, is an example of what can be done if there were peaceful relations and if the government in Gaza were truly representative and dedicated to peaceful negotiations etc. A warlike government that caters to the militants in Hamas, Al Aqsa Martyrs, etc., is simply uninterested in economic development, nor does it have any native expertise in that area. Its only legitimacy is based on armed conflict with its neighbor and armed suppression of dissidents internally.