4 ms·
Here's the weird bit. The "nut graf" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nut_graph http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nut_graph) in Hughes' essay is: > At the heart of the
by smacktoward 12y ago
Here's the weird bit. The "nut graf" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nut_graph http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nut_graph) in Hughes' essay is:
> At the heart of the conflict of the past few days is a divergent view on how the New Republic — and journalism more broadly — will survive. In one view, it is a “public trust” and not a business. It is something greater than a commercial enterprise, ineffable, an ideal that cannot be touched. Financially, it would be a charity. There is much experimentation in nonprofit journalism – ProPublica and the Texas Tribune are proving the model — and that may be the right path for certain institutions. At the New Republic, I believe we owe it to ourselves and to this institution to aim to become a sustainable business and not position ourselves to rely on the largesse of an unpredictable few. Our success is not guaranteed, but I think it’s critical to try.
So he thinks it's "critical" that TNR be operated as a business, rather than a non-profit. OK, fine. But he never bothers to explain why. Why do they "owe it to ourselves and this institution to become a sustainable business", rather than a non-profit? Non-profits can be "sustainable" too, after all. But he never gets around to mounting an argument for why having TNR be a profitable business is "critical." He just asserts that this is so.
It's like he wants to reply to his critics, but without actually engaging with their arguments in any substantive way. So it comes off reading like an internal monologue rather than a convincing argument.
- vasilipupkin 12y agoBecause he doesn't want to continuously throw money down a bottomless pit? He may be ok with it not providing much financial return, but is it too much to not want to lose millions year after year?
- vasilipupkin 12y agook, let me rephrase after a downvote: he is the owner, right? why is it unreasonable for him to want this publication he owns to be a business? Why does that require an explanation?
- chasing 12y agoIt's not unreasonable, of course. Except for the special case that he's worth $800m and the publication in question is the New Republic. And, as he notes, there is a trend of journalistic organizations eschewing the traditional for-profit model in order to sustain themselves and provide the quality journalism our country and world needs.
- vasilipupkin 12y agoSo, just because he is worth 800 million, he absolutely must be ok with New Republic not being self sustaining? that seems unreasonable to me. He may have lots of ideas about what to do with his money that don't all involve this one issue
- chasing 12y agoYou've misunderstood me. I agree with you: It's not unreasonable for him to want to run the New Republic as a self-sustaining business. And he owes no one an explanation -- especially if he's fine with changing how people view the New Republic as a brand. (Meaning, if he doesn't care about alienating his existing readers in favor of a new readership, whatever that might be.) But we're in a world where quality journalism is evaporating, I think it's fair for people to want more of an explanation than this. Especially since, as someone who possesses extreme wealth, he's not under the same financial pressures as another owner might be. Many people care about the New Republic. We want to know why things we care about appear to be breaking.
- vasilipupkin 12y ago"We are in a world where quality journalism is evaporating". Really? I don't see it that way. NYTimes, New Yorker, Vox, Atlantic, and yes, even BuzzFeed and BusinessInsider, ProPublica, NPR, WSJ, Financial Times, etc, etc. do lots of interesting, quality journalism. Maybe, I am wrong - but I feel like I have easy access to a lot more good stuff than ever before
- justin66 12y ago
- rst 12y agoHe also fails to state in any clear way what, concretely, Foer, Wieseltier, Ioffe, et al wanted that was inconsistent with his idea of a "businesslike" mode of operation, whatever that means...
- tw04 12y agoCatering to the twitter generation instead of, you know, actual journalism.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]