7 ms·
Do Small-RAM Devices Have a Future? (2011)
- FigBug 12y agoI think they do. One one hand, for building complex embedded systems it sure is nice to be able to get an Arm processor, Linux a high level language etc. Getting all that setup takes time, but it's worth it since it since the rest of the development goes so much faster. But, I still use a ton of AVRs and similar small memory micros. For each big micro I use, they have a few small micros in support. It's so much easier to do hard real time without an OS, or pipelines, etc. When you can just count instructions and know the timing. As the bigger micros continue to move down market, the small ones will get even smaller and lower power and open up new markets.
- minthd 12y agothere are already quite a few multi-core microcontrollers available ,why not use them instead?
- FigBug 12y agoCurrently I'm working on instrumentation amplifiers and the analog signal can't travel very far. So each one has its own AVR controlling it. Then there is a high powered micro that collects and stores all the data. Or, there may not be enough pins. May use a small micros to watch all the user interface buttons (think like a keyboard controller) which communicates to the large micro.
- VLM 12y agoA stereotypical answer FigBug didn't mention was interrupt latency is much faster and jitter in the interrupt latency sometimes doesn't even exist. Also, closely related to above, simplicity and modularity. Don't want to be the guy debugging why the antilock brakes occasionally miss an encoder transition when the engine RPM fuel injector routine is just perfectly the wrong interrupt rate. Its very much unix vs windows philosophy WRT monolithic-ness.
- minthd 12y agoI think multi-core mcu's have interrupt independence per core.
- userbinator 12y agoIt's 2 years after that article was written, and I don't see 8-bit MCUs and their accompanying tiny amounts of RAM going away anytime soon - although ARM seems to have had a lot of publicity, architectures like the 8051, with its 256 bytes of RAM (and up to 64K of external RAM, not present on all models), are still alive and well; for every chip containing an ARM core that's been shipped, there's probably several times more with 8051 or other 8-bit cores. I singled out 8051 because unlike PIC/AVR which are only single-sourced, and ARM which is not free, it's both produced by many manufacturers, and AFAIK it's free to implement. In fact I wish the trend of making "smart" devices with grossly overpowered processors that were likely chosen just so they could run a fully bloated Linux distro - only to poke a few GPIOs based on some very simple input events - would stop. Running a full OS when only a tiny fraction of the functionality is used is not only wasteful, it adds to the security risk because of increased attack area.
- nezza-_- 12y agoThe problem is: A lot of the 'native' libraries and even the open-source embedded RT OSs really suck. And if you use a vendor's library you are very locked in: Let's say you use a TI chip for your prototype but then someone who knows stuff about designing hardware tells you that now it has to run on an Atmel processor because $profits... you will have to reimplement a lot of your stuff which costs (quite a huge amount) of time and might even require an entire rewrite..
- minthd 12y agoyou could always use something like the mbed or arduino , and have the ability to change chips ,but if you want to access the full capabilities of chips ,you'll cant have portability ,because you lose something when abstracting.
- EpicEng 12y agoAm Arduino is not a production solution. It's great for prototyping, but to expensive for mass production. You go with something as small and cheap as possible.
- Nursie 12y agoBeen working on a device with 128k of RAM and 256K flash (for program and file storage) this year. They ain't gone yet!
- ghshephard 12y agoIf I read the article correctly, "Small Ram Devices" can refer to devices with < 16 bytes of memory and < 128 bytes (the first two categories) - from that perspective, 128 kbytes is 1000x to 8000x larger.
- Nursie 12y agoI think 128k was still in the category as he mentions the idea that processors with megabytes of on-chip RAM may become the minimum spec. But sure, 128k is masses compared to some others!
- minthd 12y agoEven assuming it would be possible to build ram that takes almost no power(which is a scarce resource in many systems), still memory is the biggest tool vendors use today to differentiate prices between chips and to optimize profitability and this fits with product makers since more memory generally means more complex and expensive product. but we also see a shift towards low-cost chips with lots of memory,for example a new NXP dual-core $2 chip with 108k ram . What's extra nice about this chip is that it let's you use( in theory ) a garbage collected language ,or even a scripting language in one core and c in another core for your realtime stuff,thus enabling you to mostly write high level code while still having a realtime system.
- homer-simpson 12y agoWhich "new NXP dual-core $2 chip" are you referring to? I skimmed through the NXP micro-controller website but could not find anything close to this.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- minthd 12y agohttp://www.eetimes.com/document.asp?doc_id=1324539 http://www.eetimes.com/document.asp?doc_id=1324539
- Sanddancer 12y agoLooking around, the cheapest I found was $2.62, if you buy a reel of 3000 of them [1]. It's definitely a nice price, but saying something costs two bucks implies maybe up to two and a quarter each, not when it's closer to three. [1] http://www.findchips.com/search/lpc54101j256uk49 http://www.findchips.com/search/lpc54101j256uk49
- stbtrax 12y agoIt says $2 @ 10K. No one is pricing for hobbyists buying in 10s.
- rasz_pl 12y agoArticle and comments below show lack of domain knowledge (even for 2011). Most of the price of the smallest (1KB ram) micros today is in packaging, shipping, handling and both manufacturer and distributor margin. Price of silicon is almost irrelevant. Micros that go into memory cards cost 1c each and are shipped as bare dies. > if a 1kB MCU were to cost ~$0.01 I think you would see it going into things like watches simple calculators and even flashlights they do and they are >I sure the heck don’t need linux or android running my washing machine. its not about your need, its about marketing. If someone can make a fridge with embedded android tablet (~$10 bom) and differentiate this way from competition they will, even if its a shitty useless embedded system. Its not a question of why, its a question of why not :) Smart TVs are a perfect example, it doesnt cost anything to make TV "smart". Difference between bare lcd controller TSUMV29LU and one full of hardware decoders TSUMV59XU (mp3, MPEG1/2/4, DivXˈ, H.264, RV8, RV9, RV10, Xvid, jpeg, mjpeg) is ~one dollar. Its the same with ram, at this point small amounts of ram are basically FREE, differences you see in datasheets and in price listings are dictated by politics and market segmentation. 8051 was ~60K transistors (same ballpark as Cortex M4), 1KB ram is 1000 transistors, <2%. There really is no difference between selling you 128 bytes or 2KB ram chip, other than trying to create virtual segments and artificial price brackets.
- TD-Linux 12y agoRight. The real jump from small to large RAM devices is the presence or absence of DRAM. Large SRAMs get costly and power hungry quick - the largest RAM Cortex-M4 devices have about 192KiB of SRAM, but cost $6-10. The jump to DRAM, however, is very expensive, because DRAM is fabricated on a different process and needs to be installed as a separate die or package. It is also too high latency to use as the only RAM, so a SRAM cache is still necessary. The market currently segregates a lot of other features based on the RAM interface. Cortex-M series cores, sold as "microcontrollers", almost never have DRAM, only support Thumb-2, and have no MMU. Cortex-A series are sold as "application processors", have external DRAM interfaces, and include a MMU. A similar divide is visible with the MIPS architecture.
- monocasa 12y agoI'm starting to see more and more Cortex-Ms with DRAM interfaces. STM32F427s added them to their FSMC peripheral (their new discovery board has 32MB of DRAM actually).
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- justincormack 12y agoI went to a talk the other day [1] that argued that the really low end were too small to do crypto so their use cases were limited by that to non networked applications. Mid range eggs Cortex can though. [1] http://www.slideshare.net/mobile/CohesiveFT/chris-swans-presentation-for-thing-monk-security-protocols-in-constrained-environments http://www.slideshare.net/mobile/CohesiveFT/chris-swans-pres...