3 ms·
No, you're correct. I believe this refers to the case going on right now [1] where RealPlayer Music that was sold in '05 or so as 'iPod Compatible' was locked
by MBCook 12y ago
No, you're correct.
I believe this refers to the case going on right now [1] where RealPlayer Music that was sold in '05 or so as 'iPod Compatible' was locked out more than once by iTunes updates.
The thing is it worked (like PlayFair before it [2]) by circumventing/faking FairPlay, which was/is quite likely a violation of the DMCA. Apple patched the bugs and thus "excluded competitors".
So because Apple "excluded competitors" (who where breaking their encryption) they artificially keep the price of music high by stifling competition (ignoring record company contracts and the fact that Real had a 3% market share at the time).
You're right thought. Throughout the entire life of the iPod you've been able to play DRM free MP3s that you got through any method, legal or otherwise.
Don't forget, Real didn't have a good reputation. And they were breaking Apple's DRM so you could play files that had their DRM so it's the "they were fighting for people's freedom" card isn't very strong.
I see this as the same as when Palm faked USB IDs so the Pre would sync with iTunes. Someone else hacked their way into taking advantage of Apple's software and then got mad when the hack was removed and claimed "unfair competition". Sour grapes.
[1] http://appleinsider.com/articles/14/12/03/steve-jobs-video-testimony-and-emails-revealed-in-ipod-itunes-antitrust-lawsuit http://appleinsider.com/articles/14/12/03/steve-jobs-video-t...
[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FairPlay http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FairPlay
- aikah 12y agoThanks for the explanation.
- gnu8 12y agoIt's not possible that it violated the DMCA because it would be fair use to copy legally purchased audio files to an iPod, regardless of vendor.
- tadfisher 12y agoThe DMCA has no exemption for "fair use". Fair use is a specific term, the meaning of which does not include being able to play any audio on hardware with copy-protection.
- brownbat 12y agoMore specifically, the DMCA (in the relevant provision) covers bypassing technology that prevents copying. Copyright law covers copying itself. So if you bypass some encryption to copy something, we have to look at two different areas of law, one for the bypassing, one for the copying. Fair use provides some exemptions to the copying. DMCA exemptions are promulgated by the Library of Congress, developed in consultation with the Copyright Office and after public notice and comment periods, and updated every three years. DMCA exemptions are not automatically renewed, so the exemptions can change radically every three years. Public comments have frequently requested a catchall fair use exemption to the DMCA, ie, if the anti-circumvention tech was bypassed only in service of a fair use of a work, then there should be no violation of the DMCA. Such an exemption has been rejected so far, but could be adopted at some point in the future.
- makomk 12y agoThe DMCA covers bypassing technology that prevents the copying of protected works. I don't think it was ever intended to cover bypassing the parts that prevent you from using it to protect your own works from copying.
- brownbat 12y agoThis has actually been the subject of (depressing) scholarly research. "Further, we conclude that the exemption proceeding is constructed not to protect noninfringing users, but to limit courts' ability to exonerate them via the traditional defenses to copyright infringement." http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=844544 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=844544
- jahewson 12y agoActually the case law means that the DMCA has been judged to have have an exemption for fair use [1]. Because neither Real nor their customers were trying to gain unauthorised access to copy-protected materials, it seems unlikely that their behaviour would be considered anti-circumvention. 1. http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2010/07/court-breaking-drm-for-a-fair-use-is-legal/ http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2010/07/court-...
- lmm 12y agoIt's no different from Microsoft changing DOS until Lotus wouldn't run on it. I'm amazed at how many people will defend everything Apple does.
- spacemanmatt 12y agoThey weren't there to wince for DR-DOS, Lotus, Borland, or consider the lurid details of just how dirty MS played to sabotage them.
- chockablock 12y agoIt's different in that DOS was an operating system for a general purpose computer, whereas the iPod was sold as a closed, non-interoperable consumer device. I'm not defending Apple's actions in the case (I'm not familiar enough with the details) but I don't think your analogy is sound.