12 ms·
Law school applications collapse: Get ready for schools to start closing
- Nicholas_C 12y agoSimply googling "Should I go to law school?" yields a ridiculous amount of horror stories about people who are hundreds of thousands of dollars in debt with a JD and working retail and/or making less than $20/hour. I would really like to see a ROI for every law school in the nation. I would suspect that most below the top 30 or so have a negative ROI. Slate is blocked on my work internet for whatever reason.
- jurassic 12y agoThe article reports that some schools are having to give large tuition discounts to attract a decent class, and the writer predicts closures similar to dental schools in the 80s. The most interesting tidbit was that "the biggest application declines have occurred among students who scored in the middle-to-high range on the LSAT." Confirms my general feeling about people who borrow heavily and go despite the overwhelming evidence that it's a bad idea outside of the top schools.
- jessaustin 12y agoDental schools are back on the upswing, at least over the last decade (and for the foreseeable future).
- Alex3917 12y agoDon't bother Googling, just go to Law School Transparency. http://www.lawschooltransparency.com http://www.lawschooltransparency.com
- debacle 12y agoThis is a good thing. I would make a rough estimate that 5-8% of the programmers that I know have their law degree. Most didn't even bother taking the bar because it didn't make sense. The "non-partner" track for attorneys is kind of a non-starter for anyone who wants to make more than minimum wage when you factor in the 70 hour work weeks.
- gnarbarian 12y ago0% of the programmers I know have one. Where do you live?
- debacle 12y agoNew York, but about half of them are not in this state.
- arthurcolle 12y agoTotal guess and not the original poster but I'm guessing NY
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- burritofanatic 12y agoI have a law degree, and I live in Los Angeles. I still don't think it's too common though - I haven't met anyone else.
- tracker1 12y agoNo kidding... It seems to me, outside of a small handful, most lawyers outside of politics aren't going to be raking it in without becoming partners... Paralegals are also cheaper still than new lawyers and can do most of the work. Not to mention my issues with the legal system becoming to convoluted for anyone... We start with a fairly simple guideline (constitution) and a common-law basis for a legal system beyond that, and it turns into the crap we have today... no bill going through congress should be thousands of pages.
- anigbrowl 12y agoThis makes me feel marginally better about dropping out from law school (correspondence version - the bottom of the barrel) after attending a large conference and realizing just how awful the odds were. It didn't cost me too much financially but I still feel depressed about it.
- debacle 12y agoIf it didn't cost you too much financially, chin up. Those are the best kind of life lessons.
- Rinum 12y agoIt's a sunk cost, ignore it.
- anigbrowl 12y agoIt's not the expense I regret, but not being in the legal academic environment. I really like law and I think I have a good grasp of it, but growing up abroad and not having an undergraduate degree means >95% of law schools are closed to me, to say nothing of the expense of a fulltime program.
- chime 12y agoDon't feel bad. I finished 1.5 years of MBA and dropped out when the university showed how little they cared about me. Originally I signed up to get an MS in Innovation Management (startups, new business tech., corporate finance for IT etc.) because my employer was keen on supporting my academic goals esp. if they coincided with my position as Director of IT. But one week before classes were to start, they dropped the entire program and "specially waived the MBA requirements" just for me and shoved me into their MBA program. After I spent 1.5 years taking MBA courses, they revived the MS IM degree but wouldn't let me transfer any credits from MBA program into it, even though most of the early classes were same, taught by the same teachers. It was then that I realized that the past few years of "leadership", "value proposition", and "customer-specific" drivel they had been feeding me was not something they actually cared about. They cared about enrollment, enrollment, and enrollment. I should know. The goal of the last class I took - Advanced Marketing - was to come up with surveys to find out what would increase enrollment into their MBA program. Initially I felt like a failure even considering dropping out because I was only 2 semesters away from getting my MBA. But then I realized life is too short to be wasting time doing what you don't want to do. Fortunately for me, my career turned out significantly better after dropping out because I decided to dedicate myself to making something I truly cared about and over time, that has paid off way more than an MBA would.
- ghaff 12y agoI've been reading about this for a while. In the eighties at least, among people I knew, law school seemed to be a pretty natural progression for those with liberal arts degrees looking for a relatively structured, well-paid, and fairly stable occupation. As a JD has become a far less reliable meal ticket (while also becoming a more expensive one), I can't say I'm surprised that the same demographic are no longer jumping into law school as the path of least resistance.
- tokenadult 12y agoTwo comments: an op-ed piece I saw in the Wall Street Journal the other day[1] made the point that the Department of Education's new regulations on for-profit institutions of higher education define levels of risk of student debt that would also give many "nonprofit" higher education institutions bad ratings. "We know this is true because if you applied the regulation to a law degree from George Washington University, a bachelor’s degree in hospitality administration from Stephen F. Austin State University or a bachelor’s in social work from University of Texas, the programs would all fail to meet the standard." Seeing the George Washington University Law School mentioned in that context made me go ouch, as that is not a completely slouchy law school, and I actually stayed there for a summer for one of my law school internships (I attended a state university law school) and later attended a student conference there. Even reasonably decent law schools are not a good financial risk these days for many students. My other comment is that the article kindly submitted here, which I've already submitted to my Facebook friends, makes the interesting point that dental school enrollments have fallen sharply since more and more public water supplies in the United States have fluoridation. People today have much healthier teeth than they had when I was growing up. Dentists, by this view, are true professionals, as they are even willing to advocate public health measures that help work dentists out of a job. I admire that. [1] "Making ‘Profit’ a Dirty Word in Higher Education" By Steve Gunderson Nov. 12, 2014 http://online.wsj.com/articles/steve-gunderson-making-profit-a-dirty-word-in-higher-education-1415837070 http://online.wsj.com/articles/steve-gunderson-making-profit...
- GFK_of_xmaspast 12y ago"Profit" should be a dirty word in higher education. Primary and secondary too.
- protomyth 12y agoWhy?
- spiritplumber 12y agoBecause then the goal changes from "raising your ranking by churning out well-prepared grads" to "making a quick buck". If the profit motive is present, making a slow buck will always lose to making a quick buck as soon as people who only wear management hats show up.
- graeme 12y agoI run an LSAT prep business. You'd be surprised how determined some undergrads are to go to law school, despite the objectively terrible math. They'll have a mediocre LSAT score, but say "School X will let me in!". School X is terrible. They have lousy employment prospects, and charge $50,000 a year. When you add miscellaneous fees and opportunity cost of not working, the law degree costs at least $250,000. And your school might close. But (some) students still want to do it, despite the stark reality. As best I can tell, they don't see alternative options. This group is shrinking however, which is why law school enrolments are in free fall. This chart from the LSAC shows a massive drop in LSATs administered. http://www.lsac.org/lsacresources/data/lsats-administered http://www.lsac.org/lsacresources/data/lsats-administered 2008-2009 was the high water mark: 171,514 LSATs. 2014-15 likely will be less than 100,000. Which is good. The industry's been in a bubble, and it needs to pop. But that means this is a VERY bad time to be going to law school unless you're extremely careful (and ideally have a guaranteed scholarship to a good school that won't close).
- ghaff 12y ago> As best I can tell, they don't see alternative options. I think that's pretty much it. I certainly knew people who had majored in "Classics" or whatever--at a good school--but didn't feel they had the ability/connections/whatever to parlay that into a decent paying career. And given that realization, law school was one of the obvious paths--and didn't tend to require full-time work experience as the better MBA programs did.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- untilHellbanned 12y ago> As best I can tell, they don't see alternative options. Soon this will trickle down to college. In many cases, you pay $250K for that too. In many, many fields, you can learn everything you need to know on the internet, and get the job you want by just hustling (often by impressing only a single person with influence in the field you want). I'm in biomedical sciences, have a Ph.D. and will be a professor at a very good school soon, but I don't give a crap about somebody's degrees. If this line of thinking is invading my world, then you better believe the rest of the economy is getting there too. (I also only got into MIT because I managed to impress one influential person). Getting ahead in life by going to college is a dying notion.
- lmg643 12y agoThis is really good news for society. Law is important but it is not productive. Also, hopefully this means fewer divorce attorneys.
- VieElm 12y ago> Also, hopefully this means fewer divorce attorneys. Because divorce is bad? Divorce can be a good thing, good marriages don't usually end in divorce, more than likely the bad marriages do. So then maybe because you think people going through a divorce shouldn't have good legal representation? What is your argument?
- x0x0 12y agoYes, most people shouldn't. Unless you've never seen two people piss away tens of thousands of dollars having legal tantrums, fully supported by their lawyers. Most people, particularly in CA, a community property state, should be able to get divorced for $500 or so. Of course, that requires that they be adult, and that no lawyers get paid (or encourage their clients to fight, all while paying them $x00/hour).
- VieElm 12y agoHow nice it must be to know what's best for people you know nothing about. I'm sure they love it when complete strangers with judgmental attitudes feel the need to interfere with their private lives.
- x0x0 12y agoCommunity property means person1 and person2 are going to get 1/2 of the assets earned during the marriage. You can get there cheaply or expensively. Lawyers get paid when you get there expensively -- and thus have an obvious incentive to inflame a negotiation between two aggrieved parties. I'm not sure why that makes me judgmental about their private lives.
- dragonwriter 12y ago
- lawschooler 12y agoThe law school naysayers paint with too broad a brush. Going to a top 15 or so school is still a golden ticket. I got a six figure job virtually handed to me for showing up and being good at school. Solidly 90% of my classmates did too. There are also massive opportunities for anyone with a bar card to earn a substantial living representing consumers, employees and the little guy in general (due to absurdly favorable fee-shifting rules) even if you can't get a job with a big firm. People who can't find these opportunities aren't looking very hard.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- DannyBee 12y ago" I got a six figure job virtually handed to me for showing up and being good at school. Solidly 90% of my classmates did too." These jobs won't last. The legal market as a whole is contracting. Lots of stuff currently given to new associates, like doc review, is seriously disappearing, etc. I went to a top 15 law school, and when I went (2005), there were plenty of 3rd year students who had no jobs. Just an administration willing to BS about it. "People who can't find these opportunities aren't looking very hard." This is also just BS. The idea that there are "enough jobs to go around" is ridiculously naive. Heck, you can find people with 10+ years of experience having to try to find legal work on craigslist en masse. There are areas of law that have contracted significantly and what appears to be permanently.
- doing_webrtc 12y agoI've worked at law firms, from boutique to solidly big law (AM Law top 10) and what you are saying is completely true and why I didn't pursue law school. Parent poster's world doesn't exist in reality. It's the reason why I'm doing software now.
- clay_to_n 12y agoThe big distinction here is "Top 15 Law School". Almost any law school that isn't up there is basically a scam. As the law market contracts, I'd imagine that the employment prospects of top-15 schools will shielded the longest - law firms that previously couldn't hire great lawyers will realize they can hire better new lawyers once it's harder for those lawyers to get a job. My brother is at NYU Law and has a starting job next year with a starting salary around 170k. From my understanding, kids at NYU are still not struggling (at all) to get decent jobs after law school.
- xwowsersx 12y agoI attended law school in NY starting in 2007. By the time I was looking for an internship at the end of my first year, the economy collapsed. As a result, it felt like the whole premise of law school (at least for most students), namely that you could get decent grades and would have a high paying job at some firm upon graduation, was completely shattered. This turned out to be completely true for the majority of people who attended at that time. Everyone was trying to find internships at the end of their first year, but there just weren't any to go around and people who had received offers in their third year were seeing them slip away. I remember thinking at the time that given the economy and the massive layoffs that were occurring that applications to my school would be going down, but what I saw was quite the contrary. Every semester, droves of new students packed the hallways. People seemed to be using the economic downturn and poor job market as an opportunity to "invest in the future" and go back to school. But I just couldn't understand how tuitions could stay propped up and I felt there had to be some correlation between the salaries/availability of jobs post law school and the high tuitions. Again, to my shock these facts just didn't seem to matter and it seemed to me that the whole law school thing was just a big ponzi scheme waiting to collapse. I know this is all anecdotal and my own experience, but maybe I was right and the big correction has finally come.
- graeme 12y agoThere was only a temporary surge after the crisis. People flooded into school thinking "school is a safe place to hide during a recession". This led to large crunches every subsequent year. Word has been spreading for the past four years. Applications have been down each year. We're hearing more now because it's finally reached a crunch point for schools. They've been trying to hold off closing by getting enough students and forcing other schools to close. It's musical chairs, and the music is now stopping.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- hkmurakami 12y ago>People flooded into school thinking "school is a safe place to hide during a recession". This led to large crunches every subsequent year. Another data point is NYC Business Schools. Lots of people in finance applied to, say, Columbia business school during the crisis, and thus around 2012 there was a huge plummet in applications there as the industry (a) started to recover a bit, and (b) it became clear that the rewards from a career on Wall Street would be much smaller than in previous decades.
- mherdeg 12y agoCould the Idaho State Supreme Court be doing Concordia University third-year law students a favor by not allowing them to take the bar exam? "Maybe it's better if you pick another profession", is that the message? (From http://www.nationallawjournal.com/id=1202677723753/Law-Schools-3Ls-Ineligible-To-Take-July-Bar-Exam?slreturn=20141102223803 http://www.nationallawjournal.com/id=1202677723753/Law-Schoo... — lede "The inaugural class of students at the Concordia University School of Law likely won’t be able to sit for the July 2015 bar exam because the new school has not yet been accredited by the American Bar Association.")
- ChuckMcM 12y agoI suspect this is not going to be isolated to Law School. The math is that tuitions have risen so far for so long that at 'premier' schools you don't get nearly the value you should. That said, it opens up the opportunity for new schools with a different model in mind. And one thing we've seen in Tech has been that when the going gets desperate, it also gets creative. I don't think the answer is going to be MOOCs but I also don't think the ivory tower model of old will survive. Something in the middle, perhaps 2 years of general education requirements online and 2 years of training in your major on campus. Half the cost and the education is just as useful. Time will tell.
- Rinum 12y agoThe same will be said for Pharmacy in the near future.
- Chevalier 12y agoWhen your position could have been automated thirty years ago by vending machines... yeah, pharmacists are in trouble. Some chains are moving to a call-in model, where your medicine is provided through cheap labor (and eventually machines) -- then if you have any questions, which is the ostensible purpose of a pharmacist, you can Skype with a pharmacist at a call center. Such a model is probably fairly miserable for the pharmacist, but it seems like the obvious solution for automating the work while still complying with (what I can only assume was intended as) protectionist regulation.
- eropple 12y agoYou're conflating pharmacy technicians with pharmacists. There are soft skills involved; it's remarkably hard to automate the person who has to know the weird interactions with drugs that different physicians prescribe--and how they interact with the over-the-counter, off-label, or just plain illegal stuff that their customers are taking. Pharmacists keep people alive when their physicians try (with the best of intentions, mind) to kill them.
- Chevalier 12y agoThat doesn't sound right to me. Humans are better than machines at the memorization and computation of a database that lists every drug in existence and the consequences of all possible combinations thereof? Pharmacists may be able to give a soft personal touch when interacting with patients, but the same could be said about travel agents, retail clerks, or taxi drivers. Or lawyers, for that matter. Still, I can't see why six-figure salary pharmacists are essential to vend pills.
- atlbeer 12y agoIn the US; legal requirements to have a pharmacists dispense controlled substances.
- brogrammer90 12y agoCoding bootcamps are full to brim with newly minted JDs.
- tricolon 12y agoCould you cite a source, or at least provide an anecdote?
- brogrammer90 12y agohttp://www.top-law-schools.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=234059&start=825 http://www.top-law-schools.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=23... http://www.top-law-schools.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=203870 http://www.top-law-schools.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=20... http://www.top-law-schools.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=208657 http://www.top-law-schools.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=20...
- acmiller 12y agoIndeed--people with rigorous analytical skills, weak math backgrounds, and limited job prospects seem the ideal market for code camps.
- pyrrhotech 12y agoMakes me smile. Keep the small wins against the bullshit jobs coming. A more productive society, may our future be! Hopefully next up to bat is hedge fund jobs and hedge funds themselves.
- boulos 12y agoThe referenced nytimes article (http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2014/12/01/law-school-becomes-buyers-market-as-competition-for-best-students-increases/ http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2014/12/01/law-school-becomes-bu...) is more informative. (Also the submission title is a bit link-baity and doesn't even match the Slate headline). Edit: ahh the submission matches the title tag but not the in-body headline. My mistake.
- pain 12y agoSo legal code gets replaced by program code.