24 ms·
Once Celebrated in Russia, Programmer Pavel Durov Chooses Exile
- myth_drannon 12y agoLife is too short to be a revolutionary hero. Be a law abiding citizen and do what Zuckenberg,Page and other American CEOs did, quietly give control control over our privacy to the government. Social networks are too important for mass surveillance. Russians are too optimistic because only 20 years ago they had an attempt of a complete governance system change.
- meowface 12y agoFalse dichotomy. You can permit law enforcement to make warranted requests against specific users or groups while still not allowing them access to all the data. You don't have to choose between "revolutionary hero" and "let the government do whatever they want with your company and your users", at least not in North America. In a country like Russia it may be different.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Htsthbjig 12y ago"You can permit law enforcement to make warranted requests against specific users or groups while still not allowing them access to all the data." Can you? With the Patriot Act? The fact is that the US gobertment can talk to any worker of any company of the US and blackmail her into doing whatever they want. If this person tells anybody, he goes to jail. "You don't have to choose between "revolutionary hero" and "let the government do whatever they want with your company and your users", at least not in North America. In a country like Russia it may be different." You mean like Lavabit?: https://lavabit.com/ https://lavabit.com/
- Karunamon 12y agoAs much as i admire Levison, at least part of that problem was his own making, namely by being a dick to the agents and charging rates for the work that is way too high. It is possible to disagree with police without being outright antagonistic to them.
- desdiv 12y ago...and charging rates for the work that is way too high. Funny, when I read about the $3500 part I was surprised at how little he asked for. My impression from various HN threads[0][1] is that someone of Levison's caliber could easily fetch $200 per hour. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5769348 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5769348 [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=182369 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=182369
- skylan_q 12y agoI was reading the article with Zuck in place of Pavel. I don't think any westerner would be courageous enough to do what Pavel did. But this falls into the narrative that "Russia bad, America good". How do you think the Russian media spins stories about Facebook's and Google's co-operation with US intelligence?
- known 12y ago"The reasonable man adapts himself to the world; the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself. Therefore all progress depends on the unreasonable man." --George Bernard Shaw
- ajuc 12y ago> 67 years ago Stalin defended from Hitler his right to suppress Soviet people Great quote.
- osipov 12y agoA very naive view targeted at equally naive Western audiences. Repression in USSR after WW2 was negligible compared to 1930s.
- asgard1024 12y agoIt wasn't negligible in my country (Czechoslovakia), where the USSR was the model. I think almost everybody felt relief when Stalin (and Gottwald) died. Maybe Stalin didn't oppress people much after the war, but he still got the _right_ to do so, and the Durov's sentence is 100% correct.
- osipov 12y agoAll governments oppress people. The real issue is to what extent they do so and what fraction of the people consider themselves oppressed. Unfortunately the frontlines after WW2 where redrawn and Czechoslovakia was in the unenviable position of having to defend the Warsaw Pact while its population wasn't fully supportive of this position. Those who opposed (anti-Stalinists) were oppressed. As a mirror image, consider Greece where pro-Stalinist communists were oppressed in 50s and 60s.
- stefantalpalaru 12y agoEducate yourself, comrade: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_repression_in_the_Soviet_Union#Genocide.2C_ethnic_cleansing.2C_and_population_transfers http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_repression_in_the_Sov...
- jpatokal 12y agoTrue enough, but that doesn't invalidate the quote, since it was still Stalin at the helm. There were still an estimated 1.7 million people in the camps after WW2, many of them Soviet POWs. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gulag#mediaviewer/File:Gulag_Prisoner_Stats_1934-1953.PNG http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gulag#mediaviewer/File:Gulag_Pr...
- Evgeny 12y agoA few weeks later, he and other VKontakte executives folded 5000-ruble notes — worth about $155 at the time — into paper airplanes and threw them out an office window, sparking a fight in the street below. I'm wondering if that can be qualified as "mean". Doesn't look like a nice thing to do. I also can't see what was the motivation other than "Look, I'm rich".
- osipov 12y agoBoth Zuck and Durov were approached by secret services by their respective countries. Zuck caved in and gave up Facebook information to NSA. Durov decided to fight and ended up exiled.
- spacefight 12y ago[citation needed]
- ivanca 12y agoFacebook is a gift to intelligence agencies: http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/the-switch/wp/2014/10/23/snowden-filmmaker-laura-poitras-facebook-is-a-gift-to-intelligence-agencies/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/the-switch/wp/2014/10/23...
- michaelhealy 12y agoI believe this was after a VK executive received a bonus from the company and someone had made a joke along the lines of "look you've made it". The employee responded to say that money wasn't his motivation. Instead, it was the idea of creating and building stuff. To prove his point, he threw the bonus money out of the window in paper planes. This could imply that money really wasn't/isn't the motivation. Maybe this was slightly foolish given the media's/public interpretation. I don't think this act had a "mean" intention.
- dreamweapon 12y agoI don't think this act had a "mean" intention. It certainly wasn't "mean". But given the hardships many people in Russia (who don't happen to be petrochemical, banking, and/or internet oligarchs) face, it went well beyond "slightly foolish."
- michaelhealy 12y agoPavel seems to be a great person, building a gift to society & mankind. He puts the users/people before himself, stands behind their rights and believes in strong ideals such as freedom of speech and privacy. I don't think you can say the same about many other internet companies/services. If you look at his previous company VK. It is by far a superior experience to Facebook, given how intuitive, fast and sleek it is. Images load 3 times as fast and has many features which FB does not have. I use daily to keep in touch with my friends in Belarus, Ukraine and Russian. I only wish more of my friends used it. He has an incredible eye for design and product. When people refer to VK being a clone of Facebook. This is innovation. Did Facebook invent the idea of Social Networking? It must be extremely annoying to be constantly referred to as "Russia’s Mark Zuckerberg" and having VK being constantly compared to FB. Here he has had a brilliant opportunity for a fresh start, freedom to create something better than before and I'm sure he will take advantage of it. As Steve Jobs put it. "Getting fired from Apple was the best thing that could have ever happened to me. The heaviness of being successful was replaced by the lightness of being a beginner again, less sure about everything. It freed me to enter one of the most creative periods of my life." Steve Jobs, 2005" Everyone should look forward for what is to come with Telegram. There is some really great technological innovations going on. They've invented a new protocol(https://core.telegram.org/techfaq https://core.telegram.org/techfaq) and have a great API to utilise this technology(https://core.telegram.org/ https://core.telegram.org/). I'm sure you'll like it. Check it out: http://www.telegram.org http://www.telegram.org
- aikah 12y ago> It is by far a superior experience to Facebook, given how intuitive, fast and sleek it is. It's riddled with childporn and sick/illegal stuff like that. Is that's your definition of "superior experience"? It's a crappy Facebook clone,always has been and always will.
- colinbartlett 12y agoIf VK is riddled with "childporn and sick/illegal stuff", I have never come across it. One could say the same about the internet in general, but that hasn't stopped you or I from using it.
- valar_m 12y agoDuring the standoff with the SWAT team, which took place soon after, he wouldn’t answer the door. They went home after an hour. Wait, what? Is that what police in Russia normally do? This would never, ever happen in the United States. LAPD actually even has a "Wrong Doors Unit" which goes around repairing broken down doors when the cops raid the wrong address.[0] [0] http://www.dailynews.com/20080316/repairs-help-rebuild-lapds-image-when-wrong-door-broken-down http://www.dailynews.com/20080316/repairs-help-rebuild-lapds...
- Energy1 12y agoIs there one-to-one correspondence between the damage done and repair job? How about the emotional distress?
- guard-of-terra 12y agoIn Russia cops can't enter your home unless they suspect some crime to be carried right this moment or have a court order. You have to open door for them. However I'm not a lawyer and that might not be valid anymore.
- gcb0 12y agomuch like the US law from some.... wow a decade ago now. has it been that long?
- valar_m 12y agoI should have been more clear -- The article doesn't say, but I was assuming that the SWAT team was there to execute a search warrant. Perhaps they did not and that's why they didn't force entry, but the SWAT team showing up without a search warrant makes even less sense to me.
- tlear 12y agoIt was a threat, they were letting him know that his time in Russia was coming to an end. He took the hint and bailed before he got into an "accident"
- moxie 12y agoThere's been a lot of controversy over the Telegram encryption protocol. Any cryptographer that looks at it cringes, but Telegram has deep pockets and has done a decent job building hype. Beyond doubts with the protocol itself, I think the more important consideration is that most people never use it. Telegram is not encrypted by default. Users have to create a special "secret chat" with contacts that is ephemeral, and some Telegram clients don't even support that mode. Last I checked, there was no way to have group "secret chats" in any client at all. The result is a situation where many users seem to think that Telegram is somehow secure by default, when it definitely isn't. Telegram even stores plaintext copies of everyone's entire message history on the server for multi-device sync. I think what Telegram is doing right now is dangerous, and potentially another Lavabit in the making. I'd like to see them incorporate a modern end to end encryption protocol, and enable it by default. To be transparent, I work on TextSecure and am involved with the WhatsApp end-to-end encryption project.
- desireco42 12y agoThank you for bringing this up, I was under impression telegram would be secure by default.
- darkhorn 12y agoThe communication with the server is encrypted, if you use the official apps. If you use secret chat they are not stored as plain text on the servers and you can make them auto destroy. Also you can delete your chat history. But it is better than WhatsApp because it is not part of governmental control.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- vertex-four 12y ago> it is not part of governmental control Isn't that a pretty dangerous assertion in itself? It's a private company running private servers that you have no control over and no ability to tell whether or not an external entity has accessed your data.
- eklavya 12y agoI think people ignore one very important aspect of Telegram which is privacy. All other chat apps just want all my private data. There is no privacy at all, I feel almost naked. After coming to know about Telegram I couldn't be happier. I don't care if the encryption in strong or not, at last I have a chat app which many people use and isn't a total privacy nightmare.
- eklavya 12y agoDownvote all you want but please share your perspective also.
- Karunamon 12y agoThat's just it - there is no privacy. You've got a client which stores plaintext messages server side, just waiting to be broken into by (hackers/government agents/kiddies). The messages are being sent unencrypted unless you enable the "secure" (it really isn't) mode anyways, so we can also add "people who can sniff your traffic" to the list of adversaries. That's pretty much the polar opposite of "private".
- knivets 12y ago> "secure" (it really isn't) There was a contest held by Pavel, with $200k prize who will break this "weak security". No one succeeded.
- incanus77 12y agoI met and talked with Pavel last year in St. Petersburg at the VK office and I found him very curious, humble, and quiet. I enjoyed it a lot and I appreciate his sense of humor. In fact he showed me their conference room, which is decorated like a medieval torture chamber: http://tinyurl.com/nm7pqt2 http://tinyurl.com/nm7pqt2 We didn't get into the details but I appreciate that he didn't take the standard approach to plain old conference rooms.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- teddyh 12y agoYou broke the formatting on this page.
- prostoalex 12y agoNot sure if this was meant as a sarcasm, but quirky conference room design (or names, or names) are the new standard in corporate spaces http://www.metropolismag.com/December-2013/Rooms-with-a-View/ http://www.metropolismag.com/December-2013/Rooms-with-a-View... http://fortune.com/2014/03/27/see-you-at-the-4-oclock-standup-in-darth-jager/ http://fortune.com/2014/03/27/see-you-at-the-4-oclock-standu... https://blog.theidealists.com/rad-spaces/rad-spaces-conference-rooms-that-arent-boring/ https://blog.theidealists.com/rad-spaces/rad-spaces-conferen... http://indohomedesign.net/great-googles-office-in-pittsburgh-usa/ http://indohomedesign.net/great-googles-office-in-pittsburgh... You'd be hard-pressed to go around Valley and find a company that does not feature an incredibly inventive conference space. Even IBM's Almaden location has some.
- ghostface 12y agoWhat smart phone chat apps are considered safe? moxie mentioned TextSecure. Any other notable examples?
- tptacek 12y agoAfter TextSecure, I'd consider the OTR applications.