7 ms·
Is Uber’s rider database a sitting duck for hackers?
- qrush 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headlines http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headlines
- ConfuciusSay 12y agoExactly. Not to mention, this type of reasoning could be applied to almost any technology company. Every company is theoretically an attractive target for personal information.
- friggeri 12y agoCorollary: Any headline which ends in a question mark will lead to someone commenting with a reference to Betteridge's law of headlines.
- danso 12y agoThe operational security and access control at Uber doesn't inspire confidence...if the data is so easily accessible from the inside to be used for whatever purpose, then it's only a matter of time before an employee with a "12345" password gets phished. The OP didn't mention the problem of user-ratings being exposed through the mobile site (https://medium.com/@aaln/how-to-find-your-uber-passenger-rating-4aa1d9cc927f https://medium.com/@aaln/how-to-find-your-uber-passenger-rat...)...even if that data isn't such a big deal, the fact that it was just left floating out there, secured via obscurity, doesn't speak well for Uber's precautionary mindset.
- exelius 12y agoI would be less concerned about hackers than old-school espionage. That's actually my biggest concern with large-scale data collection in general: if the US government requires data to be collected, that means mechanisms exist within private enterprise to collect and share the data. Hostile state actors can then use classic espionage tactics (false flag ops, social engineering, romance scams, etc.) to infiltrate those organizations and gather the data themselves because it's already being collected and shared in an aggregated manner. I guarantee there are state intelligence agencies (both US and non-US) with "assets" at Uber with access to this information. This is bread and butter espionage - plant or recruit employees at private companies with access to the information you need.
- blfr 12y agoTheoretically, maybe. But completely practically, that info is available for cabs today, for example in NYC[1]. A determined person can even figure out if you tipped[2]. All that without doing anything illegal. It's just a matter of matching pick-up locations and timestamps to people of interest. Which should be easy in case of public officials and companies with known headquarters. [1] http://www.andresmh.com/nyctaxitrips/ http://www.andresmh.com/nyctaxitrips/ [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7896537 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7896537
- danso 12y agoNo. This is not even remotely comparable. The Uber data would presumably contain identities and histories. The taxi cab data does not. And it is not simply "a matter of matching pick-up locations and timestamps to people of interest"...the only way to do that would be to actively surveil those people for a non-significant amount of time, and that's assuming they are taking the taxi on a regular basis...predicting the times they've taken one-off meetings would be futile. Another big difference: taxi destination is only in lat/lng. For Uber data, it's possible that much of the data is exact address (or at least corner) of the destination...because it's just easier to enter it in the address you want as a user rather than obfuscate it (obviously, people trying to cover their tracks would try to obfuscate, but why would the use Uber in the first place if they were that self-conscious?)
- imgabe 12y agoIs it me or are these alarmist articles are always short on detail as to what the actual threat is? > Wouldn’t detailed data on such rides be handy for a foreign power eager to map the relationships among various Washington players? It could potentially show both a history of contact and real-time movements as meetings are convening. And then what? Let's say China knows that Senator A and Senator B both took an Uber to the same restaurant at the same time. What do they do with that information? It doesn't tell them what, if anything was discussed. Maybe they didn't talk politics at all. Maybe they had a big fight and swore never to speak to each other again. Who knows? How does the ride information help? I'm hardly an expert on espionage, but I don't see what advantage this gives anyone.
- SilasX 12y agoSenators use Uber?
- gtCameron 12y agoFrom the article - "To take just one possible example, Uber has become particularly popular among the political class in Washington. During this year’s mid-term Congressional campaigns, Uber accounted for more than 60 percent of rides costing less than $100, according to Hamilton Place Strategies, which culled records from Federal Election Commission reports."
- munin 12y agowell, this is how textbook blackmail starts. you can probably compute an inverse "rides of glory" measure and detect people with something to hide, make a stab at what it is, approach them, and pressure them, without ever leaving the safety of your home. you could apply this to everyone. that doesn't sound bad? or do you think that people should just not have anything to hide...
- imgabe 12y agoIt might be a starting point for blackmail, but if someone is doing something blackmailable then that's a separate problem. They're a liability and I'm sure far more effective means at finding such vulnerabilities are already being employed. They're going to need something more concrete than ride data to effectively blackmail someone, anyway. "Give us the launch codes or we'll release that you took an Uber to this address!" isn't going to cut it, I think.
- brandonmenc 12y agoAt this point, these anti-Uber articles constitute nothing more than a smear campaign - and a bad one, at that. Every company sits on troves of data re: your personal habits and comings and goings - and they all get hacked, all the time. Even ones run by the "grown ups" that - according to the narrative - Uber so desperately needs if they ever want to be seen as a member of decent society.
- untog 12y agoAs the article states, Uber is unique in a few ones. One: all signs point to employees being given unfettered access to all user data. That's A Bad Thing.
- bengali3 12y agoAs highlighted by the last line of the article “Most people,” Lewis said, “have really bad operational security.” I don't think the media is going to stop targeting Uber for a while... I am always happy when the topic of security and data-privacy is discussed in the broader media. I wish there was an easy 'goto' option for agile/startup/lean/hacker teams with little time for security policies are focused on speed so early on. "Regulation--SOX, HIPAA, GLBA, the credit-card industry's PCI, the various disclosure laws, the European Data Protection Act, whatever--has been the best stick the industry has found to beat companies over the head with. And it works. Regulation forces companies to take security more seriously, and sells more products and services." - Bruce Schneier[1] [1] https://www.schneier.com/news/archives/2008/01/bruce_schneier_refle.html https://www.schneier.com/news/archives/2008/01/bruce_schneie...
- GrinningFool 12y agoWow. I've been taking a break from most computer stuff over the last week or so. What'd Uber do that they're now getting targeted with speculative smear pieces?
- danso 12y agoOne of Uber's exec was mouthing off against tech reporters at what he thought was an off-the-record dinner: http://www.buzzfeed.com/bensmith/uber-executive-suggests-digging-up-dirt-on-journalists http://www.buzzfeed.com/bensmith/uber-executive-suggests-dig... Obviously, that kind of alleged discussion is not going to win the hearts of the journalistic class, but Uber's problem is that it had a reported history of using user data for unexpected purposes, like to use the God View as decoration at a company party. One of the key points in the OP that I hadn't seen before is an anonymous Uber interviewee who claimed that he/she had total access to the Uber customer database as part of the interview...and for hours after the interview. I agree with some people here, that this seems like an overblown story because Uber isn't any more an attractive data center than Google/Facebook/Github/etc...the problem is that what we know of how Uber has disseminated the data within the company indicates an almost certain lack of prioritization of access control. And many of the employees at Uber being human, it's only a matter of time before someone gets phished and something like an attachable Excel file of intranet-passwords is found (or other manifestation of sloppy IT-security practices/work-arounds). And I'd say Uber deserves a little additional scrutiny...its data may not be as valuable as Google or Facebook's, but it could very well have the lowest focus on operational-security compared to companies in its tier of valuations.
- GrinningFool 12y agoVery interesting, thanks for replying and the link. While I agree that given the nature of the data they capture, it makes sense that they receive a little additional scrutiny -- this more feels like someone had the idea of how the data could be misused, then discussed the idea with a various security folks who (unsurprisingly) said, "Well.. yeah, now that you mention it, this COULD be a problem." In other words, feels like the writer was making the news here and not reporting it. And to an extent that's legitimate. I question the need to approach it in this way though - making a one-sided story of it instead of working with Uber to see if they're aware of this as a potential issue, determining what steps they're taking to prevent it, etc... As far as how Uber is using the data they've acquired - it seems they've hit that painful point that every long-term startup does. They've evolved past the point of a small group of folks with an idea, and need to adjust to a new reality. That includes reining in some of their "ooh, pretty data! let's play with it!" impulses, because of the privacy implications and because of the implicit trust their users place in them. I would expect a couple of high profile hires and some policy statements to be forthcoming as they mature.
- berberous 12y agoDoes Uber disclose their data retention policies? I don't see any need for them to retain my trip history on a non-anonymized basis, other than a short lookback period for driver and date/time for purposes of finding lost items. And I would feel better knowing that they publicly state as much.
- marknutter 12y agoThis is somewhat off topic, but these kinds of headlines should be auto-flagged from every news aggregator site on the web. Asking a question which seems to incriminate its subject is click-baity at best and unethical at worst. Either make the claim or not and back it up in the article. Don't just throw bullshit questions into your headline. For example: "Is the Washington Post the Most Unethical Publication in the Nation?"
- kej 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge's_law_of_headlines http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge's_law_of_headlines
- flycaliguy 12y agoMaybe click baity, but it is a serious question which is being asked. Not out of the blue but after a pretty shocking revelation of the unnecessary information they are gathering. Opening up innocent people to hacking is one of the most important reasons that this new school of data gathering is being discussed. Is it unethical when it appears as if the answer is almost certinly "YES!"? edit: I'm specifically thinking of Uber gathering which customers have phones with vulnerabilities.
- marknutter 12y agoIf the answer is "Yes" then they should put it in the fucking headline.
- tlrobinson 12y ago"Is [technology company's] database a sitting duck for hackers?"