3 ms·
Yes, as you say all educational uses are not "fair use" in USA (from my understanding of the USC as a non-expert non-USA'ian) - this is unlicensed derivative us
by pbhjpbhj 12y ago
Yes, as you say all educational uses are not "fair use" in USA (from my understanding of the USC as a non-expert non-USA'ian) - this is unlicensed derivative use of copyright works AFAICT. They're not even that derivative, the example I looked at seemed to be pretty much just an recut version of the show (without credits and such of course).
If someone ripped the site and added an extra line of comment to each page would the authors of that site consider it copying? The site is a very thin wrapper on the content IMO, like copying a book, cutting out the foreword and adding a new dust-jacket.
Trademarks: You don't need actual confusion to be infringing a registered trademark in USA. Even when there is definitely no actual confusion you can still "infringe" a mark, cf Trademark Dilution, 15 USC 1125(c).
- pbhjpbhj 12y ago[If downvoters can cite USC to show any factual errors that would be helpful. If you just disagree that this use, eg feel this should be allowed use, it helps to say that too.]
- Cushman 12y agoI didn't (and can't) downvote you, but if I had to guess it's because your comment didn't add much content, but has a very negative tone. HN likes to see commenters being constructive, not just correcting. (And keep in mind that things you write on the internet generally read as more argumentative than you intend them.)