8 ms·
Detroit gentrifiers face daunting task buying $500 homes evicting poor residents
- xpaulbettsx 12y agoIf there was anything worth starting a KickStarter for, it would be to raise money to buy as many of these homes as possible, and give the deeds outright to the people who already live there. That'd be a really great thing.
- jpetersonmn 12y agoAccording to that article a lot of these people already have paid off the mortgage and have the deeds to the house. It's that they can't keep up with the taxes. If you raised money to pay their back taxes, what would they do the following year? This kind of stuff really is sad, there has to be some solution to not kicking people that have lived in these houses for 30+ years because they can't afford the taxes.
- jMyles 12y agoOne of the first times I've seen that property tax really does read like serfdom.
- Scramblejams 12y agoProperty tax is really onerous for those who own their houses but fall on hard times. Its implementation can be terribly unfair, because it essentially says that you don't really own all of your property. You own most of it, but if you don't kick that little bit up every year, then you're out on your duff and what you get back is subject to the whims of the auction bidders. That's a troubling implication for me. I'm a big fan of first sale doctrine. If you bought it, it should be yours. I'm deeply uncomfortable with the notion that you must always pay rent to the government on something you ostensibly own, or you get the boot. There are so many ways this could be addressed. Property taxes could be eliminated and other taxes raised for a revenue neutral solution. Or below a certain property value, the tax levied could be zero. Lots of ways to fix this.
- angersock 12y agoI think it's even more screwed up than that, right? One pays property taxes in order to get the benefits of the people they pay taxes to. It looks like the local and state government have utterly failed to provide the policing, schooling, or other tangible benefits associated with taxes. There is literally no incentive to abide by that part of the social contract other than the vague fear that they'll be called in one day or forcibly evicted. The state is acting in bad faith.
- pkaye 12y agoThat is what we did in California. We started capping the rate of growth of property taxes. Now old people and companies pay little property taxes since they bought the property long ago. Meanwhile the young people usually end up paying the bulk of the property taxes (along with sky high mortgages.)
- AnthonyMouse 12y ago> Property taxes could be eliminated and other taxes raised for a revenue neutral solution. The perfect solution for this is to eliminate both property tax and the mortgage interest tax deduction and let them cancel each other. For most people it makes no difference, but we stop kicking little old ladies out of the homes they own just because they can no longer afford the property taxes.
- icebraining 12y agoWould they cancel each other? In value, I mean? Seems like the property tax would cover much more than mortgaged houses.
- AnthonyMouse 12y agoThe numbers depend on several variables, but they seem to be in the same ballpark. The amount people owe on their mortgages is generally in the neighborhood of the assessed value of their homes. People may make some headway into actually paying off the mortgage, but the tax deduction makes that financially unattractive (better to pay off all other debt before the mortgage because the interest rate is lower and the interest is tax deductible) and housing crisis notwithstanding the assessed value is generally lower than what people pay for houses to begin with. So you're really comparing tax rates against approximately the same base. Then you only need to know the mil rate, the marginal income tax rate and the loan interest rate. Plug in typical numbers and they end up within an order of magnitude of each other one way or the other (e.g. somewhere around 2%). Unless your point is that property tax applies to more than single family homes, but there is no reason we have to eliminate property tax for e.g. commercial property.
- icebraining 12y agoThis kind of stuff really is sad, there has to be some solution to not kicking people that have lived in these houses for 30+ years because they can't afford the taxes. There is, the article points it out: Owners can buy their homes back with debts cleared at auction for $500 as a solution of last resort. The problem doesn't seem to be the lack of a solution, but knowledge that it exists and what they have to do to benefit from it.
- corysama 12y agoSo, the solution is: Don't pay your taxes. Wait for your house to go to auction. Hope no one buys it. Pay $500 to effectively erase your three year tax debt. Repeat. That apparently currently works. It's a clear market signal to the government that it has no alternative but to put up with you not paying your taxes. But, I expect if it became widespread, the tax man would see it as a loophole to be closed.
- AnthonyMouse 12y agoThere is also clearly something fishy going on there. The only way you get to pay $500 is if no one else offers to pay more than that, i.e. the market value of the house is only ~$500. For a dilapidated house in a bad neighborhood that is entirely possible, but then why are the taxes on such a low value piece of real estate so high that the occupant can't afford them?
- Scramblejams 12y agoAgreed. Other government housing auctions have been recently documented in the press as bearing signs of bidder collusion. A closer look here would be welcome.
- jpetersonmn 12y agoYes, but it's an auction, no guarantee that the place is going to go for less than the taxes owed, let alone $500.
- Scramblejams 12y ago
- nthj 12y ago> If you raised money to pay their back taxes, what would they do the following year? Detroit property tax rates are something like 3% per year. If I own the house outright, shouldn't I get a mortgage on the house to pay the property taxes, rather than lose the entire house? If I was a banker in the Detroit area I'd be all over this—with a little bit of marketing I could offer to “save your house from the tax man”, take care of all the paperwork, and charge the highest interest rate that still let me sleep at night. (People could shop around, but if you're going to shop around for a better interest rate, you're probably of the type that isn't about to lose your paid-off home over a bill for 10% of the total value.)
- icebraining 12y agoWhy? These houses are getting foreclosured due to owed taxes. If they got the deed back, they'd just get foreclosured again to pay the rest, no?
- corysama 12y agoI agree that throwing money into tax auctions every three years is a band-aid. However, there is certainly an 8-figure opportunity here for whoever can come up with a more permanent solution. Perhaps instead of paying $500 each to boot out poor grandmas to the streets, some low-income apartments could be built for those grandmas based on the expected values of flipping their houses and a govt tax break promise.
- tedunangst 12y agoThe upside for a flipped home in Detroit is about zero. There's a reason these homes are (barely) selling for $500. And buying a home for that and booting granny is a lot cheaper than building granny a new apartment. Not sure where the eight figure upside is going to come from.
- klous 12y agoWell my friend raised over $6,000 on IndieGoGo [1] to buy homes at the foreclosure auctions to give to the families who live in them. There's a potluck tomorrow with all the families and funders to celebrate the success. I could see many more of this type of effort in Detroit being successful. [1] https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/the-tricycle-collective https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/the-tricycle-collective
- teacup50 12y agoThis is wonderful. I would invest in something that took it a step further; turn it into self-sustaining non-profit or co-op that's focused on keeping people in their homes and able to repay the costs of repurchasing them.
- justin_vanw 12y agoWhy would that be in any way good? If someone can't manage to pull together $500 to buy the house they already live in, they also can't pull together $500 to fix anything that breaks in the house. Giving these houses to the people living in them is EXACTLY the same as encouraging people to live in houses that we know are not going to be maintained, and have them evicted in a few years, leaving the city with the cost of condemning and tearing down the house.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- angersock 12y agoNah, we've got the police and military on our side. Oh, and food and running water and communication networks and healthcare. We're prepared for class warfare--they're not. :|
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- BrainInAJar 12y agoI interpreted it as he bought $14,000 worth of debt and sold it to her for $7000, so he halved her tax bill
- nthj 12y agoCertainly his time and capital are worth something. He's probably out of pocket for at least a few lawyer fees. And if he intended to live there, he's now set back 2-3 months rent while he finds another permanent solution. All in all, still seems really generous to me.
- jedberg 12y agoOk wait. So the guy paid $3500 to clear $14,000 in back taxes, right? Then the person who owed the taxes paid him $7000. Why couldn't the owner just pay the city $3500? Or even the $7,00 she paid to the other guy? Why is the city willing to take $3500 from a random person but not the owner?
- tedunangst 12y agoWhy is the owner willing to simply not pay their taxes? (We're missing a lot from the story.)
- jedberg 12y agoI'm assuming they don't have the $14K, but have $7K.
- tedunangst 12y agoWhich they could have taken to the auction. Who knows? Maybe they could have paid it off for only $5k.
- mcgarveymr 12y ago"One of the things linking them: lack of information. Low-income homeowners are eligible for tax exemptions. While many residents would meet the requirements, they must file requests before their taxes are due, neither of which are readily known pieces of information, Mullane says. Owners can buy their homes back with debts cleared at auction for $500 as a solution of last resort." It seems the problem is a lack of communication. It seems they don't know how much trouble they are in until they receive the foreclosure notice. The homeowner is welcome to bid on their house at auction, but if they are outbid then they are out of luck. From the city's point of view it is better to try to get as much money back on the debt by auctioning the house instead of trying to settle at some arranged value with the debtor, which may be less than what they could get from two people trying to outbid one another. For example at the end of the article the debtor could only budget $1,400 for repurchasing his home, but he was outbid at $3,000.
- voidlogic 12y agoIf the current residents can't afford the property taxes, they need to relocate. On a personal level is very unfair, if its unfair at a societal level, we can debate. But the reality still stands- If you can't pay your property taxes, you need to move. It is a financial imperative. For Detroit in general, these pejoratively described "gentrifiers" could be the best thing to happen in a long time. What kind of failing community would not welcome an influx of affluent skilled workers--- A boom of these kind of folks could even ignite the local services industry and provide jobs for the remaining lower skill workers. I feel for these people on a personal level, I really do. But I don't see how ignoring economic realities is going to help them or their community long term.
- pond_lilly 12y agoWhat is up today with HN? I have been extremely turned off by insensitive, cruel and plain nasty comments on several threads. Why so much cruelty towards fellow humans, fellow Americans? Do you realize that your "I am fine, and to hell with ya' all" attitude is like cutting the branch you sit on? You cannot live, prosper and flourish in a society ridden with cruelty, nastiness, lack of empathy and extreme forms of egoism.
- eli_gottlieb 12y ago>On a personal level is very unfair, if its unfair at a societal level, we can debate. This has already been debated many times. The right answer is: property taxes on improvements are a malign disincentive, but property taxes on location/land value are a beneficial incentive for greater development. Detroit's location value is basically zero.
- raverbashing 12y agoAlso on occupation. Low property taxes are an incentive to hoard properties.
- thephyber 12y ago> If you can't pay your property taxes, you need to move. I would argue you are talking in the wrong tense. Detroit has suffered from resident and employer flight for 40 years. About A MILLION people took your advice before you gave it. It has caused a tremendous downward pressure on property values and gutted employee mobility. Those people that are currently living in Detroit who can't or can just barely pay their property taxes are unlikely to be able to afford to leave and/or probably have too much hope / faith / pride (the regular irrational actors) to face the hard reality. I would bet that a lower intelligence and/or education level is likely to correlate highly with people who stick around despite the city crumbling around them. Also, if residents can't afford to pay $500 to buy their own house at county auction, they also can't afford to move and start new somewhere else. Even if they could manage to leave before foreclosure, that does not absolve them of their obligation to pay property taxes on a property they still own and likely can't sell. People that can't afford property tax bills likely also have bad credit, which is another impediment to being able to afford a move, rent / buy a new place elsewhere, and even being able to apply for a new job. I would argue that people who can't pay this month's bills don't worry about "long term". That's why there are more short term ("PayDay") loan centers than there are McDonald's restaurants nationwide. Not trying to absolve them of their bad economic sense, just pointing out some likely reasons they haven't already moved elsewhere.
- raverbashing 12y agoThat's what "having money" (ok, 500 bucks) but no sense of business entails. Negotiate a rent. You can have a grace period, a rent that starts small and increases later. But then again it's people that have limited financial means
- johnohara 12y agoIt's obvious in many cities, not just Detroit, that government has not been able to hold up its end of the property tax agreement by providing and properly maintaining essential services such as water, streets, sewers, schools, fire and personal protection, and countless other "promises". Why should homeowners lose their homes to non-payment if their streets are falling apart, their schools are sub-par, their personal safety is non-existent, their water pipes are 100 years old, and their government declares bankruptcy? Selling off in tax delinquency court, homes with deeds that are free and clear, is an insult worthy of sustained organized protest. The fact that it doesn't happen is remarkable.
- bluedino 12y agoNot to mention the insane amounts that municipalities are paying towards the massive pensions and benefits for retired workers. How many existing police officers are cut in order to pay the pensions of the previously retired?
- themartorana 12y agoEdit: rant ahead, not aimed directly at bluedino I will never understand this. I agree life-time pensions are unsustainable. I argue constantly for a) all new public employees being enrolled in a 401k and pensions being phased out and b) offering younger workers buy-outs, allowing them to invest their contributions themselves in reward for opting out of the pension system. But that said - every pensioner out there worked for that pension. It was in their contract as an employee, a perk that often kept them in public service jobs, teaching your kids, putting out your fires, and so on. Every single person that argues for pulling the tablecloth out from under pensioners would be ferociously mad at the idea of any company canceling or reneging on a contract. To me, canceling or changing the pension of a retired (or soon to be retired) worker is the same as a bank deciding that you can't keep your house after all, even though you're not delinquent - it's just that the bank could use the value of your house, and breaking a contract is no big deal. Get off of the backs of pensioners - they put in their time, worked often for decades, contracted the promise of some security in retirement, but hey, we have a financial crisis, and suddenly they're freeloaders. Pretty much everything about pensions is broken and unsustainable, but that's not on the worker, that's on those that made the promise, and not keeping it is just the lowest form of horrible. Apologies for the rant. I accept the down voting I expect.
- cyphunk 12y agoAre you kidding me? Why isn't this a thing: He had made a previous purchase in the yearly tax foreclosure auction. His coup turned less appealing as he was confronted with the reality of removing the owner and then-occupant from her home. Goldenberg sold the house back to its occupant for the bargain price of $7,000 – twice what he had paid for it, but half what she had owed in property taxes. Meaning why isn't there a protection agency or service that buys houses from these foreclosure auctions and sells them back to their owners at a bargain???
- gajomi 12y agoI agree. This seems like a no brainer. Barring any legal barriers that might arise in the implementation of such a scheme, it seems like the main bottlenecks would be (1) verifying that the current occupant was indeed the original title holder (2) transferring the purchased title to said previous occupant without incurring substantial fees From a the technology standpoint it seems to me like everything else could be fairly standard CRUD. There might be a bipartite graph between lenders and the foreclosed upon, simplified by averaging the resources of the former across all nodes. Can anyone keen on the Detroit scene pipe in on the legal aspects?