6 ms·
Nintendo files Patent Application for Hand-Held Video Game Emulation
- gmuslera 12y agoIt can't be invalidated by the existence for years of prior art, even as open source?
- JohnHaugeland 12y agoSure it can. That happens when they try to leverage the patent, not when it's granted.
- adriansd 12y agoYou mean when it gets challenged. Companies leverage their patents all day long without them being challenged for validity.
- evanb 12y agoThat's right, now that the patent has been granted. But, in principle, if the patent office found prior art then it shouldn't have been granted in the first place.
- snarfy 12y agoPatent laws have changed. It's now first to file, not first to invent.
- tjl 12y agoThat's not the way it works. First to file vs. invent has to do with two independent inventors creating something and trying to file. If something has already been invented and is publicly available (patented or not), that's prior art and can invalidate the patent.
- noonespecial 12y agoThis isn't quite what most people think. Prior art still invalidates patents. "First to file" is merely the method now used to deal with two or more parties claiming to have invented a thing in secret who show up at the patent office more or less at the same time. Before, there used to be a trial type thing where the inventors presented lab notebooks and evidence to try to prove who was first. It was lengthy and expensive for all involved. First to file does not mean first to pluck some heretofore unpatented but well known already used technology from the field and run to the patent office.
- icebraining 12y agoThat's right, now that the patent has been granted Has it? I understood it was still only a patent application.
- amirmc 12y agoThat just underlines how broken the system is. As a sibling comment points out, patents can still go uncontested. Even worse is when small players end paying fees (because they can't affird lengthy litigation), which ends up supporting the patent.
- PythonicAlpha 12y agoYes. And I am also upset, that a patent like this (when that what an other poster posted is complete) can go threw the patent process, because what the claims say is nothing more as an generic emulator that can emulate binary software of a different computer --- something that exists in hundreds or thousands of versions ... there exist at least three only for the C64 computer and this software is around for 20 years or so (Vice, one of those is ~21 years old).
- derf_ 12y agoThe AIA now allows third parties to submit prior art before a patent is issued. The fine folks at http://www.pubpat.org/ http://www.pubpat.org/ might be able to help.
- rasz_pl 12y agolol no, what will happen is a $500K lawyer bill for person fighting this patent.
- mahouse 12y agoThat's what I thought; this is completely stupid. I already had a Game Boy emulator in my Sony Ericsson V630i, over seven years ago.
- LukeShu 12y agoThe patent specifically is 20140349751[a]. Notably, all but one of the claims have been cancelled. I've bullet-ized it: 17. A method of adapting an emulator, the method comprising: - executing, on a processor, an emulator capable of running a plurality different binary applications; - recognizing, by the processor, an identity of a binary application based on an inspection of the binary application; - automatically adapting, by the processor, a behavior of the emulator to the binary application based on the recognized identity of the binary application; - and generating, by the processor, an audio visual presentation using the adapted behavior of the emulator. [a]: http://appft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO2&Sect2=HITOFF&p=1&u=%2Fnetahtml%2FPTO%2Fsearch-bool.html&r=2&f=G&l=50&co1=AND&d=PG01&s1=Nintendo.AS.&OS=AN/Nintendo&RS=AN/Nintendo http://appft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO2&Sect2=H...
- MBCook 12y agoCan someone de-patentese this? It sounds like it's talking about the idea of having an emulator recognize that it's on a 3DS playing a copy of Pokemon Blue for the GB and then running special code that may be built into the emulator to enhance the presentation of Pokemon Blue, perhaps by overlaying 3D models of the attacks during battle. Sort of like the auto-coloring that the SuperGB and GBC added to games but taken to a much further level. Not a bad idea to have built in enhancement for popular/'important' games. (I'm ignoring any 'should this be patentable' issues for the purposes of my post).
- akersten 12y ago> Can someone de-patentese this? No. Because there's really nothing novel there. It's as generic as it sounds, and absolutely unenforceable - but it got through anyway. No surprise there.
- DSMan195276 12y agoWhat do you mean it got through? It is an application, not a patent.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- kabdib 12y agoNintendo has a history of getting absolutely unoriginal stuff patented. Many of the patents for the Wii controller algorithms made claims already covered by well established and published techniques. "Someone at the patent office got a Wii for their birthday," one of my fellows quipped. I guess you could argue that Nintendo's patents are really no worse (or better) than the existing practice of filing for software patents, namely "claim the sun and the moon" to get trading cards for the sword-rattling contest [sorry about mixing metaphors...] Software patents are a circular firing squad that we should just stop. The patent office has proved itself utterly incompetent to judge their merit, and these patents -- far from protecting innovation -- can only do harm in the hands of trolls, lawyers with prosthetic morals and large corporations.
- Joeri 12y agoThe problem with getting rid of software patents is that you have to do it retroactively, invalidating the existing patents. The patent holders would sue the government for destroying their property, and would likely win it even if those patents collectively destroy more value than they represent (something which I strongly believe). So, even if you had a government willing to get rid of software patents, they're not likely to get away with it. The only practical way to do it would be to reduce the life of a new patent by one year every year, so that all software patents, current and future end up exiring at the same time. But that still takes 20 years before it actually takes effect.
- mikeash 12y agoWhy couldn't they simply stop issuing new ones entirely, and let existing patents expire normally?
- PythonicAlpha 12y agoThat would be a solution. But political pressure is high, that the system stays as it is. And they that want it that it stays are the biggest players on place, since they think they can win most of this ridiculous system. It is like dinosaurs, which make a law, that children must come from an egg....
- chromanoid 12y agoI flew with Singapore Airlines in 2000 and they had already Nintendo systems for each seat. Similar to this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EIkx6E0Mwsk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EIkx6E0Mwsk So they just add a patent for emulating...
- acd 12y agoSoftware patents are stupid and hinders innovation!
- Roboprog 12y agoSooooo.... The US Patent office doesn't have an internet connection??? The irony is that I did a Google search last night for emulators for my tablet, and found, shall we say, just a bit of prior art. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_video_game_emulators#Nintendo http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_video_game_emulators#Ni... How can the Patent Office be immune to their seemingly utter incompetence? (or am I pulling a "reverse Hanlon's Razor" here - ascribing to stupidity what is really evil)
- RedLeg 12y ago1. This is merely a published patent application, and not an issued patent. An inventor may file a patent application that claims whatever he/she wants. An application has no legal effect until it has been examined and issued by the USPTO. 2. This particular patent application claims priority to a patent application filed on November 28, 2000. This means that any prior art must have been published before that date. It does not appear that your links contains any such prior art. I know it is quite popular on the Internet to criticize the USPTO for its perceived "incompetence", but please make sure that you have the "competence" of understanding the basics of the US patent application process before making disparaging remarks.
- dang 12y agoThanks for this clarification. The TechCrunch title was obviously misleading, so we changed it. Edit: we also changed the url from http://techcrunch.com/2014/11/28/nintendo-patents-game-boy-emulation-for-use-in-mobile-devices-in-flight-entertainment/ http://techcrunch.com/2014/11/28/nintendo-patents-game-boy-e... to a more substantive article that it points to.
- Roboprog 12y agoYeah, I get the distinction between "applied" and "granted". The old link had less information, without further searching around for the casual reader. The fact that 16 out of 17 claims had been mentioned as invalidated, but still leaving one remaining, was suggestive of part of the patent being granted. Are you claiming the USPO doesn't grant overreaching patents, by the dozen? The "prior to 2000" part is interesting, though. I wonder who filed what patent in 2000 about emulating old bitty boxes?
- Karunamon 12y agoOkay, so what's a normal person to do? This is obviously a BS patent, given the utter scads of prior art out there. Is there a way to file a complaint/challenge or otherwise point this out to someone at USPTO?
- spacemanmatt 12y agoAlrighty. This ought to be quick work for a good patent attorney now that they can cite http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alice_Corp._v._CLS_Bank_International http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alice_Corp._v._CLS_Bank_Interna... to get their subject matter ruled ineligible. I think the real question is when the Nintendo patent will see a court test.
- spacemanmatt 12y ago'quick work' being, of course, entirely relative. Not to be flip, Alice should help the situation a lot.