3 ms·
The difference, in my city, anyway, is that lights are timed for cars and not bicycles. A light pattern that usually stops a car twice might stop a cyclist thre
by 1123581321 12y ago
The difference, in my city, anyway, is that lights are timed for cars and not bicycles. A light pattern that usually stops a car twice might stop a cyclist three or four times. A cyclists' lower speed and presence in the open air means that they react to the environment much more quickly. It's nearly impossible for a cyclist to fail to notice cross traffic when approaching an intersection whereas it's difficult for an auto. So, a series of lights that minimally inconveniences a car, and reduces the chance of a crash, inconveniences a cyclist more and hardly reduces the chance of a crash (it may increase the chance since hindrances to cycling reduce cycling rates, which puts people in cars, which are more dangerous per mile.)
Because of all this, the "Idaho Stop" is a recognized, lawful traffic behavior for cyclists in many jurisdictions. It lets them treat stop signs as yields and red lights as stop signs.
Someone claiming to be a safe cyclist who runs red lights may present poorly to people who only drive, or who imagine a cyclist speeding through a red light at 20+ MPH, but it's not an oxymoron and it should be understood by someone who is familiar with cycling.
- mikeash 12y agoAccording to Wikipedia, the Idaho Stop has not been adopted outside of Idaho. I believe many jurisdictions allow bicyclists to proceed through a red light if they stop and wait for a minute or two and the light doesn't change, as a way to compensate for sensor-activated lights that bicycles won't trigger. But that's quite different.
- judk 12y agoSo is Idaho wrong, or are the laws elsewhere wrong? I don't think the potato surplus changes the nature of traffic.
- judk 12y agoSo is Idaho wrong, or are the laws elsewhere wrong? I don't think the potato surplus changes the nature of traffic.
- 1123581321 12y agoAh, you're right. I believe it's spread unofficially, though, because I've heard about the practice from several areas of the country.
- mikeash 12y agoIt seems pretty common. In general, the law around cyclists and how cyclists actually behave is pretty different. And I don't mean to blame the cyclists there. In many cases (like IMO this one) the law is in the wrong and should be changed. In others (e.g. blasting through red lights without even stopping) the cyclists are in the wrong. But making the law better conform to reality here would probably make enforcing the good parts much easier.