10 ms·
Permissions asked for by Uber Android app
- api 12y agoThere's a general trend of mobile apps that ask for everything: camera, microphone, sensors, access to local files, WiFi, etc. These are apps (like Uber) with no good reason to need access to such things. In most cases I can think of no good reason for this except either a desire to surveil customers for indirect monetization, or participation in government or private surveillance grid efforts. I've got Lyft on my Android phone, but not Uber. I look at its permissions and the only dubious looking one is "access to take photos / videos." Is this perhaps for signing up as a driver and photographing yourself and your car? I don't see anything else that doesn't make sense.
- alexbecker 12y agoIt's worth noting that the quick summation of Android permissions given to users isn't quite accurate. There are a limited number of permissions, and many of them (such as SD card read/write access) are very broad. So the summary Google uses is a lay description of the worst possible thing an app could do with those permissions, which may be much more invasive than what it actually does.
- _lce0 12y agoThe permission model is broken. I should not give permission at install-time, it should be asked at runtime, at OS-level, and I MUST be allowed to say no anytime .. if I trust the app enough, then I should be able to say "allow the app to do that thing for this hour/day/month/always" why mobile OS authors haven't learn anything from the web security model yet?
- prostoalex 12y ago> why mobile OS authors haven't learn anything from the web security model yet? Which mobile OS authors? The behavior you described is default in iOS.
- rco8786 12y agoIt's a common practice to do this "just in case" you need the permissions later on. When first installing an app users are likely to hit Ok to whatever, but when permissions change on an update they are hit with another screen that tells them the specific thing you are now asking permissions for.
- socrates2015 12y agoIf the author is correct, then Uber is not only asking for permission but actually reading all the information and sending it back to its servers.
- api 12y agoSounds like classic poor security UX design -- it encourages people to allow everything, and encourages apps to claim everything.
- TillE 12y agoI have a lot of issues with iOS, but I think Apple's UX here is clearly superior: it asks you about each individual permission an app requests (not on install, but when the permission is first used), and allows you to deny it.
- dvhh 12y agoWasn't that almost the same approach with UAC ?
- r00fus 12y agoAs usual, Microsoft did it first, but got the UX all wrong. Apple comes along does something very similar, but because of the App Store and the infamous review cycle, can enforce some semblance of control over the app ecosystem. Notice: Apple only does this fairly granular security on iOS, and OSX is much more similar to how Windows it.
- api 12y ago
- anigbrowl 12y agoYeah, my T-Mobile account app wants to know about my Photos and wifi status. Of course, after that my automatic photo upload stopped working and I have to sttart Google voice manually because they want me to use a T-Mobile app for international calling via Wifi and buy a new SIM card for the privilege. T-Mobile talks a big game but treats its customers little better than its competitors - I may go back to MetroPCS but I think T-Mobile bought them already :-/
- andrewvc 12y agoRecall that PUT / DELETE aren’t official HTTP requests, rather extensions implemented via WebDav. Modern applications don’t bother with these requests since its easier / more secure to perform those same actions with a server side language. Apparently the author has not ever heard of REST. I'm a little shocked by that.
- mcav 12y agoPUT and DELETE are standardized. http://www.w3.org/Protocols/rfc2616/rfc2616-sec9.html http://www.w3.org/Protocols/rfc2616/rfc2616-sec9.html
- jwegan 12y agoFurthermore, it looks like PUT & DELETE were never part of Webdav (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WebDAV http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WebDAV).
- charlieok 12y agoIn that a WebDAV implementation wouldn't make use of them? I assumed that a WebDAV implemenation would use them, but the WebDAV spec doesn't need to define them because the HTTP spec it references already did...
- iolsantr 12y agoYeah I noticed that as well, it makes me wonder about the rest of his technical assertions that I'm less able to judge. Just in case anyone was wondering here's the HTTP 1.1 rfc: https://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc2616.txt https://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc2616.txt A simple search will show that it does include PUT and DELETE.
- amirmc 12y ago> "... it makes me wonder about the rest of his technical assertions that I'm less able to judge." What technical assertions? From what I can gather, he's just pointing out what he sees in the code and what he thinks it might be doing. None of that feels like technical assertions (apart from the statement about PUT and GET).
- imperialdrive 12y agothanks for reporting the findings... they should make it so you can block the specific settings after-the-fact and see if it actually breaks anything
- dmix 12y agoTLDR: Uber's Android app is literally malware Since the website is currently down, this person reverse-engineered Uber's Android app and discovered it has code that will "call home" aka send data back to Uber with your: - SMS list [edit: see other comments re SMSLog, SMS permission is not currently requested] - call history - wifi connections - GPS location - every type of device fingerprint possible (device IDs) It also checks if you're phone is rooted/jailbroken and if it's vulnerable to Heartbleed... which it also calls home. From my understanding, which the author somehow missed, is that it is using http://www.inauth.com http://www.inauth.com SDK which provides 'malware detection'. This SDK is popular in the 'mobile finance industry' and the banking sector. Also notably one of the founders is former DHS/FBI. Two possible theories: it is being used for fraud detection and/or an intelligence gathering tool. Edit: here is a copy of the decompiled source code http://www.gironsec.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/InAuthManager.txt http://www.gironsec.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/InAu... note the name "package com.inauth.mme" Edit #2: here is a screenshot of Uber's permission request https://i.imgur.com/4MmYrJH.png https://i.imgur.com/4MmYrJH.png no SMS on the list
- ericdykstra 12y agoYikes, uninstalling now. I haven't used Uber for a while, but it's been useful to have just in case Lyft is +200% and Sidecar doesn't have anything available... Now it's not even worth it to have the software on my phone. Thanks for the summary and link to the decompiled source code.
- revelation 12y agoJust for completeness sake and judging from the function names, this is the list, with attributes stored for each: - Accounts log (Email) - App Activity (Name, PackageName, Process Number of activity, Processed id) - App Data Usage (Cache size, code size, data size, name, package name) - App Install (installed at, name, package name, unknown sources enabled, version code, version name) - Battery (health, level, plugged, present, scale, status, technology, temperature, voltage) - Device Info (board, brand, build version, cell number, device, device type, display, fingerprint, ip, mac address, manufacturer, model, os platform, product, sdk code, total disk space, unknown sources enabled) - GPS (accuracy, altitude, latitude, longitude, provider, speed) - MMS (from number, mms at, mmss type, service number, to number) - NetData (bytes received, bytes sent, connection type, interface type) - PhoneCall (call duration, called at, from number, phone call type, to number) - SMS (from number, service number, sms at, sms type, to number) - TelephonyInfo (cell tower id, cell tower latitude, cell tower longitude, imei, iso country code, local area code, meid, mobile country code, mobile network code, network name, network type, phone type, sim serial number, sim state, subscriber id) - WifiConnection (bssid, ip, linkspeed, macaddr, networkid, rssi, ssid) - WifiNeighbors (bssid, capabilities, frequency, level, ssid) - Root Check (root staus code, root status reason code, root version, sig file version) - Malware Info (algorithm confidence, app list, found malware, malware sdk version, package list, reason code, service list, sigfile version) Or, put differently, I really don't see any reason for Google not to immediately remove this app from the store permanently and ban whatever developer uploaded it. There should probably be legal action. Edit: I've augmented the various types of data retrieved (ie: there is capability in the source to read, save and transmit this data) from the inauth framework sources.
- akanster 12y agoGoogle cache: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://www.gironsec.com/blog/2014/11/what-the-hell-uber-uncool-bro/ http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://...
- profinger 12y agoI like his image at the bottom that tells you to put in your credit card number and expiration to see if its been stolen. Upon inspection, the onclick just pops up an alert that says "Dumbass!" haha
- tempestn 12y agoIt still hangs trying to load assets. The text-only version should load immediately: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://www.gironsec.com/blog/2014/11/what-the-hell-uber-uncool-bro/&strip=1 http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- msoad 12y agoGoogle cached http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:6rWGz01vSDoJ:www.gironsec.com/blog/2014/11/what-the-hell-uber-uncool-bro/+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:6rWGz01...
- chc 12y agoimperialdrive, if you happen to read this, you appear to have been hellbanned. Just FYI.
- aikah 12y agoarchive https://archive.today/CR3eW https://archive.today/CR3eW I personally believe Uber app on android fits the definition of a malware.
- georgeott 12y agoPro Tip: Unintall the Uber App, and use m dot uber dot com inside Chrome.
- hkmurakami 12y agofyi I believe the web app breaks when Surge is in effect.
- bcoates 12y agoworks for me, surge notifications and all
- guelo 12y agoI do this with Facebook also.
- georgeott 12y agoExactly. As soon as they removed FB messaging from the app, I simply removed it, and use the mobile site.
- skeletonjelly 12y agoWon't that mean that Facebook will know what sites you visit that run FB's beacon/SDK? Better off using Tinfoil for Facebook (if Android) https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.danvelazco.fbwrapper https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.danvelazco...
- monort 12y agoAndroid needs a sandbox, which will provide apps with empty contacts, call history, fake location and so on. Does such sandbox exists?
- cle 12y agoXPrivacy? https://github.com/M66B/XPrivacy https://github.com/M66B/XPrivacy
- dserodio 12y agoI'm devastated that it doesn't (and apparently, never will) work with Lollipop.
- msoad 12y agohttps://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=biz.bokhorst.xprivacy.installer&hl=en https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=biz.bokhorst.x...
- bjackman 12y agoCyanogenMod implements it. It looks like Google actually implemented it themselves too but never shipped it.
- minot 12y agoI know that at least Cyanogen exposes something similar inside settings > privacy. I believe it comes from the hidden app permission manager built into Android. Further reading: http://www.androidpolice.com/2013/07/25/app-ops-android-4-3s-hidden-app-permission-manager-control-permissions-for-individual-apps/ http://www.androidpolice.com/2013/07/25/app-ops-android-4-3s...
- andymcsherry 12y agoThere's perfectly reasonable explanation for almost all of these permissions, and there's nothing in this analysis that suggests they're doing otherwise. The only one that I couldn't think of was WRITE_SETTINGS Permissions ACCESS_COARSE_LOCATION & ACCESS_FINE_LOCATION: Fairly obvious, they need to figure out where to pick you up ACCESS_NETWORK_STATE, ACCESS_WIFI_STATE , INTERNET: They need to figure out if you have internet and use it WAKE_LOCK: Keep the network running so you can get real-time updates about your driver GET_ACCOUNTS, USE_CREDENTIALS, MANAGE_ACCOUNTS: For logging in with Google CAMERA: You can take a picture of your credit card for easier entry CALL_PHONE: So you can call your driver MANAGE_ACCOUNTS: So they can add your uber account to your phone READ_CONTACTS: Probably for inviting friends or splitting ride costs READ_PHONE_STATE: Legacy analytics reasons WRITE_EXTERNAL_STORAGE: Probably unnecessary, but they are probably just storing data VIBRATE: For notifications The rest are for push notifications As far as the roottools, I know Crashlytics checks for root so they can provide that data in their console for crashes. It's a pretty useful thing to be able to weed crashes from rooted devices out. They usually make very little sense and violate the advertised behavior of the SDK.
- revelation 12y agoThis is like saying we should give everyone root access because there are legitimate situations where that is warranted and not misused. I mean, I might trust my neighbor with the key to my apartment, but I'll still call the cops when he comes in and trashes the place. Similarly, maybe there are valid reasons for Uber to have these permissions. That doesn't mean they can upload a dump of whatever data they can find to their servers.
- andymcsherry 12y agoThere's a difference between checking if root access can be granted and gaining root access. If Uber were to use this access, the superuser app would prompt the user to approve it. The user would then have to grant permission. There's no proof in this article that they are uploading this data to their servers, just speculation. The snippet of some methods he showed doesn't even make sense, because they don't ask for permissions for your SMS, MMS or other permissions required for these things.
- hartator 12y agoDown for me. http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:6rWGz01vSDoJ:www.gironsec.com/blog/2014/11/what-the-hell-uber-uncool-bro/+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:6rWGz01...
- blhack 12y agoA LOT of this stuff is pretty easily explainable. They want access to SMS and phone calls because the Uber app uses those things. Camera doesn't seem terribly implausible. IT could be an incoming feature that allows you to take a photo of where you are so that your driver can find you more easily. The WiFi stuff is probably related to location. edit: as pointed out below, this is so that you can take a photo of your credit card so you don't have to type it in. This seems like "hydrogen hydroxide KILLS" scare mongering. BTW, this is all available in the app permissions: https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-FVPu6x-F5SM/VHUZgU47m-I/AAAAAAAAJuQ/STPzA9cJdQ4/w668-h1186-no/14%2B-%2B1 https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-FVPu6x-F5SM/VHUZgU47m-I/A... I don't see the big OMG SECRET MALWARE scariness.
- benigeri 12y agoThey let users take pictures of debit/credit cards for easy input.
- 2xlbuds 12y agoUber uses the card.io SDK to let you enter your credit card information by taking a picture of the card, which requires the camera permission.
- blhack 12y agoHOW DARE THEY! Thanks, I forgot about that since it's been so long.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- dmix 12y ago> I don't see the big OMG SECRET MALWARE scariness. This is the definition of malware: n. Malicious computer software that interferes with normal computer functions or sends personal data about the user to unauthorized parties over the Internet. I'm all for people taking responsibility for their privacy but this is basically what you are saying to people: "Hey you accepted that list of permissions (or Terms of Service)! What? you didn't expect that your Taxi app is not going to retrieve and store your call logs and other personal information? How silly of you." This rational among tech people is why there is zero privacy. The myth of consumer choice in the matter. The average person doesn't reasonably expect Uber to be mining this information about them. Merely assuming it is a function of the application. We in technology know that they can but the average user? Who has responsibility here then? Noone? Uber has an ethical responsibility not to actually abuse this trust from their users IMO. Which is why the inclusion of this library deserves scrutiny.
- pkaye 12y agoWonderful! Just last week, Samsung did an update on my phone software and installed the Uber app automatically. Glad I removed it after that.
- rubyn00bie 12y agoDefinitely uncool and a great article. I do find it funny that despite all the other allegations, absolutely reprehensible business practices, and general malice they've put in the world that this is a surprise to anyone. I'm quite surprised that they still have so much business, but then again, morality isn't a one-size fits all sort of deal. What bothers me, may not bother other folks, or may seem as smart business tactics ( :sadface: ). To me, it's just more icing on the cake.
- thisjepisje 12y agoAs a dumbphone user, why people even allow an app to get information like this is beyond me.
- dvhh 12y agoSome people find it acceptable to give up information for "convenience", or even worse : bragging
- declan 12y agoI'm not sure the criticism in the linked post is justified. Here's what Uber says about its Android permissions -- the page isn't that difficult to find: https://m.uber.com/android-permissions https://m.uber.com/android-permissions Uber says the camera permission is required to take a snapshot of your credit card. The phone call permission is required to call your driver. The get accounts permission is required to enable single sign-in (Google Sign-In, Google Wallet). The Uber app doesn't, according to the gironsec.com post, request Android's READ_SMS permission, so pointing to a "sendSMSLog" code excerpt by itself doesn't mean much. And so on. As <andymcsherry> pointed out elsewhere in this thread, there's a "perfectly reasonable explanation for almost all of these permissions" except WRITE_SETTINGS. Uber says in its Android permissions post that: "We use this permission to save data and cache mapping vectors." It seems as though it would have been useful for the author of the gironsec.com post to read what Uber has to say -- or, better yet, contact the company before posting a critique. If Uber PR can't cough up a good explanation, it makes the final critique more powerful. I've posted here on HN criticizing Uber before (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8383854 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8383854), but before rushing to judgment here let's check our facts first.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- lukasm 12y agohttp://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:6rWGz01vSDoJ:www.gironsec.com/blog/2014/11/what-the-hell-uber-uncool-bro/+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=uk http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:6rWGz01...
- wpnx 12y agoMirror in google cache: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:6rWGz01vSDoJ:www.gironsec.com/blog/2014/11/what-the-hell-uber-uncool-bro/+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:6rWGz01...
- dang 12y agoWe've attempted to change the baity title to something accurate and neutral, but if anyone can suggest a better title, please do.
- uptown 12y agoYeah, when I posted it, I realized the title wasn't ideal - but figured the safe bet was to adhere to the "post with the author's published title" rule.
- aosmith 12y agoLooks like it's time to turn on memcached...
- dpiers 12y agoThere's an article here explaining what the permissions are used for: https://m.uber.com/android-permissions https://m.uber.com/android-permissions
- click170 12y agoOne way to deal with this is to filter all outbound requests and not let the requests that you've identified as "phoning home" to complete. Then, you test the app, if it still works you can continue using it. If it doesn't, you find a different service or you consider re-adjusting your restrictions. Outbound filtering can quickly highlight any app that tries to call home. Luckily, many apps continue working if you block those calls. YMMV.
- dingaling 12y agoSadly, filtering is a privilege only rooted Android users may enjoy despite there being a perfectly functional iptables/ iptables6 instance on every phone. The first thing I do after rooting is install a front- end to iptables and set it to whitelist mode. Any app that has a genuine need to access the internet can then be authorised; everything else is denied. It frustrates me greatly that the ' common user' is denied this protection.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- gasull 12y agoThis is outrageous. Write a review at https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.ubercab https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.ubercab and link to the article. I just did that.
- ape4 12y agoUber: nice idea, evil company.
- makeramen 12y agoChecking for root access is actually really useful from a developer standpoint. I've seen countless bugs on Crashlytics that are 100% on rooted devices which often is because the user has xposed or some other system level hacks that break my apps. This allows us developers to spend more time focusing on real bugs instead of chasing down these rooted device problems.
- MrGunn 12y agoIt's not a user's fault they have to root to regain some control over a piece of hardware they own. Your app shouldn't crash under xposed - test for it.
- krschultz 12y agoAs an Android developer, I don't want to have to ask for as many permissions as I do. I have 1 button buried on 1 screen that allows you to call customer support. 99.9% of users never click the button. However, I have to make every single customer accept the CALL_PHONE permission. There are a bunch of permissions required for basics like autocompleting the users email for login, or checking the network state so you can adjust the app behavior based on connectivity. Not to mention the incentives are all wrong in the Play store. Changing permissions murders your update rate, so you want to do it as little as possible. So when you are forced to add a permission, you grab a bunch of extra ones you 'plan' to use later to avoid having to get over that hump again. It's really awful.
- driverdan 12y agoWhy? All we have is a tel: link that opens the phone number in the dialer. They can choose to initiate the call or not, no permissions needed.
- pja 12y agoA guess: The call might show up in the phone logs if it's made through the standard Android Phone app. If the call is made directly from the Uber App, then perhaps this means that Uber can hide the phone number from the user. I can think of a number of reasons why they'd want to do that if they could.
- stesch 12y agoI don't have Android 5.0. Is it now possible to block certain permissions per app?
- fstephany 12y agoNo.
- bndw 12y agoIf you're interested in exploring this, and other Android app's permissions, I built http://appethics.org http://appethics.org last weekend. The goal was to easily surface what permissions a given app requires, and what they mean.
- zeus180 12y agoI don't see that Uber has permissions to my SMS, however, after going through the other list of granted permissions, I went to the settings and modified the permission and also enabled privacy guard for the app. You can go to Settings -> Apps -> (scroll down) tap on Modify - screenshot http://i.imgur.com/AVXLqgh.png http://i.imgur.com/AVXLqgh.png
- first_account 12y agoUber doesn't know who does the ride of shame based on pickups and drop offs, they just monitor the phones of their customers!
- duncan_bayne 12y agoI've contacted Uber in Australia, and requested a copy of all personal data they have collected. This is my right under Australian law; it'll be interesting to see how they proceed.
- rrrrr 12y agoIsn't it possible to route all traffic to/from an Android device through a MIM proxy, run the Uber app, and then see exactly what data is being sent to Uber HQ?
- djabatt 12y agoClearly aggressive and not in a way that improves UX.