2 ms·
The article is rendered worthless by making the same flawed assumptions most of these articles make: - No one is claiming there is a "STEM shortage". There is
by jandrewrogers 12y ago
The article is rendered worthless by making the same flawed assumptions most of these articles make:
- No one is claiming there is a "STEM shortage". There is a shortage of qualified software engineers. STEM includes an abundance of marine biologists, aerospace engineers, astronomers, and myriad other subfields with poor job prospects that are in no way qualified to fill the shortage that actually exists in other STEM subfields.
- The category of "IT worker" sweeps up a lot of low-skill jobs that have nothing to do with software engineering. Maybe the low-skill jobs are not making great money but software engineers qualified enough to get a job easily make six-figures where I live, and I do not live in Silicon Valley. The oppression and slavery are palpable.
- Training to become a qualified software engineer is not like training to operate a backhoe. It is not just about "being good with computers". Tool chains you can learn over weeks or months, but developing domain competence useful to an organization can take years. By analogy, both chemists and chemical engineers deal with designing chemical reactions, but neither can do the job of the other without a couple years of additional training even though they are both just making chemicals. Most companies will not pay to train a chemist to become a chemical engineer when they need a chemical engineer now.
Every article like this that conflates software engineers with "STEM jobs" or "IT workers" isn't really talking about software engineers.
- nradov 12y agoThere is no shortage of qualified software engineers. As a hiring manager I have been able to find as many as I need, at the market price. Anyone can do the same.