3 ms·
The standard argument against immigration is that it "takes jobs away" from local applicants. A successful business will typically generate new jobs. Thus, al
by kasey_junk 12y ago
The standard argument against immigration is that it "takes jobs away" from local applicants. A successful business will typically generate new jobs. Thus, allowing in people who create jobs over those that take them is seen as a net positive.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoIf I were to start Chris's Italian American bakery I'm likely taking some business away from Patel's Pure Ghee Sweets and possibly reducing the number of jobs he creates. So while I've generated 5 gross jobs, it's unclear that I generated any net jobs. (For the record I think "new jobs" is a moronic reason to do anything. A job is a cost, delicious rainbow cookies are the benefit.)
- kasey_junk 12y agoCompletely agree with all of that. But that is the standard reductionist argument.
- anigbrowl 12y agoThis is true to the extent that different goods are economic substitutes for each other. But even if they are perfect substitutes and no net jobs are created, increased competition would reduce prices for consumers, resulting in a net aggregate economic benefit. I also think 'jobs' is a moronic reason to do things but immigration policy, more than most, is the focus of atavistic political passions rather than rational economic analysis.
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoThere doesn't need to be any argument against immigration. Since immigration is something the state actively does and permits, immigration policies require active justification in terms of how they benefit the country.