5 ms·
How medieval astronomers made trig tables
- exDM69 12y agoVery interesting, makes me want to order the spherical trigonometry book that was the source for this text. Spherical trigonometry is sometimes very non-intuitive. I recently took a few courses of university level astronomy. And as has been the tradition at least from the times of Ptolemy's Almagest in the 2nd century, we started with spherical trigonometry. When doing exercises, we'd draw triangles on oranges we got from the cafeteria. That's way better than trying to draw spheres on a flat piece of paper.
- sxp 12y agoWouldn't it be easier to calculate the values by drawing a giant circle on the ground and measuring the values? You can mark out the angle on the circle and then measure the X & Y values of different points on the arc.
- pokpokpok 12y agoaccurate measurement tools weren't so easy to come by as paper and time
- wging 12y agoYou'd also probably need to do some fairly precise calculations in order to manufacture accurate measurement tools. Chicken-and-egg sort of problem?
- ColinWright 12y agoIt's tough to get 6 digits of accuracy that way. Think, if the circle is 10 metres across, 1 mm is still 0.0001, just 4 digits. Trying to do it physically is orders of magnitude less accurate.
- breadbox 12y agoYou might think that if you've never tried it. But how do you get a giant circle on the ground in the first place? I mean, sure that giant circle you've drawn there looks circular, but how do you know that it is? Normally you'd measure it and verify it, but the whole point is that you're trying to use this circle to determine what those verified measurements ought to be in the first place. Even a hairsbreadth misshapen circle is going to give you wrong numbers. No, there's no comparison to finding a precise mathematical formula and exploiting it.
- willvarfar 12y agohttp://www.instructables.com/id/How-to-draw-a-circle-with-string/ http://www.instructables.com/id/How-to-draw-a-circle-with-st... or is that too obvious?
- ColinWright 12y agoDo you really think you'll get six digit accuracy with that?
- oh_sigh 12y agoDepends how long your string is.
- marcosdumay 12y agoAlso depends on a ruler marked with 6 digits of accuracy.
- mturmon 12y agoMaking it longer will not fix the problem. The longer the string, the more it stretches. Replace it with a rod. The longer the rod, the more it sags.
- breadbox 12y agoNo, that's not too obvious. As has already been pointed out, you're going to need a circle the size of a building if you want to get more than 2-3 digits of precision (assuming that you can make your measurements with millimeter accuracy). How are you going to verify that your inscribed circle has no serious imperfections? Try making a building-sized circle on the ground using string -- it will be off of true by much more than a millimeter, I assure you.
- gradi3nt 12y agoVery interesting. Life was seriously tough before series expansions were invented!
- KhalilK 12y agoMeta note: Al-Kāshī was not a "medieval astronomer", the Middle Ages are related to European history and Al-Kāshī lived in Iran during the Islamic Golden Age.
- m-photonic 12y agoBut "ancient" astronomers would have been even less accurate, and headlines need words that people can instantly recognize.
- michael_fine 12y agoYeah, post-classical would have been the more accurate term, thought I'm not sure it would've had the same comprehensibility.
- vacri 12y agoThe "Classical" world is as limited as "the middle ages" (perhaps even moreso); it mostly deals with the Mediterranean civilisations - and Iran is a long way from there.
- michael_fine 12y agoAccording to my AP World textbook, at least, classical refers to a lot of geographically diverse civilizations, from the Byzantines to the Song Chinese to the Aztecs
- nichtich 12y agoWhat's wrong with 14th century then?
- Someone 12y agoChristianism. The man probably thought he lived around the year 800.
- 12y ago
- analog31 12y agoThanks! I love reading about how people solved problems without our contemporary tools.
- srean 12y agoYou may find the work of Kerala mathematicians on Taylor series of sin, cos, and arctan quite intriguing http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kerala_school_of_astronomy_and_mathematics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kerala_school_of_astronomy_and_... They happen to be at the center of a minor controversy and semantic games of what exactly is Calculus because they were doing these series approximations routinely about a couple of centuries before the European recognition of the Taylor series or calculus for that matter.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- thewarrior 12y ago>> Then sin 1° is a fixed point of f. Why ?
- CarolineW 12y agoThe fact that it's a fixed point comes from the triplke angle formula just a few lines above. Substitute and simplify, and you'll see that f applied to sin(1 deg) returns sin(1 deg). As to why it conveges when iterated, starting from a value that's close enough, that's a different question. Is that what you actually intended to ask?
- thewarrior 12y agoYes.
- raverbashing 12y agonumpy? really? "For deg2rad"? REALLY? But to be fair: >>> math.sin(2 * math.pi/360.) 0.01745240643728351 >>> numpy.sin(2 * numpy.pi/360.) 0.017452406437283512
- VikingCoder 12y agoOkay, I'll voice my desire... My understanding of this comes from Carl Sagan's original Cosmos miniseries... Kepler and Brahe were reluctant allies. Brahe had the observational data Kepler needed to try to understand the motions of the planets... ...but how the hell did Kepler do it? I've gone through Differential Equations, I've done Linear Algebra quite a bit, I'm good at computer graphics... I had to derive the equivalent of Bresenham's Ellipse drawing algorithm for a test... And I have no idea how it's even remotely possible for Kepler to have taken astronomical observational data, and derived the motions of the planets from that data. Has anyone ever done a "For Dummies!" write up of how this was possible?
- plikan13 12y agoI didn't read the book, but from leafing through Stephen Hawking's "On the shoulder of giants" I got the impression this book tries to reconstruct how Copernicus, Kepler etc... acquired their understanding of the universe, based on their original texts. So maybe that's the book you want?