10 ms·
South Korea to raise $500B for unification
- jkrome 12y agoThere's no way the North Korean military will allow unification to happen. They're much farther advanced, technologically and militarily than South Korea so in any war, they will squash them. Just watch this video of North Korean might: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O-hyVzTVDLg http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O-hyVzTVDLg
- jkrome 12y agoHahaha. Everyone that downvoted me has no idea of the sarcasm here... The video is hilarious, btw.
- comrade1 12y agoIs there a reason for this planning? Is this government or private enterprise? Maybe this is the south sending a signal to the north? Or private enterprise in the south with government backing? I swear Korean politics is more confusing than the east-west Cold War. Reunification went well in Germany. Although even now there are vast differences between the east and west, the east is fully integrated. Think of it as the poor southern US vs the east coast.
- lolgas 12y agoI don't fully understand the politics either, but this is a clear signal that the South wants the North to flourish. Everyone wins when capitalism is injected into an economy. The South's private sector gains would be big because of the cheap labor, and the population of the North would have incredible wage growth. The effects of injecting capitalism would be magnified relative to the fall of East Germany because the differences in GDP are enormous. If this happens, it would be the biggest win for capitalism/democracy I've seen in my lifetime (I'm born after the fall of ussr)
- tsotha 12y ago>Is there a reason for this planning? Is this government or private enterprise? Maybe this is the south sending a signal to the north? Or private enterprise in the south with government backing? I swear Korean politics is more confusing than the east-west Cold War. The South Korean government expects the North to collapse at some point. North Korea only survives as a country because the Chinese give them oil and other countries give them food periodically. Nearly 100% of the country's economic output goes to the maintenance of the state. >Reunification went well in Germany. Although even now there are vast differences between the east and west, the east is fully integrated. Think of it as the poor southern US vs the east coast. That's ridiculous. Germany is a very wealthy country and it paid a huge price to reintegrate the East. A process that's not complete, by the way. South Korea is not as wealthy as West Germany was, and North Korea is far worse off than East Germany. Reunification will break the South, economically.
- bewo001 12y agoIt is a good idea to plan ahead. The East German gorvernment of 1988 looked at least as secure as the NK government looks now. The West German military draft was extended in 1988 'because the commies are stronger than ever'. When the East German regime fell, it fell so quickly that nobody had the time to make a well-thought out plan. The West German government didn't have any plan in 1989, despite all the Sunday speeches dreaming of re-unification. In hindsight, many things could have been done better, eg the rules about ownership of nationalized property. Unresolved ownership questions were a huge roadblock for economic development.
- adventured 12y agoI'm glad they're considering doing this. However, it's going to cost a lot more than $500 billion to raise per capita GDP by ~7 fold. It'll cost $500+ billion in the first ten years in just welfare support, security, education, infrastructure, disarmament, healthcare, job training. $50 billion per year in net drag is perhaps even far too low of a number. There are 24 million people in the north. That's a mere $2,000 per year per person. It's going to cost a lot more than that to start bringing them up to speed. I think you could easily spend $2k per person, just on the person - not counting several expensive things I listed previously. South Korea should plan for $2 trillion over 20 years. They'll intentionally under-shoot the numbers, to avoid freaking out the tax paying public, and the cost will end up ballooning far beyond the public relations numbers.
- throwaway344 12y agoAnd even if they do (impossibly) increase GDP/capita to 10,000 with that amount of money, North Korea would still be way, way, way poorer than South Korea. I wonder at this point whether reunification as was done in Germany is even possible, given the dramatic (and growing) difference between the two states. Perhaps some sort of confederation will be done.
- WildUtah 12y ago" cost a lot more than $500 billion to raise per capita GDP by ~7 fold." That's a good point, but remember that North Korea, in spite of being the most backward and poor nation on Earth, is full of Koreans. A strong creative drive and high levels intellectual life and potential talent and a flair for protest and organizing reform will do a lot for a nation. Most nations would be lucky to unify with 15 MM Koreans, no matter how poor. Within a generation of getting freedom, I expect them to be doing well. Remember that it only took RoK twenty years to go from a brutal dictatorship among the poorest in the world to the 1st world nation it is.
- Nogwater 12y agoWhat is so special about Koreans that your comment couldn't have used "humans" instead?
- WildUtah 12y agoThere should be scholarships for a phalanx of Korean economists to go to Germany and study the world's best example. Maybe we'd get some new answers about what's going on with the old DDR's economic malaise, too.
- orbifold 12y agoFor comparison Germany unification has now cost roughly ~100billion per year for 20 years, so far. So roughly 2 trillion total. Given that the DDR was actually in relatively good shape compared to North Korea, that is there weren't any famines, it had a more or less working industry and a very good education system, I believe South Korea would have to bear much higher costs per annum.
- pgodzin 12y agoAny idea how much the initial conversion of currency at below going rate cost?
- kalms 12y agoAs to my knowledge, most industries became obsolete after reunification, since they only built and developed state sanctioned products that wasn't needed after that event.
- lgierth 12y agoMost of the industrial production means was sold to western capital in the early 90s by the Treuhandanstalt (trust agency), and the companies were closed. Edit: this was of course one of the biggest waves of privatization Germany has seen. The English Wikipedia has a bit more information: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treuhand https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treuhand
- justincormack 12y agoThey were sold. That means they were not closed, you do not buy something and then shut it down. Some was shut down later, or repurposed.
- blahedo 12y ago> You do not buy something and then shut it down. An ironic comment on Hacker News, of all places.
- notastartup 12y agoshouldn't they, the north koreans accept reunification first? I wonder if there is some non public intelligence about north korea that is pushing them to do this.
- walterbell 12y agoWhy did Eric Schmidt visit North Korea (and Assange on a separate occasion)?
- threeseed 12y agoThe North Koreans already accept reunification. Except that they assume South Korea will be unified into the DPRK under the leadership of Kim Jong Un.
- jpatokal 12y agoUnification is about the only thing the Koreas do agree on: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Korean_Unification_Flag https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Korean_Unification_Flag But the devil is very much in the details! (And in this case even the broad strokes: capitalist democracy vs communist dictatorship, etc.)
- corford 12y ago>I wonder if there is some non public intelligence about north korea that is pushing them to do this. First that and then this: https://www.irishtimes.com/news/world/asia-pacific/north-korea-human-rights-practices-challenged-in-un-1.2006789 https://www.irishtimes.com/news/world/asia-pacific/north-kor... Something seems to be going on behind the scenes.
- meric 12y agoIf unification was going to happen I think maintaining two currencies until the two economies are on par would be most stable for noth Korean citizens. By stabilising the NK currency through having it managed by the SK central bank while having the currency maintain a lower value than SK's, stability can be maintained while retaining labor competitiveness. All they need to do then is open the country to foreign investment and gradually open up the border. This way minimal public funds will be required and the private sector will help the economies unify over time in the most stable and efficient way.
- WildUtah 12y agoGermany just gave a huge gift to ever DDR citizen by trading the Mark and the DDR Mark at 1:1. With a per person limit of a few thousand marks, it wasn't that expensive and really set the unification up to succeed with popular backing.
- meric 12y agoThey could do the same by just sending some amount of south korean currency to every NK mailbox (or do it more throughly through records which I'm sure NK has kept on almost every household), while maintaining two currencies to allow NK export firms to have a competitive advantage in cheaper currency, rather than suffocating them for a period of time after unification (as you can read in the link), slowing the economic recovery. "East German currency was exchanged for West German deutsche marks at a rate of 1 to 1, although the market rate was 4 to 1, according to the FSC. The overestimated currency conversion helped stabilize the livelihoods of workers from East Germany in the short term, but soon resulted in a sudden wage hike, which damaged the profitability of East German companies."
- rdl 12y agoI wonder how much insurance companies could save through unification instead of war (* the odds of war). I have to imagine "rebuilding Seoul with 10% odds over the next 50 years" would exceed the direct costs of unification.
- twistedpair 12y agoNo way. Ever heard of a force majeure clause? If Kim Jun nukes Tokoyo or LA, Progressive and Geico are not going to cover the damage to your car. In war, all contracts are off. You're simply screwed.
- rdl 12y agoWar risk insurance doesn't include such a clause.
- lolgas 12y agoI would love to see the US devote a huge portion of foreign aid to this development. Probably going to write my senator about this. Check this to see if your senator is on the subcommittee for East Asian Affairs, and write them about spending on the unification of North and South Korea -> http://www.foreign.senate.gov/about/subcommittees/subcommittee-on-east-asian-and-pacific-affairs http://www.foreign.senate.gov/about/subcommittees/subcommitt...
- throwaway344 12y agoJust the US military mission in South Korea costs $1.1 billion a year. Dealing with the North Korean situation would make most of that spending completely unneeded.
- kijin 12y agoEven without North Korea, I can't imagine the US giving up a military base within spitting distance of mainland China anytime soon. More American troops are stationed in Germany than in Korea, and Germany has been united for over 20 years.
- anemitz 12y agoOngoing cost of the U.S. bases in Korea isn't likely an issue. You have to house those troops somewhere and bringing them back to the U.S. would require building and/or expanding of existing domestic facilities so the economics would make keeping the existing bases ideal.
- riffraff 12y agoI'm not sure how it works for the US army but don't people get "mission" wages which are many times the base wage they'd get if they were at home?
- WatchDog 12y agoThey get hazardous duty pay if they are serving in a hazardous zone, I dont think they get anything extra for serving at a peaceful base, no matter where it is.
- FD3SA 12y agoIt also noted that currency conversion is the most sophisticated issue in unification as the exchange rate would be largely conditioned on political negotiations and social consensus. Somehow I doubt that currency conversion is the most sophisticated issue. The nuclear-powered dictatorship is also going to require a few brainstorm sessions.
- jfaucett 12y agoCould someone give more background on this? Is the reunification something that's on the table now, is this just planning and hoping? It would be great to see that happen, it'd be great to hear from someone who knows more about this issue.
- kijin 12y agoNothing's on the table as far as what is publicly known. This is just the SK government trying to get prepared for the economic shock of having to absorb NK on short notice, which could happen at any time this century. SK is also sending a message to the international society that we should all prepare for the collapse of NK, while sending a message to Kim Jong Un that "you won't last long, and we know it." Just today, the UN General Assembly approved a resolution to refer NK leaders to the International Criminal Court for human rights violations. Totally unrealistic, to be honest, but I guess this is how political pressure works on the world stage. Timing the "we'll spend $0.5T" press release to coincide with the UN resolution is no doubt intended to increase pressure on NK -- if not directly, then at least indirectly by letting the people of NK know that $0.5T is waiting for them if they can get rid of their Dear Leader. (Yeah, the news is censored there, but I'm sure a few thousand people will have heard of it by this time next year.)
- jfaucett 12y agothanks - that provides some context :)
- threeseed 12y agoI don't see the people of North Korea ever getting rid of their Dear Leader for two reasons: (1) A significant amount of the working population is part of the government apparatchik especially in Pyongyang which is where any uprising would need to start. (2) There is a pervasive culture of fear. Everyone is well aware of the "we will harm you and your entire family tree" approach to keeping everyone in check. There is a culture of people telling on other people and "someone always watching" which makes it hard to trust anyone. So I think the ICC/UN will be key to all of it in particular China/Russia who need to be convinced to abstain from any resolutions. China's speech to the Australian parliament at the G20 was promising in that they are trying to be better citizens in Asia. And Russia surely doesn't want the US to be continuing to use North Korea as an excuse to build anti-missile systems in Eastern Europe.
- threeseed 12y agoI've been twice to North Korea on tours and I just don't see a true reunification happening anytime soon. This isn't like West/East Germany where both sides were still similar. North Korea is a fundamentally different country to South Korea in almost every single way. Any comparison between the two situations is stupid and naive. There are plenty of opportunities for economic integration. But how exactly do you plan to reunify when significant parts of the North Korean government are actively against it i.e. they are doing well under the current regime. Or when the narrative has always been reunification under the DPRK banner ? The only way any of this is happening is if China stops supporting North Korea and the UN Security Council/Agencies puts much of the government in jail for crimes against humanity. Then South Korea would effectively just take over and Pyongyang would be turned into a tourist attraction.
- dominotw 12y ago"One of the biggest misconceptions I think people have of North Korea is that they are simple and naive. But I feel that North Koreans as a group of people have gone through a lot of hardship, and their ability to survive in difficult situations are a lot higher that what people think. People think that unification will be a basketcase for North Koreans, but they will definitely be able to manage. People also think North Koreans will have a hard time adjusting to the market economy, but the black market is also growing under the regime’s nose, and people are used to working in this environment. North Koreans are not naive." From recent Kang Chol Hwan AMA https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/2m87gi/i_spent_ten_years_living_as_a_prisoner_inside_of/cm1vsys https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/2m87gi/i_spent_ten_ye...
- threeseed 12y agoThe issue with all of this isn't the North Korea people. They are well aware of life in South Korea and elsewhere courtesy of all the black market DVDs that have been finding their way there. It's the government filled with old socialist-era guys who surely aren't going to be so willing to just give up their power.
- 12y ago
- brownbat 12y agoFareed Zakaria wrote in 2010 that too few were preparing for an internal meltdown of the NK regime: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/10/17/AR2010101702608.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/10... He describes it as a black swan event that would not come on any predictable timetable, but something that would be far better managed if some preparations were made in advance. Maybe that idea is catching on.
- aaron695 12y agoThe notion of black swan events is rubbish. The theory makes no sense. Even if it was a logical theory that had coherence not sure how it fits here. We know countries unify. We know what happens. You can be sure North and South will one day unify. Yes the only question is when. Prepare to early = big loss. Prepare to late = a loss. It's just about creating a sensible plan on how to deal with something we don't have a timeline on. When will a building have a fire? Who knows, just make a sensible plan for pre and post when it happens. You don't need to call it a black swan. It's just risk management.
- bnjs 12y ago> You can be sure North and South will one day unify. How can we be sure? We know countries unify and we also know that countries split never to be unified again.
- nandemo 12y agoI'm looking forward to Brazil and Uruguay's unification.
- crucialfelix 12y agoYugoslavia will rise again
- GFischer 12y agoYou mean Uruguay and Argentina, right? :P Short summary for non-uruguayans: Uruguay started out as the Spanish piece of the land on the eastern side of the river Uruguay according to the treaty of Tordesillas, and became a disupted frontier between Spain and Portugal. During the May 1810 revolution (Argentinean revolutionaries against Spain), while the capital city was a Spanish stronghold the local leader José Artigas sided with the Argentinean insurgents and founded the United Provinces. Artigas wanted a federal system, but the Buenos Aires leaders wanted centralism. So Uruguay actually became a province of the Federal League. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liga_Federal http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liga_Federal When Uruguay announced its independence from Spain, it became annexed to Argentina. Then Brasil invaded, and it became a Brazilian province for a short time, thus the parent comment.
- verisimilitude 12y agoIn order to understand North Korea, you simply _must_ read Escape from Camp 14[1]. If not, then at least read the Wikipedia entry[2]. Dear lord, it's incredibly tragic... [1]: http://www.amazon.com/dp/0143122916/ http://www.amazon.com/dp/0143122916/ [2]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shin_Dong-hyuk http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shin_Dong-hyuk
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- kayone 12y ago>If the NK regime was to fail, it won't be surprising if China pull a putin and annex NK. If China were to annex NK Wouldn't that remove the buffer? Wouldn't China prefer the west/south to take over north korea and all the costs that comes with it? that way west/south would be too busy with rebuilding north and so deep in costs they would have less time threatening China.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- robbiep 12y agoIf China doesn't annex North korea, then 28,000 American troops sitting on the DMZ have no reason to be there and the justification for high troop deployments to Japan is lessened
- swombat 12y agoI for one totally trust the US military leadership to see things from this point of view and move all those troops out, rather than figuring out excuses and pretexts for keeping the bases there.
- nl 12y agoChina wouldn't annex North Korea, even in the event of a collapse. They are nothing like Putin. OTOH, they wouldn't really want to see Korea unified, unless they think it would increase their influence over South Korea (which it may well).
- trhway 12y ago>russian tech you must be kidding. Russia can't even build a modular space rocket (Angara, last 20 years) which Musk has pretty much built during last 12 years from scratch. All other areas of technology are pretty much non-existent. You are welcome to mention at least one area where "russian tech" does exist (programmers employed in the Russian offices of transnationals obviously don't count :)
- noobermin 12y agoI've talked to Korean friends and they don't want reunification to happen, at least the younger generation do not. After living a life seeing nothing but hatred come from the other side as well as unprovoked attacks on innocent civilians, it's not surprising that that opinion exists. Certainly, the younger generation does not remember a unified Korea at all. It seems like the rest of the world wants them to reunite, but they don't want to.
- schoolixer 12y agoIt isn't a question of desire. If the economy of the north collapses and millions of people are on the verge of famine, the south needs a plan to maintain some sort of order.
- zo1 12y agoI wouldn't think that "order" is what they'd like to maintain. But rather, keep the humanitarian crisis just past it's border from resulting in millions dying.
- richsinn 12y agoNot just the South, but China too. North Korean refugees are already a concern for China.[1] If the economy or the government collapses in North Korea, it's not hard to imagine chaos spilling over in to both countries. [1] http://blogs.piie.com/nk/?p=13422 http://blogs.piie.com/nk/?p=13422
- noobermin 12y agoPerhaps then, the question is how much of the responsibility lies with the South after such a thing occurs. Would SK simply annex NK or would something like a joint/international humanitarian effort to help NK survive and may be start its own government be better? Honestly, I don't have any right to say one way or the other is right because I'm not even Korean, I just think that we in the west need to stop taking as a hypothesis that if NK collapses that it is SK's responsibility. I think it is up to the South Koreans to decide whether they want that, and not us [1]. [1] And yes, that's what this article is about, the government is preparing for this contingency, but as we in the west know, our government doesn't always do what we want.
- munimkazia 12y agoThe article talks about numbers, finance, GDP and economy without explaining the politics of it. How are they going to attempt reunifying with a country which is run by an autocratic regime that has essentially brain washed its citizens into hating the south? Is there going to be military intervention? What about north's nuclear arsenal? Or is it going to be an open reunification where the north government decides to stop ruling and handover the country to the south?
- restalis 12y ago"has essentially brain washed its citizens into hating the south" I've been to DPRK a few years ago, and as far I could see, their state propaganda is not aimed at southern ordinary citizens, but on the government of South Korea. They consider it to be a puppet government in the hands of USA. (There is actually more than that, but I think this reduction is accurate enough.) Overall, they are very open to the idea of having the entire Korea united, and in a lot of instances you can even find maps and logos depicting their country as the entire Korean peninsula.
- contingencies 12y agoThe unspoken assumption throughout the article that the essentially globally failed model of central-bank inflationary capitalism (on someone else's terms) is the de-facto result of de-facto desirable reunification is, I think, the elephant in the room.