4 ms·
I wonder if there's a reason they didn't design the lander with some sort of energy-absorbing material (something analogous to the crush zone in a car) on the b
by lisper 12y ago
I wonder if there's a reason they didn't design the lander with some sort of energy-absorbing material (something analogous to the crush zone in a car) on the bottom of the landing pads to prevent bounces. I thought I'd "wonder out loud" here because someone on HN might actually know the answer.
- shawabawa3 12y agoFrom the article it seems they assumed the comet surface would be a soft layer of dust, absorbing the impact
- Tloewald 12y agoin the initial race to the moon it was widely speculated that the moon was covered in a deep layer of ultrafine dust, and any spacecraft landing on it would be liable to sink. Arthur C. Clarke's novel "A Fall of Moondust" was based on this thinking. It seems astronomers have a bias towards assuming dust will cover stuff. Perhaps this says something about their office space.
- hnal943 12y agoI thought they calculated the amount of dust that based on the current rate dust accumulation and extrapolating based on the believed age of the universe. It's a little surprising we have not corrected that thought since the moon landing.
- Tloewald 12y agoWho's to know why they were wrong — it's just amusing to see the same error come up again. I prefer the theory that they look around their offices and extrapolate ;-)
- dandelany 12y agoThey weren't wrong, there's plenty of dust on the comet. The first photo of the initial landing site is visible precisely because of the shadow cast by a giant cloud of dust kicked up by the lander.
- Tloewald 12y agoThey were wrong about the amount of dust, not the presence of dust -- as was the case with the moon landing. There's plenty of dust on the moon, too, just not oceans of it.
- callahad 12y agoThe legs were actually designed to dampen the impact and use that energy to drive ice screws into the comet: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-77-Z_DHTlY#t=1m40 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-77-Z_DHTlY#t=1m40
- lisper 12y agoI see. Thanks!
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- bunderbunder 12y agoIts landing was supposed to be softened by a thruster, which didn't work, and it was supposed to be held fast upon landing by harpoons, but they also failed. They presumably did use some shock absorbtion, but it was probably engineered under the assumption that at least some of the rest of the landing system would have worked.
- hughes 12y agoThe thruster, if it had fired, would actually have propelled the lander towards the comet. The idea is that it would hold the lander in place against the ground, not slow the lander's descent.
- woodchuck64 12y agoReally too bad the harpoons failed. Why I wonder? http://image.slidesharecdn.com/rosettamediabriefing16octbiele-141016091057-conversion-gate02/95/rosetta-media-briefing-16-october-dr-jens-biele-dlr-philae-lander-payload-manager-16-638.jpg?cb=1413468719 http://image.slidesharecdn.com/rosettamediabriefing16octbiel...
- coob 12y agoThe thrusters to counteract the force of the harpoons were bust.
- bunderbunder 12y agoApparently the propellant they used was found (after launch, unfortunately) to be unreliable in a vacuum. http://www.wired.com/2013/10/in-space-no-one-can-hear-your-nitrocellulose-explode/ http://www.wired.com/2013/10/in-space-no-one-can-hear-your-n...
- ryandvm 12y agoOuch. This strikes me as a particularly avoidable mistake.
- 12y ago