36 ms·
Then you understand wrong. According to Snowden's documents, the NSA has diminished its powers under the Obama administration (e.g., bulk collection of email he
by lern_too_spel 12y ago
Then you understand wrong. According to Snowden's documents, the NSA has diminished its powers under the Obama administration (e.g., bulk collection of email headers for feeding their social graph and proposing to end bulk collection of call log data).
- adventured 12y agoThe NSA has drastically increased its powers and data collection under the Obama Administration. 1) Snowden said these programs have gotten dramatically worse under Obama. He has said that numerous times. 2) Prior to Obama's election, it didn't have all the tech companies lined up into XKeyscore. That was put into place on his watch. 3) The NSA also was not yet illegally tapping into and stealing bulk data from these companies via interception, to get around collection restraints. 4) The NSA's massive Utah data center was built during his Administration. 5) In 2009 Obama's DOJ admitted to illegal surveillance abuses, and claimed steps had been taken to correct such. They lied of course, they did the exact opposite: they massively expanded surveillance. http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/16/us/16nsa.html http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/16/us/16nsa.html 6) The U.S. Marshals Service overflight program came into existence during Obama's Administration. The service was initiated in 2007, and the flight program was put into place by the Obama Administration. Worth noting: he also didn't stop it, he expanded the program. 7) The NSA began actively helping other agencies illegally (eg the DEA), via parallel construction, during Obama's Administration. This practice has massively expanded under Obama's watch. 9) Obama also loves to use the Espionage Act to persecute journalists that act to reveal the dirt of his Administration. 10) The Obama Administration continued to lie about the programs. The Obama Administration continued to refuse to admit their existence. The Obama Administration massively expanded all surveillance programs. This is all continuing right now. 11) During Obama's watch, the Stingray device has gone from being a piece of military technology, to being handed down from the Federal level to the local and state level. During his Administration, efforts have been made to expand illegal surveillance from the domain of the Federal Government, and to ensure widespread surveillance at all levels, so the Feds have a greater total access to communications. There has never been a more abusive surveillance President in US history. And there are another easy dozen items on this list, of abuses by the Obama Presidency when it comes to surveillance.
- lern_too_spel 12y ago1) As I've already shown and will continue to show in this post, Snowden's own documents refute this. Snowden clearly didn't have time to look at what the documents he spidered actually say. 2) Xkeyscore is merely a database and does not constitute new surveillance. Snowden's documents show that it contains fewer sources under Obama (no more email metadata). 3) The NSA significantly reduced the scope of its upstream collection under Obama in April 2012. http://fas.org/irp/agency/doj/fisa/fisc0912.pdf&ved=0CB4QFjAB&usg=AFQjCNHOnLiH-z9ZCtai5B8Py1RnXu0rcQ&sig2=mxzyVWOwvKtNKaPJFzpycQ http://fas.org/irp/agency/doj/fisa/fisc0912.pdf&ved=0CB4QFjA... 4) A datacenter does not constitute new surveillance, whether it's built or not (not). 5) Your article says that Obama's DOJ found pre-Obama abuses, once again, the exact opposite of what you claim. Your claim that Obama lied about taking steps to fix this are unsupported by any of your links. Simply stating something does not make it so. 6) There is no proof that the overflights are recording data from anybody other than the targets. You're engaging in wild speculation here. 7) According to my link above, this claim is false. The NSA shut down any ability to assist in parallel reconstruction with upstream data in 2012. 8) There is no 8. 9) Again, false. No journalist has ever been prosecuted (or persecuted) with the espionage Act. http://blogs.reuters.com/alison-frankel/2013/06/24/journalists-and-the-espionage-act-prosecution-risk-is-remote-but-real/ http://blogs.reuters.com/alison-frankel/2013/06/24/journalis... 10) More unsourced claims. What expansion? 11) There is no evidence that the Stingray records data from anybody other than the target. http://m.wsj.com/articles/BL-DGB-23163 http://m.wsj.com/articles/BL-DGB-23163 Where does this leave us? Three counts of reduced NSA powers (email headers and other upstream collection and phone records) and zero counts of increased powers.
- xnull2guest 12y ago1.) ... 2.) Isn't this like saying python doesn't add any new programming capabilities over hand written assembly? Having full-take data in a database, all in one place under the hands on one agency DOES constitute new surveillance. Also to be clear the XKEYSCORE program uses metadata to search but will return full content in the query response. It is a database with full-take data. 3.) http://fas.org/irp/agency/doj/fisa/fisc0912.pdf&ved=0CB4QFjAB&usg=AFQjCNHOnLiH-z9ZCtai5B8Py1RnXu0rcQ&sig2=mxzyVWOwvKtNKaPJFzpycQ http://fas.org/irp/agency/doj/fisa/fisc0912.pdf&ved=0CB4QFjA... resolves to http://fas.org/404-not-found/ http://fas.org/404-not-found/ for me. From what I can tell, however, lots of upstream collection has happened during the Obama administration. Would you care to provide another link? 4.) Covered in 2. 5.) Agreed about his link. Let's talk about this one. http://www.theguardian.com/world/interactive/2013/dec/18/nsa-review-panel-report-document http://www.theguardian.com/world/interactive/2013/dec/18/nsa... 6.) They are recording the data. But they presumably delete it if it isn't related to their case. It is known that there are no formal safeguards - the deletion of data is enforced merely by policy. 7.) Again we need a new link. But I don't understand how shutting down of upstream data collection could imply no assistance in parallel construction. Could you expand? 8.) ... 9.) You can use the threat to persecute journalists, which is what I believe the parent is talking about. Furthermore other laws are used in its place (e.g. Risen). 10.) > The Obama Administration continued to lie about the programs. The Obama Administration continued to refuse to admit their existence. This is all continuing right now. Do you agree with these sentences? > The Obama Administration massively expanded all surveillance programs. I think the parent is speaking generally about the growth of the budget and capabilities of the NSA during the Obama Administration including the Utah Facility, the renewal of the spying programs and Patriot Act by the administration, and legislature that would have (had it passed) expanded the NSA's ability to look directly at content without having to make requests to corporations. 11.) Back to 6.