5 ms·
"Earlier this year, German politician Patrick Sensburg announced that Germany’s government officials might start using typewriters, as they are seen as being an
by joezydeco 12y ago
"Earlier this year, German politician Patrick Sensburg announced that Germany’s government officials might start using typewriters, as they are seen as being an “unhackable” technology."
Yeah, about that...
http://legalinsurrection.com/2014/07/using-old-school-typewriters-will-not-protect-you-from-snooping/ http://legalinsurrection.com/2014/07/using-old-school-typewr...
http://www.magicmargin.net/2012/12/silencing-chatty-selectrics-operation.html http://www.magicmargin.net/2012/12/silencing-chatty-selectri...
Unless they're going back to mechanical ones.
- yzzxy 12y ago(Nonmechanical) computer keyboards, relatively quiet in the world of text input technology, have been found to be extremely vulnerable to acoustic attack: http://www.cs.berkeley.edu/~tygar/papers/Keyboard_Acoustic_Emanations_Revisited/tiss.preprint.pdf http://www.cs.berkeley.edu/~tygar/papers/Keyboard_Acoustic_E... A mechanical or electric typewriter full of moving parts? Sounds like side channel city to me.
- 001sky 12y agoIf your using a mechanical typewriter, your likely not in a public (and/or pre-deterined place). This forces an attacker into a cumbersome, intrusive, and maybe-evidence-left-behind espionage scenario (B&E). That in and of itself is quite useful.
- nitrogen 12y agoOr just shine a laser or RF beam at the window and read the vibrations.
- 001sky 12y agoyou'd have to have either a permanent installation or exquisite timing. again, the greatly narrows down attack surface. you might be able to surveil small lots of targets this way, but it would be harder than you think. Again, if your a stuxtnet-level target, you're not going to be safe...but that's not really most people...is it? Your normal-ish executive will have the ability to work in places without LOS from non-credentialed personell (eg, high rise apartment, gated community, interior conference rooms, etc). The NSA or MI6 could of course rent the flat across the street, or have a sub-contractor con his way into employment, but this type of stuff is outside the remit of your basic opportunistic threat. And it leaves evidence and paper trails unless you are the mossad or cia whomever and can fake identities like passports, bank accounts, etc.
- DanBC 12y agoLess effective if there's more than one typewriter in the room or if the curtains are drawn.
- yzzxy 12y agoWouldn't airgapped computers have almost the same effect? EM sidechannels are probably comparable to acoustic for espionage difficulty.
- rtpg 12y agoEven for mechanical ones, isn't it possible to read off the ribbons to see what someone has typed? Granted, there are no spaces but we can still get the gist I imagine.
- DrStalker 12y agoI'd assume that ribbons get securely disposed of, just like old documents/backup tapes/etc.
- WalterBright 12y agoGood luck with my old typewriter ribbons. I'd rewind and use them over and over, even the ones that tried to prevent you from rewinding them.
- jonnathanson 12y agoTypewriters are subject to attack, but it's a much more laborious and non-scalable process. It requires social engineering, infiltration, or else planting bugs, intercepting shipments, etc. It can be done, and certainly was done, back in the age of typewriters. But it requires some old-fashioned, boots-on-the-ground fieldwork. It's a lot tougher to place bugs in embassies today than it was in the 1970s. And in some respects, it's logistically tougher than hacking into computers, which can be done from any location on Earth. (Which is not to say that computer hacking doesn't benefit from social engineering strategies, of course). "Unhackable" is a poor choice of words -- more like "practically speaking, tougher to hack." This is a speed bump, not a roadblock. Of course, if the US were to adopt this sort of strategy, we'd have to make sure we're manufacturing the typewriters domestically. Which probably means setting up a puppet company somewhere in the States, purely for the sake of making typewriters for government contracts. And then you'd have to make sure that company isn't socially engineered, infiltrated, or hacked. And so on, and so forth.
- lukifer 12y ago> Typewriters are subject to attack, but it's a much more laborious and non-scalable process. I definitely subscribe to the idea that security is not about making unauthorized access impossible (no such thing), but rather about making it prohibitively expensive (both in terms of resources and risk). In that light, it should surprise no one that government agencies have always had the ability to spy on citizens when sufficiently motivated. What is truly concerning is that per-capita, it is becoming more and more affordable for agencies to spy on every single person everywhere, all the time.
- jonnathanson 12y ago"I definitely subscribe to the idea that security is not about making unauthorized access impossible (no such thing), but rather about making it prohibitively expensive (both in terms of resources and risk)." Exactly. There is no such thing as a foolproof security strategy. Anyone who tells you his plan is foolproof has already proven himself a fool. Security is about protection, mitigation, and contingencies. It is not about full-stop prevention. Build a 100-foot wall, and I'll build a 101-foot ladder. (Proverbially speaking, of course). "What is truly concerning is that per-capita, it is becoming more and more affordable for agencies to spy on every single person everywhere, all the time." This is probably 50% of what concerns me. The other 50% is the coming revolution in analysis. I use that word so strongly as to place it in <em>sterisks. Advances in machine learning will allow us to find needles in the mountains and mountains of haystacks that we're collecting now. It is truly marvelous (and also scary, depending upon your point of view) to consider what one could make of the most seemingly mundane of patterns and breadcrumbs.
- swartkrans 12y ago> Unless they're going back to mechanical ones. I've been going back to cash instead of using credit cards because I've been exposed twice now via Target and Home Depot. I want to even avoid using ATMs and go into the bank to get cash because you can't really even tell when an ATM has a malicious card scanner installed. Once we have automated cars maybe we'll go be back to walking and riding bikes to avoid being victimized by remote car jacking. Imagine the mess hijacked delivery drones might cause. Your phone can be cloned remotely. You can't easily clone a rotary phone that plugs into the wall. I'm definitely not looking to automate my home, especially after reading how Chinese hacker had installed back doors on wall mounted AC devices or whatever which had access to the internal network at the New York Times building to keep infiltrating and reinfecting all the machines on the network. Maybe we jumped into the digital world a little bit too quickly.
- xur17 12y agoSerious question - why do you very concerned if your credit card number is stolen? By law, credit cards have > 30 days (I forget the exact amount) of fraud protection as long as you report it. The only downside I can see is the pain of getting a new card. Your money really isn't at risk. That said, I do agree that security is becoming a major issue in our world.
- swartkrans 12y agoYeah there are laws, but you have to catch it, and you have to report it and sometimes you don't realize you've been defrauded until months later. Hackers in my experience don't empty your account out, they charge $30 here, $19.99 here, sign up for this thing for a monthly charge of $9 you didn't realize. My time and stress costs me. And you can lose money. It's best to just not have to deal with it. My credit card number has been put up for sale twice now, twice. Because I used it at a Target and a Home Depot. Ok, I just don't want to go through that again. I don't care if there are laws, if I use cash, I'll be fine. It's no problem, cash is accepted everywhere. I'm not likely to be mugged where I live and I don't carry a lot of money.
- 12y ago