4 ms·
Did your ISP make an illegal copy of your email?
by tedunangst 12y ago
Did your ISP make an illegal copy of your email?
- Dylan16807 12y agoThe DMCA is so biased that it doesn't matter.
- Animats 12y agoThat's the beauty of it. It's hard to waive the anti-circumvention provisions of the DMCA. The law says "no person shall circumvent", not "no person shall circumvent without permission". I just sent a note on this to the EFF.
- DanBC 12y agoThey don't need to make a copy to fall foul of the anti-circumvention parts of the law. See also unlocking phones to any carrier where no copying was involved. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2009/04/dmca-hearings-phone- https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2009/04/dmca-hearings-phone-
- tedunangst 12y agoNot sure that's entirely comparable. SSL stripping doesn't make any long term modifications to your device or program. In particular, it takes place before the protected work is transmitted. Cracking encryption would more clearly be circumvention of a protected work, but if the protected work doesn't yet exist, can circumvention exist?
- DanBC 12y agoIt doesn't matter if it's making long term modifications to devices or software. The law is about "circumventing", not about "long term modification". Again, this is not about copying the email; it doesn't matter that the circumvention is done before the copy-righted work is transmitted. Encrypting your email is preventing access to those emails. Thus, it seems to be covered by DMCA anti-circumvention. http://www.copyright.gov/legislation/dmca.pdf http://www.copyright.gov/legislation/dmca.pdf > Section 1201 divides technological measures into two categories: measures that prevent unauthorized access to a copyrighted work and measures that prevent unauthorized copying of a copyrighted work. Making or selling devices or services that are used to circumvent either category of technological measure is prohibited in certain circumstances, described below. As to the act of circumvention in itself, the provision prohibits circumventing the first category of technological measures, but not the second.
- tedunangst 12y agoStill not convinced this would hold up. The lack of encryption is apparent to the sender before the DATA is transmitted; the decision to proceed even so could be construed as consent.
- jessedhillon 12y agoImagine you were shipping something large and top-secret across country. Then, after the trucking company picks up your shipping container, they paint with a substance that makes it transparent. They're not copying or even looking inside to see what's there, but they've defeated your ability to hide your secrets as they are in transit. What would you think of that situation?
- tedunangst 12y agoI think it's possible for SSL stripping to simultaneously be a bad thing and not a DMCA violation.
- jessedhillon 12y agoWouldn't you think the shipping company is circumventing your countermeasures, despite not having copied your cargo?
- tedunangst 12y agoIf that's what were happening, sure. But it's not. This is akin to the shipping company saying "sorry, only clear containers are permitted. Do you still want to ship it?" And then you saying "sure, go ahead."
- Animats 12y agoYou're thinking about the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act. This is a different law.