4 ms·
I'm one of the folks working on the GNOME defense campaign. Happy to answer any questions people might have.
by JoshTriplett 12y ago
I'm one of the folks working on the GNOME defense campaign. Happy to answer any questions people might have.
- perrupa 12y agoCan you guys just rename it to genome to skirt this whole issue please? :)
- golgappi 12y agoThe terrorists want to turn everyone to Muslims and kill them all. Can we just end all other religions, convert to Islam and then willingly get murdered to skirt the whole war against terrorism issue, please?
- JoshTriplett 12y agoWe have no intention of just giving up, no.
- hobs 12y agoI think the people replying to this thread think you are working for groupon. That is the only way this makes any sense.
- JoshTriplett 12y agoGah! No, definitely not; I'm helping with the GNOME defense campaign.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ivraatiems 12y agoNot op, but GNOME had the name first...
- JoshTriplett 12y agoWhen the GNOME foundation chose it, back in 1997, it was an acronym for "GNU Network Object Model Environment". (And it's pronounced with a non-silent 'G', just like GNU.)
- icoder 12y agoTIL I have been pronouncing it wrong all this time. Which may be the result of my background in genetics though :)
- michaelx386 12y agoThey say Groupon's Gnome is an operating system, do you know any details of how they built it? Is it Linux based, etc?
- JoshTriplett 12y agoIt seems to be based on iOS.
- alexholehouse 12y agoWait what? They built an 'iOS based operating system'? I don't understand how that would be possible?
- Beltiras 12y agoHave you opened a dialog with Groupon and if so, can you share anything of that communication?
- JoshTriplett 12y agoFrom the article we posted at https://gnome.org/groupon/ https://gnome.org/groupon/: > we nevertheless got in touch with them and asked them to pick another name. Not only did Groupon refuse, but it has now filed even more trademark applications
- anoncow 12y agoHi Josh. Can you give us Groupon's perspective on this issue?
- JoshTriplett 12y agoI'm working with the GNOME foundation, not with Groupon. Our perspective on Groupon: > It was almost inconceivable to us that Groupon, with over $2.5 billion in annual revenue, a full legal team and a huge engineering staff would not have heard of the GNOME project, found our trademark registration using a casual search, or even found our website, but we nevertheless got in touch with them and asked them to pick another name. Not only did Groupon refuse, but it has now filed even more trademark applications
- alasdair_ 12y agohttps://engineering.groupon.com/2014/misc/gnome-foundation-and-groupon-product-names/ https://engineering.groupon.com/2014/misc/gnome-foundation-a... "We love open source at Groupon. We have open sourced a number of projects on github. Our relationship with the open source community is more important to us than a product name. We’ve been communicating with the Gnome Foundation for months to try to come to a mutually satisfactory resolution, including alternative branding options, and we’re happy to continue those conversations. And if we can’t come up with a resolution, we’ll be glad to look for another name."
- gooseus 12y agoCan you also sue them for frivolousness or something like that?
- JoshTriplett 12y agoWe're exploring many options. :) I can't say anything about specific plans for legal actions, sorry.
- zanny 12y agoIf you guys could bankrupt Groupon, take all the money, and hire an army of devs to make Gstreamer, Pulseaudio, Avahi, CUPs, Telepathy, Wayland, etc great (I think the GNOME desktop itself is in really good shape, just the internals need love), I'd go to the victory parade.
- jordigh 12y agoWhy that amount of money? Is that how much the SFLC needs? I assume you're picking the SFLC to represent you, right? Does the FSF handle any of Gnome's finances? As a GNU package, I thought there still was a relationship between the FSF and Gnome. I ask because as a fellow GNU-in-arms, I might be able to make a case for sending you a bit of Octave's money. We gotta look out for each other, right?
- JoshTriplett 12y ago> Why that amount of money? Our counsel has advised us that we will need that much to oppose the registration of the first set of 10 trademark applications. > Is that how much the SFLC needs? I assume you're picking the SFLC to represent you, right? We're currently working with pro-bono counsel from an independent attorney. The amount is how much we've been advised that we'll need to successfully defend the trademark. > Does the FSF handle any of Gnome's finances? No; the GNOME Foundation is an independent 501(c)3. > As a GNU package, I thought there still was a relationship between the FSF and Gnome. Not a financial relationship, but GNOME is still part of the GNU project. > I ask because as a fellow GNU-in-arms, I might be able to make a case for sending you a bit of Octave's money. We gotta look out for each other, right? The thought is appreciated, but if you're talking about funds donated to GNU Octave, I don't think that'd be appropriate. We're raising funds specifically for this defense campaign, rather than using general donations to GNOME; for the same reason, we shouldn't be using donations people offered to Octave for Octave development. But thanks for your consideration. One thing you could do: we'd appreciate it if you promoted the campaign further across other projects, such as via the news feeds and social media accounts of those projects.
- jordigh 12y ago> The thought is appreciated, but if you're talking about funds donated to GNU Octave, I don't think that'd be appropriate. The funds were donated to the FSF for Octave. However, many of us in Octave use Gnome, so I could see a point in saying that we in Octave need to ensure that Gnome works well for us. Also, we collect the funds in a rather ambiguous language, without any promise of how they will be spent, within the boundaries of the FSF's 503(c). > One thing you could do: we'd appreciate it if you promoted the campaign further across other projects, such as via the news feeds and social media accounts of those projects. We don't have much of a web presence, but I'll promote the Gnome problem in whatever scanty resources we have. Of course, the FSF is also doing this for you, right?
- zemanel 12y agoGnome has definitely had an impact on my career, as it was my desktop of choice for a long time, both professionally and at home. Thank you for your hard work, i've donated $50 (not much but). Go get them boys :)
- alasdair_ 12y agoGiven the statement from Groupon (https://engineering.groupon.com/2014/misc/gnome-foundation-and-groupon-product-names/ https://engineering.groupon.com/2014/misc/gnome-foundation-a...) that if they can't work something out with you, they will choose another name, do you still plan on raising the $80K?
- natch 12y agoObviously Groupon's definition of "working something out" would include doing so by brute force (bulldozing over Gnome's interest with lawyers and money), so you have to read what they say carefully, and not assume they are giving up.
- JoshTriplett 12y agoWell said. The tone of that response doesn't match the tone of our previous attempts at discussion. We'll have to see how things go.