6 ms·
This Verbal Confrontation Shows Why Walmart Will Never Accept Apple Pay
- wilde 12y agoI think I'm missing something. How does Apple Pay have enough info to generate the larger payload they're looking for if you add cards by typing in the number?
- ploxiln 12y agoApple Pay gets the lower rate just because they decided it does, there's no real technical reason. The technical answer was just re-iterating that with the full technical terms. If you think about it, until chip-and-pin is required in the US, there's not really more security for card-present transactions in the US. Anything they read from the card when they swipe and use to validate the transaction could be intercepted, saved, and written to another card. So it's all arbitrary. Sometimes they ask for your zip code, so they get a better rate. Sometimes (often) they ask for the csc online, so they get a better rate. I guess the statistics work out, but from a technical security point of view, it all seems not really secure.
- ghshephard 12y agoYou can't just add a credit card to an iPhone - it has to be validated against the owners account. The data Being sent to the Nfc terminal can't be used for anything other than that transaction, and it's generated by the secure element on the iPhone.
- stock_toaster 12y ago> it has to be validated against the owners account Indeed. I had to actually call my bank and get them to authorize my card for apple pay. * take picture of card, enter CSC/code * call bank (tell them a bunch of things about me to verify I am me) * bank authorizes card for apple pay
- prostoalex 12y agohttp://www.zdnet.com/apple-pay-and-security-could-tokenization-be-the-tool-that-curbs-data-breaches-7000033585/ http://www.zdnet.com/apple-pay-and-security-could-tokenizati... [Apple Pay] "Tokenization removes the actual credit card number and replaces it with a randomly generated number. That number, or token, can be configured to expire after one purchase or made specific to a certain transaction, making it a useless target for hackers or fraudsters. But what's more, tokenization removes a huge storage burden from merchants, since they never see a person's actual credit card information and it never enters their POS system or online payment portal. Now, Apple didn't invent tokenization. But by taking the tokenization route, the Cupertino powerhouse could be looking to ride the security wave all the way to payment success, especially considering the rising number of merchant data breaches and instances of stolen credit card information that continue to hit the payment and retail industries."
- fpgeek 12y ago> But what's more, tokenization removes a huge storage burden from merchants, since they never see a person's actual credit card information and it never enters their POS system or online payment portal. Yes, merchants think that getting additional customer-identifying information that forces them to run extra analyses on the mountains of transaction data they warehouse is a huge burden they'd like to be relieved of. </sarcasm>
- prostoalex 12y agoDon't most of them use loyalty cards for that purpose anyways? Target's data http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/business/2014/03/11/target-customer-traffic/6262059/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/business/2014/03/11/targ... showed showed that customer visits, sales and profits decreased significantly following the breach. They would probably be happy to offload that nightmare onto somebody else.
- fpgeek 12y agoAs I understand it, retailers use loyalty cards to improve their customer-level data and as a way to act on that data (e.g. targeted coupons), but even the baseline they can extract without loyalty cards is very important to them. In fact, even after last year's breach, Target clearly isn't happy offloading that nightmare. They're currently teting CurrentC: http://www.dispatch.com/content/stories/business/2014/11/10/target-testing-its-own-mobile-app-hopeful-that-it-can-rival-apple-pay.html http://www.dispatch.com/content/stories/business/2014/11/10/...
- evanspa 12y agoWhen you provision a card to Apple Pay by taking a photo of your card or entering the info manually, what happens next is that the iPhone makes a call to the card network (Visa/MC/Amex) to verify the card data (the card network will also make a call to the issuing bank of the card for a validity check), and if all is well, the network will return the same information that is effectively provisioned to physical ICC chips that you see in newer credit/debit cards. These parameters are stored in the iPhone 6's secure element, and allow the iPhone to perform full EMV transactions. One difference between these parameters and those provisioned to a physical ICC on a new debit/credit card, is that the card number (PAN) is not used; instead a payment token is used (it looks like a PAN - it has the same number of digits, etc). This allows Apple Pay transactions to run on the same infrastructure as chip+pin/signature transactions.
- zaroth 12y agoWalmart's Mike Cook asks an interesting question; At a physical store, if you use any other mobile app, like LevelUp, then the merchant pays the higher 'card-not-present' rate. The same transaction with Apple Pay pays the lower 'card-present' rate. But an in-app purchase on an iPhone still charges the 'card-not-present' rate. Visa's Jim McCarty's response is, "Fundamentally because the payload is different. One is a full EMV track read transaction and the other is not." "Because it's a rule that y'all made?" "No, because the data doesn't flow. It's why the standard was written like that." ... and then later Jim quips... "That's the first time Mike's complained about getting the card-present rate." which the moderator replies "OK, that gets the best answer beer." The format of the packet is irrelevant. The security properties are derived from the user interaction points. Specifically, Alice loads her card into Apple Pay by taking a picture of it. A week later Alice uses her phone to pay with Apple Pay and the merchant would get a card-present rate. Can any other app do the same thing? Is there an open standard which allows LevelUp (who currently is forced to pay card-not-present) to use the same exact steps and get the same favorable rate? If not, I think Cook has a very valid point. Apple Pay wins by default if they are the only mobile app in town which can get a card-present rate. I assume Google Wallet is card-not-present, for example. Merchants won't pay a higher rate so you can use some app. Jim McCarty specifically mentions the scale problem with changing brick & mortar merchants card-not-present rates.
- fpgeek 12y agoAccording to this: http://www.quora.com/Is-Google-Wallet-considered-a-card-present-or-card-not-present-transaction http://www.quora.com/Is-Google-Wallet-considered-a-card-pres... Google Wallet is card-present for the merchant, but card-not-present between Google and the consumer. I guess that means Google is eating the difference between the two rates (and/or has other tricks up their sleeve).
- demallien 12y agoI would imagine that it is because brick and mortar merchants are a lower fraud risk than an online property. Don't forget that visa and MasterCard suck up fraud on both sides of the transaction. Which is not to say that there aren't shenanigans going on, but there's a reason that consumers really like MasterCard and visa, they both look after customer interests, sometimes at the expense of merchants.
- briandear 12y agoThe idea that WalMart is paying a high percentage is nonsense. For an commerce startup I work with, we're getting .5% from First Data. I'm sure WalMart can do better than us. This is about something else.
- thaumaturgy 12y agoEven .5% at Wal-Mart scale is a lot. Regardless, it's a bad enough situation that in March Wal-Mart withdrew from a $7.5 billion settlement to continue its own lawsuit against Visa et al: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014-03-27/wal-mart-sues-visa-claiming-card-transaction-fee-fixing.html http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014-03-27/wal-mart-sues-visa-... I found a few other articles that support the guess that the big retailers are in the middle of an all-out war with their credit card processors (e.g. http://www.csmonitor.com/Business/new-economy/2011/0413/Credit-card-swipe-fees-US-firms-pay-too-much-and-it-hurts-consumers http://www.csmonitor.com/Business/new-economy/2011/0413/Cred..., http://www.forbes.com/sites/danielfisher/2012/07/24/wal-marts-swipe-fees-are-a-political-weapon-against-visa/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/danielfisher/2012/07/24/wal-mart...), so now CurrentC and the rejection of Apple Pay makes a little more sense. I didn't get it before.
- nemothekid 12y agoYahoo Finance says Yahoo's current profit margin is 3%. (Most others of the top 10 most valuable companies in the world are at 20-30%). If you are only making $3 for every $100, 50 cents is huge - thats nearly 15% of your profits you are paying out to CC processing.
- ohsnap 12y agoWalmart pays over 2%. Probably a hidden variable in the .5% number.
- ewang1 12y agoIs that 0.5% total or 0.5%+interchange? 0.5% total sounds unbelievably low.
- alkonaut 12y agoThe article mentions cards linked to a customers checking account. I assume that means a "debit card", i.e. one where transactions are deducted immediately rather than aggregated into a monthly bill? How common are those cards in the US? Here (.se), most Visa and Mastercards are bank-issued debit cards, and almost everyone would have such a card, even if they also have a credit card from Visa/MasterCard. Is the situation the same in the US?
- tombrossman 12y agoIn the US you would typically get one of these debit cards automatically with your checking account, and it works as you describe. If you want a credit card you would have to submit a separate credit application at the same (or different if you like) bank and that would be a completely different card with its own account and terms. I think this is the same in most countries.
- alkonaut 12y agoOk. Guess the difference is not technical but cultural, here the debit cards are used more frequently, and many never get a credit card. I do think we have bonuses on many cards, but I have never found them appealing enough to switch to a pay-later system. I prefer knowing the balance all the time. I use mine only for work expenses and "future" expenses such as flights, where an airline going bankrupt would be problematic if I had already paid the ticket up front. Maybe we also have less fraud since chip+pin is used everywhere?
- andybak 12y agoSame in the UK. Debit cards (with Chip+Pin) are pretty much the default
- ubernostrum 12y agoDebit cards come free with most bank accounts here. But the fraud-protection laws give you much more protection for a credit card than a debit card, so many people who have both only ever use the debit card to withdraw cash from an ATM, and use the credit card for purchasing things. Also, among the types of people likely to have and use luxury-device payment systems (like brand-new iPhones), typically credit cards are coming with some type of "reward" for use -- some give "cash back" (you get refunded a certain percentage of what you spend), some give points/miles for hotels or airlines, etc., which creates another incentive to use the credit card rather than the debit card.
- MrJagil 12y agoI'm sorry, but what is the god damn deal with those video players? I am so so tired of companies and sites building their own _always_ shitty video player, and then it's like they don't even test them! And Recode! A site for tech enthusiasts, made by tech enthusiasts! I am so confused, sitting in hazy cloud of memories of real player... On a mac, neither safari nor chrome will allow me to watch the video.
- chris_wot 12y agoI'm on Windows, and it won't run for me on Firefox or Chrome. Dunno what the deal is here, but I fully agree with you - whatever they are using, it sucks.
- tombrossman 12y agoSame here on Linux. I don't have Flash installed but it claims to work with 'either the Flash Plugin or an HTML5-Video enabled browser'. Both FF & Chromium (HTML5 enabled for sure) won't play it. Disappointing to see them outsource video with such poor results.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- zimbatm 12y agoTry removing your ad-blocker maybe ?
- lsaferite 12y agoNo ad blocker here (Win 8/Chrome) and it won't work for me either.
- manicdee 12y agoiPad user here. The two minute ad played perfectly fine, despite being a pile of buzzwords rammed together with beautiful young women in the hopes of convincing someone that the product/service was worth investigating. The video did not play. Just black space for three minutes Neil I gave up waiting for the two minute segment to load.
- acex 12y agoan article from recode.net - really? a fox news of tech.
- netcan 12y agoIt's interesting to think of how various technology-business complexes could have unfolded differently f they had gotten onto a different track. What if Google had been bought pre-IPO? Could the World Wide Web have "lost" to some other technology, perhaps centrally controlled? etc. You end up with a lot os scenarios where certain things get set back decades. It's hard to imagine WWW and its internet riding siblings thriving in the same way under some different paradigm. The creative zeal of the telecommunications industry is not a force I would like to rely on for progress. Anyway, I think that most "money" industries might be like the web if it hadn't hit some lucky breaks. Financial services, ways of moving money from one place to another are incredibly clunky, bureaucratic, expensive, difficult to understand, slow, expensive and expensive. Credit cards are expensive, complicated, & oligopolistic. Bank transfers are slow and bureaucratic. It's ridiculous that heavy, stealable, physical money is cheaper to handle than electronic variants. This is all a very straightforward example of "transaction costs," a concept at the centre of many basic and fundamental economics theories. Basically, transaction costs permeate everything in economics by reducing efficiency and limiting the velocity and cumulative volume of transactions, which are one of the few very basic elements in the economics' periodic table (say, resources, labour, technology, consumption & transactions… or something). Many massive efforts have been made to reduce transactions costs in the form of barriers to entry or international trade. Transaction costs inherent in our financial services industry are the same sort of problem, probably even more important. A 10, 100 or 1000X reduction in transaction costs could have a lever effect on the economy similar to the discovery of a new energy source, continent, new method of communication, better legal paradigm or some other fundamental column in an economy. This is why I was (and still am) hoping for cryptocurrencies to succeed. Who knows where it could go. Whatever you think of Walmart, they are obsessed with costs and efficiency. I'm not surprised this pushes their buttons. The suboptimal state of electronic payment is as bad or worse than the energy industry in the worst days of cartels.
- hownottowrite 12y agoApple's never had any problem hiding behind rules and standards they write for their own walled gardens. Why start complaining now? Better to take action. Just pull their products from retailers who won't roll over. It's what Bezos would do. They could also subsidize purchases made at flagship Apple Pay partners. They have the cash for it. $1B in subsidies to happy retailers would have a punishing effect on those who decided not to play. With the thin margins in retail, that would like translate to quarterly results questions like "why aren't you taking the free money from Apple?" Or "How has turning down Apple Pay hurt your business? Company X reports a healthy jump of Y."
- aaronem 12y agoYoung bull, old bull. Credit card associations don't overtly lean on anyone much, and neither need Apple do so now that it's working with them. As Apple Pay gains traction, the same effect will come into play on its behalf that keeps merchants paying fees to take plastic -- people used to using Apple Pay will take their business to merchants which allow them to do so, and merchants who don't will come to understand that half a loaf is better than none.
- amelius 12y agoSigh, why do we even allow a company to build quasi monopolies like this?
- wfjackson 12y agoNot sure if you're referring to Walmart or VISA/MasterCard.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- transpy 12y agoThat website... where is the volume control? And if I want to re-watch the clip, I have to re-watch the damn 25 second long commercial! And I have to sign up in order to comment. Horrible website.