8 ms·
How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shutting down Silkroad 2.0
- throwaway7808 12y ago""" More to the point, if you're buying drugs online you're not supporting local drug dealers and the crime and violence that typically accompany open air drug markets, particularly in inner cities. By cutting those sellers out of the equation, you're seeing a net reduction in violence overall.
- danielweber 12y ago"Buy local! Except for drugs!" How do you actually get your drugs if you buy them on Silk Road? Do you have UPS bring the MDMA to your door?
- rwmj 12y agoBasically yes - they are sent through the post.
- shawabawa3 12y ago> How do you actually get your drugs if you buy them on Silk Road? Do you have UPS bring the MDMA to your door? Yes. Typically it comes in "stealth" packaging to prevent it being detected en route. If it wasn't for tor being so slow it would be basically the same flow as ordering something off amazon (or so I'm told)
- kissickas 12y agoThere's a bit of added friction on the Bitcoin end as well, don't forget.
- joosters 12y agoThe FBI raids might actually be giving free publicity to these kind of markets. People who had never heard of them have now read news stories about the markets and might now seek them out. After all, the services that sprang up to take the place of the original silk road soon grew bigger than the original site. Perhaps the same thing will happen now with whatever new services now emerge?
- modo_ 12y agoI think that you're right. The FBI has (so far) only managed to take down three of the top six darknet markets[1]. It seems likely that the majority of the sellers from the shutdown sites will move their operations over to the remaining three; bolstering their sizes and attracting more customers. [1]: http://www.digitalcitizensalliance.org/cac/alliance/content.aspx?page=Darknet http://www.digitalcitizensalliance.org/cac/alliance/content....
- zanny 12y agoThe FBI is acting as a good litmus test of the security and confidentiality of these sites as well. If they got three but the others are still running, then maybe it means it is harder for them to find out where or who is running those sites. You would hope eventually we can use this evolutionary process to see completely opaque black markets emerge. Or you may not hope, depending on purview.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- shawabawa3 12y ago> Even if all drugs were made legal these sites would still have to be taken down unless you could find some way to tax them. If all drugs were made legal its very likely risk overheads would exceed tax, driving them out of business. Why can't I go on to a darknet market and buy a hard drive tax free for example? Because they can't undercut amazon even without tax
- gambiting 12y agoJust like we have to close eBay because people don't pay tax on some items they should pay tax on?
- pistle 12y ago"A strong argument can be made..." but the OP never does such a thing nor contextualize it, so linkbait it is. The title is breezed over, as a topic, in the article. Looks more like WP blogger likes to get high and is miffed.
- Multics 12y agoCool ad hominem, bro.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoNot true - its the content vs the title that's being criticized. Which strikes to the heart of what 'linkbait' means. Or is calling out linkbait considered 'ad hominem' and thus gets a free pass now?
- owenmarshall 12y agoPlease read "the ad hominem fallacy fallacy": http://laurencetennant.com/bonds/adhominem.html http://laurencetennant.com/bonds/adhominem.html
- danbruc 12y agoYou can disagree with current drug laws and desire a change, you can say that the actions the FBI has taken made the situation worse and be correct with that, but you can not blame the FBI for doing so, because they are just doing what they are expected to do given the current laws.
- ahallock 12y agoWhy are those who follow immoral laws not accountable?
- Nursie 12y agoThis is my problem with policing in general. The drug laws in particular cause so much harm, but there are many bad laws. As a police officer you have to be involved in enforcing them all regardless. I don't think that scrapping enforcement is a viable or useful option but...
- madaxe_again 12y agoBecause those who would hold them accountable either created or support said immoral laws. Also, you could go the deontological route, and say that by doing their duty they are being moral, for what other measure do you have, in a subjective and self-referential world? Although frankly I think that you either have to be amazingly naïve or amazingly egoistical (or both) to work in law enforcement and not have moral qualms about your employ.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoHarsh! Without police, random thugs would rule. Now you may slander police as thugs, but they follow rules, and those rules can be changed. Where your random thug is just out for himself, and out to get your stuff.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Now you may slander police as thugs, but they follow rules They are supposed to follow rules (aka, the law), just like everyone is supposed to. There are quite reasonable bases for being concerned that they too often don't, and that they are less constrained to do so than others, because they receive preferential treatment from the enforcers of the law, being as how that is their own community.
- tptacek 12y agoThe same argument is better directed at drug prohibition writ large, and seems intellectually incoherent when focused selectively on individual enforcement actions. Too, there's something galling about the idea of militating for forbearance for the drug market that serves primarily the wealthiest actors. Before we turn a blind eye to what are in fact gigantic organized criminal conspiracies operated by the kinds of people who will happily slap $70,000 on the barrel for a vanity electric car, maybe we could take a hard look at sentencing laws and early release programs. Finally: it's an easy sleight of hand trick to suggest that the "darknet" traffic solely in substances, as if allowing them to operate unimpeded would have only the effect of getting some of the drug trade off the street.
- btreesOfSpring 12y agoas far as prohibition goes, those who remember history are doomed to watching it repeated.
- madaxe_again 12y agoIt's only intellectually incoherent from the perspective we hold, on the outside of the bureaucracy. From within, either cognitive biases fill the gap, or there is information which, true or not, fills the gap. I'm not sure which is scarier, as I find myself often wondering whether our governments are barking mad, or know something we do not - or are just deluded by bog standard cognitive dissonance. Either way, the problem you describe extends far beyond prohibition, and drives much of the world's woes.
- yc1010 12y agoI doubt the FBI cares, lets not forget that for a long time they put a blind eye on organized crime (Mafia etc) while spending 100% of their resources looking for communists in every bush.
- Havoc 12y agoNot sure I agree. Nobody is putting that genie back into the bottle no matter what they do & by extension this supposed "benefit" is also not affected imo.
- venomsnake 12y agoThe real "more dangerous" argument is that the next gen sites will be even better, better hidden and more secure. They will evolve. So we will be in a situation where they will have to crack on everyone rights to bust this darkernet (situation I don't like), and with the way the security agencies are acting lately I doubt that they will think twice about it.
- neltnerb 12y agoI'm a bit confused as to what the alternative is from their perspective. If they infiltrated the site, and it was doing things that are illegal, they'd be horribly negligent to not act on it. It would be the equivalent to the "Fast and Furious" scandal when spun by news agencies. We can disagree with the morality of drug laws (I think they're horribly misguided and incoherent), but what else can they do? I think the best we can hope for is that they do the job we asked them to through the laws we put in place without violating other laws we put in place to protect civil liberties. If they're doing that (...) then it seems like this was their only ethical* choice. Assuming they're following the laws protecting civil liberties (...), the decision on whether or not the upside of shutting down a few markets balances the downside of hardening the others is way above their pay grade. * where ethical is defined as I imagine the individual law enforcement personnel are obligated to view it
- Nursie 12y agoIf enough investigators and enforcers started to kick up a fuss or outright refuse to enforce the current drug laws I bet we'd see change pretty damn fast. A lot of them would lose their jobs first, but if they were principled enough to take that stand... we'd be in a better place.
- Dirlewanger 12y agoOne can only hope that for the coming decades (not years) that those who put such policies in place (and those who continue to enforce them) will be rotting in the ground, and more forward-thinking people will begin to realize the irreversible damage the War on Drugs has caused (and continues to cause), and start to undo such shit policies. Hopefully that wasn't too much of a run-on sentence.
- Tloewald 12y agoHow the Washington Post these days seems to have become random (in the excellent sense that Bill Gates uses the term).
- GotAnyMegadeth 12y ago> in the excellent sense that Bill Gates uses the term Which sense is that?
- Tloewald 12y agoRandom is his worst put down -- someone who is consistently wrong actually conveys information.
- shittyanalogy 12y agoNone of this is research it's gut feeling spewed by an effected individual. It's easy to say that online marketplaces reduce street violence but with no research to back it up it's meaningless. Prohibition can be detrimental to the society around it but you can't solve the problems with gut instinct.
- undersuit 12y agoJust because it's an online website hosted on Tor doesn't make it completely unique. We've had black markets before, and we have research on what black markets do.
- spacemanmatt 12y agoThis is why "law enforcement" is a bankrupt concept. It does not care about safety or rights. It is a tool for kings.
- at-fates-hands 12y agoThis reminds me of back in the 1980's when the government was knee deep in breaking up the mafia. Several academics suggested it was a bad idea because the Mafia kept a lot of the other gangs and cartels in line since they ruled so much territory. By dismantling the larger mafia families, they were unknowingly giving free reign to a lot of the smaller street gangs who openly advocated violence and couldn't handle all the power they were being given.
- soylentcola 12y agoSlightly off topic but did anyone else find it weird/funny that in the first graph showing total listings by drug, alongside more "official" names for substances like MDMA, LSD, and amphetamine, they listed "weed"? I mean...I understand using common terms that have become de facto names (like "marijuana" instead of "cannabis") but "weed"? That's like making a list with Morphine, Oxycodone, PCP, and Blow. I dunno...maybe it just tickled my "one of these things is not like the other" sense since the list wasn't all slang terms but rather more accepted labels with a single street/slang name.
- stefantalpalaru 12y agoFiat iustitia, et pereat mundus!
- jedunnigan 12y agoThis is likely an erroneous argument with little evidence to support it. Violence between street dealers and drug consumptors is unlikely to be the largest source of drug related violence. After all, if the street dealers started killing their custies than no one would buy from them. It's bad for business. Instead, most heinous drug violence happens between cartels and gangs at the levels of production and [major] distribution [pipelines]. These darknet markets are usually filled with well off youth buying drugs for themselves and their buddies who alternatively would have been unable to source the drugs or would have texted their neighborhood dealer to meetup in a McDonalds parking lot.