5 ms·
A.C.L.U. In $50M Push to Reduce Jail Sentences
- aaronbrethorst 12y agoA little more background on this: the person who was tapped to run this program was the key person behind Washington's marijuana legalization I-502 citizens' initiative. i.e. she's pragmatic, capable, and has a track record of getting things done.
- mchanson 12y agoIts exciting to think we (the USA) might slowly be waking up from the nightmare that is the war on drugs. Hopeful for continued progress!
- Someone1234 12y agoIf you're referring to the Washington legalisation, I'd agree that is a step forward. If you mean in general I'm not sure if the US is changing all that much. The US has a strange puritanical undertone to it that doesn't seem to be going away. Things that are considered immoral are outlawed and heavily punished, often with no chance of redemption (i.e. in the US most crimes never expire and it is hard (and expensive) to get them expunged). You can see this puritanical nature everywhere, from violence Vs. sex on TV, in crimes (i.e. sex is prosecuted disproportionately harshly), video games, and so on, to drugs ("war on drugs," US's obsession with [legal] painkillers, while dishing out anti-depressants like candy), homophobia in general (and "abnormal" things in the bedroom), alcohol, and on and on.
- duaneb 12y agoYou know, it's funny—I typically view "puritanical" as something Massachusetts is. In this case, I think it's more like simple dogma. Puritanism is based on morality, but our current view of drugs and crime (as a country) seems to be derived from the 60s-80s "war on drugs". Instead, I see people just not trying to think about it. They become uncomfortable when the subject comes up. There aren't a lot of people making urgent, moral arguments against it—it really does seem like it's driven more by the momentum of law enforcement agencies attempting to justify their own excistance than anything else, and the rest of the country being complicity because they don't want to be labeled a hippy.
- tomsthumb 12y ago> Puritanism is based on morality Puritanism is based on a morality. Your phrasing indicates how deep seated it is in our culture.
- duaneb 12y agoWell, it is based on a certain framework of morality, but it's also based on morality in general. I don't think the government should be in the business of moralizing.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ojbyrne 12y agoYou say yourself it is an undertone, and certainly there is a very bipolar nature to American culture. That doesn't mean it can't change for the better. Gay sex has gone from something that once was the most heinous possible thing imaginable to something that's being accepted in even the most conservative of states. Marijuana is now legal in 4 states (and a district) and only a minor infraction in several others. Both these things wouldn't have been imaginable 20 years ago. The one thing the country is, is dynamic. It changes a lot quicker than many other countries.
- toomuchtodo 12y ago> The one thing the country is, is dynamic. It changes a lot quicker than many other countries. As the population "ages out" (older people with different societal mores die out, are replaced with younger folks), these changes occur. If you check out the exit polls for Florida for their recent medicinal marijuana ballot initiative, the 65+ age cohort was 62% against/38% for it. Compare that to the 18-29 age cohort (79% for/21% against). http://cnn.com/election/2014/results/state/FL http://cnn.com/election/2014/results/state/FL I leave it to the reader to calculate the "run rate" at which time ballot measures such as these pass based on actuarial data in various states.
- adventured 12y agoI'm completely sure of it. In general it's changing drastically in the US in fact. National polls indicate the majority are now in favor of pot legalization. States keep moving step by step toward treating drug addiction as a medical problem instead of a criminal problem. There is extremely wide-spread recognition that we have far too many people in prison, and that the police are far too violent / aggressive; both problems are finally seeing push-back and improvement. The US has a long history of making sweeping cultural changes, sometimes extremely rapidly, other times extremely slowly. There is immense and continual precedence in the US for the culture moving in the right direction, from women's suffrage, to civil rights, to gay marriage. America has a problem with alcohol? Where? I think you have it exactly backwards, there is relatively little puritanical anything left in America's culture. 1) The US is the world's largest consumer of alcohol. 2) The US is the world's biggest pornography market. The US is freer when it comes to that, than many European nations that are supposed to be non-puritanical. 3) I have no idea why you referenced video games, there are no actual problems with video games in the US despite whatever sensational blip you might have seen. 4) Most media in the US is perfectly fine with sexuality, you're referring to an extraordinarily small part of it, the broadcast networks.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- aaronbrethorst 12y agoSlightly over half of inmates in state prisons are there for violent crimes, and only about 8% of federal inmates are in for violent crimes. [1,2] Disparities in sentencing guidelines between powdered and crack cocaine have had very real effects on sending more poor people to prison:[3] While a person found with five grams of crack cocaine faced a five-year mandatory minimum prison sentence, a person holding powder cocaine could receive the same sentence only if he or she held five hundred grams. Similarly, those carrying ten grams of crack cocaine faced a ten-year mandatory sentence, while possession of one thousand grams of powder cocaine was required for the same sentence to be imposed. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incarceration_in_the_United_States#Violent_and_nonviolent_crime http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incarceration_in_the_United_Sta... [2] http://www.sentencingproject.org/doc/publications/inc_federalprisonpop.pdf http://www.sentencingproject.org/doc/publications/inc_federa... (note that this is from 2002) [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fair_Sentencing_Act#Sentencing_disparity_and_effects http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fair_Sentencing_Act#Sentencing_...
- Someone1234 12y agoCan someone explain why this is? Is "crack cocaine" 500x stronger than powdered cocaine?
- pstuart 12y agoNo. Powdered cocaine == white people, crack cocaine == black people.
- Someone1234 12y agoSorry, let me ask a different way, how do the law makers justify this distinction? Presumably they aren't outwardly racist. So how do they justify harsher sentences to one type over the other type?
- coldpie 12y agoI'm surprised how often I read articles about good work the ACLU is doing. I began a monthly donation earlier this year and plan to continue it for as long as I'm able. If you like the work they're doing, please consider starting a donation yourself.
- gohrt 12y ago$50M is approximately what the prison industry has spent in the past decade in their push to increase jail sentences: http://www.thenation.com/article/173122/what-does-millions-lobbying-money-buy-five-congresspeople-pocket-private-prison-indus http://www.thenation.com/article/173122/what-does-millions-l...
- gohrt 12y ago> Koch Industries recently gave a grant “of significant six figures” to the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers to support the defense of indigents A small fig leaf compared to the Koch budget, but interesting.
- spacemanmatt 12y agoFar less than a fig leaf.
- jessriedel 12y agoInteresting that it's not higher? The Koch's are libertarians.
- clairity 12y agoawesome! most crimes are out of desperation (particularly drug offenses), not ill-intent, but we punish them the same. the disadvantaged and systemic poor are in situations from which escape is exceedingly difficult. we should have a little compassion and bring sheep back into the fold with forgiveness, not exacerbate the underlying condition. it's not the punishment that keeps people in line anyways, it's social bonds. you need systems that strengthen social bonds for offenders, not tear them apart like prison does. "there, but for the grace of god, go i" (an apt sentiment, regardless of the religious connotation).
- arzugula 12y agoThis should be especially exciting to tech feminists who are striving for gender equality and are surely outraged about the crime sentencing gap which jails men for 63% longer than women who commit the same crimes.
- chasing 12y agoYup, people who are interested human rights should be supporting fair and just sentencing for everyone.
- lazaroclapp 12y agoSpeaking for myself here, but yes, as a rule, we are. Profiling and discrimination based on race and gender is a terrible thing, and arguably even more so when it interacts with the provision of justice. This is true whether it is re-victimization of abuse survivors, the racist characterization of young black men as inherently dangerous or criminal, or any other double standards based on a person's birth rather than their actions.
- lotso 12y agoThis comment seems like a way of criticizing tech feminists, while still trying to be relevant to the article? Why post this type of comment at all?
- Steuard 12y agoYep, speaking as a pretty staunch feminist (though by no means any sort of formal spokesperson), it is exciting to see a move toward greater justice on this front. I'm sure it's not universal, but just about every feminist site that I've ever spent time on (and just about every feminist I've known) is upset by the ways in which the gender biases in our society hurt and constrain men as well as women. It's a very real and frequently stated hope that as social attitudes toward men and women become less polarized, everyone will be better off (and issues like criminal sentencing and fathers' rights are prime examples of that). Mind you, different people have different senses of where the easiest or most urgent places are to advance that broad cause. But that's true of all of us, and not just in feminism: some people make charitable gifts to local soup kitchens, others to global malaria prevention, and yet others to the EFF. That's why it's so crucial for a wide range of people to be part of the feminist movement: to effect large-scale social change, we need people with passion working on as many fronts as possible.
- chasing 12y agoThis is great -- I wholly support it. But we've also got a government that's increasingly run by willful know-nothings. So I'm skeptical about our ability as a country to make a much-needed change like this. (And I wish to be proven wrong.)