7 ms·
I grow tired of this pathetic baseless fear mongering every single time anything is posted with voice control. You people completely ignore the mode of operati
by Someone1234 12y ago
I grow tired of this pathetic baseless fear mongering every single time anything is posted with voice control.
You people completely ignore the mode of operation and start making idiotic claims about "well NSA!"
In this case, as the website makes clear, you have to say the word "Alexa" for it to start listening. If you had been paying attention to the mobile scene even a little bit you'd know that this is on-chip listening for the term, rather than in the cloud.
So, no, you're in fact wrong. Nothing will be transmitted to the cloud unless it is the word "Alexa" or sounds similar enough to the term.
- skorgu 12y agoThe website makes clear that the listen-and-answer /behavior/ isn't activated unless triggered. That's absolutely not evidence in either direction for what happens in the non-triggered case. For example the idea that there's a debug mode that dumps the whole audio stream for troubleshooting isn't exactly tinfoil-hat paranoia.
- chaostheory 12y agoHow do you really know? How do you know that it won't be processing sound without the trigger when they get served with some government request? Is this in the terms and conditions? Is this in the privacy policy? Yes the original post is making an assumption, but you are as well.
- wtetzner 12y agoI think you misunderstood skorgu's post. I think you're both in agreement. He was saying Echo won't act on anything without first hearing "Alexa," (as in, perform the action you're asking it to) but that we don't know if it will be transmitting the voice data.
- SideburnsOfDoom 12y ago> Nothing will be transmitted to the cloud unless it is the word "Alexa" You can't be certain that there's no way to activate it remotely without you knowing. Seven mikes in your lounge is an attractive nuisance.
- spacefight 12y agoThis, a million time this. Actually reading stories like these, I wonder how big the market will be in 2020 for fully off-grid home solutions. If we proceed at the current rate with the IoT, cloud based storage of huge personal data sets, I feel that the future is brim. I bet that market will be huge, eventually.
- Someone1234 12y ago> You can't be certain that there's no way to activate it remotely without you knowing. Ditto with every electronic device with a microphone: Smartphones, tablets, laptops, home phones, bluetooth in your car, Microsoft's Kinect, baby monitors, etc. And while we're on an NSA paranoia trip, let's also remember that if you bounce a laser off of one of your windows it will allow them to pick up sound from within, plus signal leakage via the electrical grid, and of course unless you're in a faraday cage tons of EM leakage from everything you use.
- SideburnsOfDoom 12y ago> Ditto with every electronic device with a microphone: Smartphones, tablets, laptops, home phones, bluetooth in your car, Microsoft's Kinect, baby monitors, etc While there's a lot of truth to this, that is no reason to go even further down that road. If it's wrong for laptops to be used to eavesdrop then it's insanity to install a seven-microphone listening station in your lounge. "paranoia trip" is a rather condescending and dismissive way to refer to matters of documented fact, e.g. http://news.yahoo.com/yikes-nsa-turn-iphone-camera-mic-without-knowing-124525611.html http://news.yahoo.com/yikes-nsa-turn-iphone-camera-mic-witho....
- vibrolax 12y agoOf course, you could be monitored by the laser bounced off your window, or by your EM leakage. But it is an order of magnitude cheaper and easier for the commercial/governmental entity to use your own voice-enabled communications device for their own purposes. The commercial/governmental data gathering dragnet has come to its current state because it works on devices and networking services that the consumers themselves have purchased.
- oscargrouch 12y ago>Echo's brain is in the cloud, running on Amazon Web Services so it continually learns and adds more functionality over time.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- SideburnsOfDoom 12y agoHow can it "hear" the wake-word if it's not already continually working?
- Someone1234 12y agohttps://www.qualcomm.com/videos/snapdragon-voice-activation https://www.qualcomm.com/videos/snapdragon-voice-activation
- nwndarkness 12y ago"you have to say the word "Alexa" for it to start listening" That means that it is ALWAYS listening. It needs to listen for that trigger word at all times.
- sp332 12y agoIt's much easier to listen for a single word than to do the rest of the voice-recognition tasks. It would be a huge waste to upload all of the audio all the time, so usually these systems do the one-word thing on the device. They have a rolling buffer of a few seconds so that when it detects that hotword, it can send that to the cloud. It helps with noise removal. But not everything.
- sfennell 12y agoIt is always listening just like your dog is always listening. If you are not talking to it and you are not saying its name you are being (mostly) ignored. Most of the time, it is not paying attention - the chip that is processing the sound is looking for the ONE word that will activate it. That passive audio processing is happening locally on a chip that is dedicated to the task. Once activated - the expensive processing happens and the sound gets processed, converted to text, sent to the cloud.
- DEinspanjer 12y agoI understand this, and I don't happen to agree with the people who feel this type of technology should not be embraced, but, to be fair, the chip is controlled by software that is constantly connected to the cloud and updating over the air. It would take very little to update the software to disable the on-chip keyword detection and just record everything. That update could easily be done without your knowledge and in a way that would be almost undetectable since the software stack doesn't appear to be open and the server-stack is in the cloud and out of your control.
- gallamine 12y agoThe question is "what" is listening. For it to be responsive it's probably hardware-on-device that's doing the keyword processing. It would be simple to check though - look at network traffic.
- spacefight 12y agoUnless the chip design, the firmware, the OS, the software is 100% open source, there is no way to confirm "Nothing will be transmitted to the cloud". It could be an update check, or it could be the transmission of a new voice fingerprint. Same shit with cellphones, I have to admit.
- rstupek 12y agoIt is certainly possible to wireshark it and know whether it is transmitting anything. You don't need anything to be open sourced.
- spacefight 12y agoRead this again, then you'll see what I ment: "It could be an update check, or it could be the transmission of a new voice fingerprint."
- r0h1n 12y ago> you have to say the word "Alexa" for it to start listening Incorrect. The device is always listening, waiting for you to say "Alexa" so that it can start acting upon your commands. I'd take Amazon's claim that no data is transmitted or stored without the wake word "Alexa" purely at face value. There have been enough examples of devices and corporations collecting/sending data they weren't meant to in the past few years for us to deny any new closed-source device the benefit of doubt. So no, this isn't "pathetic baseless fear mongering".
- Someone1234 12y ago> Incorrect. The device is always listening, waiting for you to say "Alexa" so that it can start acting upon your commands. You say "incorrect" then re-phase exactly what I said in a different way but retain exactly the same meaning. The detection of the key word is on-chip. That's all that matters. Until the chip signals that it was spoken nothing is transmitted. > So no, this isn't "pathetic baseless fear mongering". Sure it is. If you know that on-chip keyword detection is a "thing" (which you do by your own admission) then you know also that claiming that everything you say in a room is sent to the cloud is entirely "pathetic baseless fear mongering." You fully admit you know that that isn't the case here, but yet continue on like it /could/ be the case. Pathetic.
- Crito 12y agoCan I, as a consumer that hypothetically owns one of these, control the software that is running on it?
- Someone1234 12y agoCan you, as a consumer control the baseband on your cellphone?
- vezzy-fnord 12y agoI suppose with a lot of constraints that you can, using something like OsmocomBB: http://bb.osmocom.org/trac/ http://bb.osmocom.org/trac/
- legohead 12y agobaseless? did you miss out on how the NSA has been recording everything you've said and making deals with companies for gathering your information?
- untog 12y agoYou people completely ignore the mode of operation and start making idiotic claims about "well NSA!" In this case it wasn't even the NSA I was thinking about, rather Amazon themselves. "Hey, I'm heading to the grocery store, do you need anything?" "Yeah, get some milk?" <user requires milk approximately every 4 days, enter "send Amazon Fresh promo e-mail" event for 3.5 days from now> Nothing will be transmitted to the cloud unless it is the word "Alexa" or sounds similar enough to the term. You don't know that. This is not going to be a piece of open source software you can evaluate. It's Amazon's literal black box to do with what they wish.
- lbearl 12y agoIts not really a black box, you still conceivably own the network it is running on. Last I checked Wireshark was pretty good at capturing network traffic. Even if the connection is encrypted, if the device isn't sending oodles of data to Amazon when you are chatting chances are good it isn't send "every word" to them. Granted, being able to audit this directly ourselves instead of observing it in other ways would be nice.
- kevinbowman 12y agoIt's possible that the device will transcribe and record the text of everything, and then only send it upstream in batches along with the consumer-useful chatter. Over a TLS link, that would look quite innocuous.
- sehugg 12y agoWith a tiny little tweak to the firmware, it could be always-on. With the seven far-field microphones it would be a very nice audio surveillance device indeed. No thanks.
- Someone1234 12y agoRight. Cellphone's baseband also. Hope you don't have any in the room with you otherwise that would be hypocritical. Most have a speakerphone which will pick up the whole room's audio.
- jaxbot 12y agoOk, since everyone here is making baseless claims about privacy, why don't we just buy one for science and monitor the network traffic on it? Problem solved. Getting really tired of HN stating obvious paranoia instead of talking about innovation these days. Yes, I get that privacy concerns exist, and this should always be kept in mind. But when more than 90% of the comments are about that, and circulating on completely theoretical claims, we've lost all value in the conversation.
- chipotle_coyote 12y agoI think we're in both a time and among an audience (HN readers) where privacy/surveillance issues tend to drive the conversation. I don't think that's bad, but I agree that it's a little disappointing that the main reaction among the HN crowd to the promise of ubiquitous computing is to immediately focus on all the ways it can be used for evil. My own take, which is either naive or mercilessly pragmatic depending on how you look at it, is that it's going to be a lot more productive to start thinking about how to protect privacy -- and, bluntly, what tradeoffs we're comfortable making as a society, which may not mean "share nothing unless explicitly told otherwise" -- in an always-on, always-connected world where networking will almost certainly become so pervasive that we largely stop even thinking about "the network."
- chaostheory 12y agoIt is not "pathetic baseless fear mongering" when we already have evidence that governments around the world are willing to overstep their bounds in terms of monitoring their own people. > In this case, as the website makes clear, you have to say the word "Alexa" for it to start listening. In order for it to hear the key word 'Alexa', it has to be always listening. They're just saying that they promise not to process the audio any further until they hear Alexa. Of course the obvious question is 'Does this promise apply for every situation?' What happens when Amazon gets served with a request to procure data from a user? Do they state this in the terms and conditions or in their privacy policy?
- LLWM 12y agoYes, it is. That's not relevant at all. Governments are not making these devices or forcing them in peoples' homes.
- chaostheory 12y agoHave you not read the news in the last year? It is relevant. They don't need to manufacture anything. They can just coerce private companies to give up their customers' data in the cloud. The companies aren't even allowed to announce it. > or forcing them in peoples' homes. Hence my argument for holding off from buying this and other devices like it.
- melling 12y agoYeah, I was just having this conversation 4 days ago. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8545144 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8545144 There's always a guy on HN who wants to warn everyone like we're all a bunch of idiots. It's ok to be paranoid but we should file it under an FAQ. Our time is probably better spent discussing the value of the product itself. Hopefully, we get to that today.
- tree_of_item 12y agoThanks for dragging me in to this. This is an even better example of the point I was trying to make, yet you're still doing this bland dismissal. You should really stop and think about the privacy implications of this technology for a few minutes.
- melling 12y agoThanks, I didn't realize there were privacy implications. How did I miss that. I think I slept through the hundreds of Snowden posts to HN. Now would it be possible not to turn every post like this into an NSA warning? I'll make my own choices from here.
- SideburnsOfDoom 12y ago> Now would it be possible not to turn every post like this into an NSA warning? Sure, right after the need for an NSA warning on all of these things stops being necessary.
- hackuser 12y ago> idiots > paranoid I don't see much difference between calling someone an "idiot", and calling them "paranoid" and dismissing their concerns to an FAQ. > Our time is probably better spent discussing the value of the product itself. Confidentiality has a large impact on the product's value, at least for many people. I don't see them as independent issues. If you feel, like many, that confidentiality is necessary to its value then the focus of the discussion makes sense (if it wasn't so redundant).
- castis 12y ago> You people completely ignore the mode of operation and start making idiotic claims about "well NSA!" You say that like the thing people are concerned about isn't possible.
- andrewstuart2 12y agoYou'll hopefully notice I deliberately said "it's too bad", "privacy concerns", and "might," all of which are key to the meaning of that sentence. My first comment was mostly in jest. That said, it's ignorant to blindly trust or blindly distrust anything. I believe the rational concern is not what it does now, or what Amazon intends it to do, but what it could be updated or hacked to do. Hence the "can hear," not "will hear" present even in my joking. I'm making a deliberate choice to ignore your insulting language and look for the reasoning behind it, but you could stand to make it a little easier to do so. Let's be gently rational. Something about flies, honey, and vinegar.
- opendais 12y agoIts not baseless when stuff like this happens: http://mediabuzz.monster.com/benefits/articles/1288-google-says-that-it-collected-data-from-open-wi-fi-networks-by-accident http://mediabuzz.monster.com/benefits/articles/1288-google-s... 1) Its quite possible for a firmware glitch to "accidentally" leave it on. 2) Given I interact with Amazon's APIs enough to know they have "intermittent" issues that are quite hilarious, I fully expect #1 to happen at some point.
- angersock 12y agoThis is installing a general-purpose computational device with audio listening and networking. In addition, its normal use case is listening for a phrase, doing additional decoding in the cloud, and then taking an action. It is not at all unreasonable to say "Man, that functionality sounds a lot like spying. I sure hope that nobody roots this device." Are you 100% sure (beyond some marketing copy on a website) that this is purely on-chip voice recognition? That this chip's firmware isn't reprogrammable? That it can't decide to, once activate on-chip once, stay on continuously? You can't. Unless the hardware and software was open-source, and then was verified on-site, you can't. That's the problem with these kind of things. And yes, we have the same problem with cellphones, laptops, tablets, soon cars, and everything else; that doesn't somehow magically make this any better. Also, please stop saying "pathetic". It conjures to mind some jerk swirling cheap booze in a glass saying "mmm yes how pathetic the plebes" and then waiting for their next r/atheists post to get upvoted. You just end up sounding like a pompous ass.
- wtetzner 12y agoEven so, you're basically voluntarily placing a "bug" in your house, allowing anything you say to be transmitted to someone else. The user has no way of knowing how that data may or may not be used.
- hyperbovine 12y agoThe phenomenon of the average person being surrounded by a half dozen internet-enabled cameras and microphones is a pretty recent one; I don't think we've even begun to experience the Bad Things that can result from that. Even if it's highly unlikely that Amazon would use it for evil, there's no stopping a technically savvy malfeasant from doing so. I mean, probably 1/3rd the people reading the post, including myself, are on an Apple laptop. You're staring right into the face of an internets-enabled HD camera. Is it recording? The light says no but the light can lie (https://jscholarship.library.jhu.edu/bitstream/handle/1774.2/36569/camera.pdf https://jscholarship.library.jhu.edu/bitstream/handle/1774.2...). Is your microphone recording audio and sending it somewhere? Even you, the 1%ers of the tech savvy world, have got to admit that you would have little way of knowing this if somebody did it correctly.
- Karunamon 12y agoLikewise. I'm all for recognizing a credible threat, but there is nothing credible here. The level to which the readership of HN abandons all pretense of critical and rational thought when a surveillance angle on a story presents itself is downright frightening.
- flavor8 12y ago> All of this is made possible through the advanced, tightly integrated hardware and software in Snapdragon 800 processors. https://www.qualcomm.com/news/onq/2013/02/20/snapdragon-wakes-mobile-world-snapdragon-voice-activation https://www.qualcomm.com/news/onq/2013/02/20/snapdragon-wake... cf. Stuxnet, BadUSB. There may not be a remote exploit for these chips yet, but I will bet my paycheck that intelligence agencies somewhere are working on doing so.
- jfoster 12y agoI agree with you about the NSA-related claims dominating the discussion too much, but your tone isn't nice. May I suggest that a better way of mitigating the dominance of the NSA-related discussion would be by making some top-level posts about other interesting aspects of the product?