9 ms·
The hammer-feather drop in the world’s biggest vacuum chamber [video]
- dia80 12y agoI know how this will turn out but my intuition is screaming otherwise.
- saalweachter 12y agoThis is a great example of the 'Reality is Unrealistic' trope. The feathers just look so photoshopped falling next to the bowling ball, motionless, unfluttering.
- derekp7 12y agoOne way of adjusting your intuition is to imagine the bowling ball and the feather standing still, and the ground coming up really fast and smacking them like a giant ping pong paddle. That's the only way I can get my eyes to agree with what the brain is thinking.
- oneeyedpigeon 12y agoI find it interesting that Brian Cox, the presenter and avowed scientist, obviously finds it so 'surprising' as well. Maybe that's the true meaning of being a scientist, though - he doesn't truly believe it until observing it with his own eyes.
- sambeau 12y ago>Brian Cox, the presenter and avowed scientist, I think you mean "Brian Cox: Professor of High-energy Particle Physics, member of the High Energy Physics group at the University of Manchester, and the ATLAS experiment at the Large Hadron Collider at CERN (who also presents popular science programmes in the UK)" I think his career as a scientist deserves a little more recognition than "avowed". And, as for his career in popular science he has been awarded both a Faraday and a Kelvin prize.
- oneeyedpigeon 12y agoSorry; I have every respect for Brian Cox, unlike others on this thread. I think I'm merely using totally the wrong word.
- sambeau 12y agoSorry; I read "avowed" as a deliberate slur. I suspect some of the negativity about him here must have got to me. For an unknown reason I picked on your comment – I now see there are plenty worse :)
- vacri 12y agoStill, I wish he'd use SI units, instead of things like 'cubic feet'.
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoI just watched this today - I've studied physics at Uni - I've done many experiments and known this result for a long-long time. However, this was actually the first time I've seen it myself. It is awesome to see something so un-intuitive but so well known actually occurring - like if you could actually see quantum tunnelling happening. If you don't find the world awesome then doing physics has got to be a pretty hard slog. But then I'm over-awed just about every time I use a mobile [aka cell-phone] or computer at the physics and engineering that's happening, the maths being applied, ... A computing equivalent might be seeing Babbage's Difference Engine[1] or a valve based computer at work for the first time - you know the maths, the algos work, you know the science well enough (certainly in the mechanical computers) but seeing it all chug away and produce the result has a certain enthralling beauty. Maybe it's more like seeing a visual emulator [2] working on assembly code? You know it works, you know why it works (at some level at least) but it's doing it, it's awesome! [1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jiRgdaknJCg http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jiRgdaknJCg [2] http://www.visual6502.org/JSSim/index.html http://www.visual6502.org/JSSim/index.html
- oneeyedpigeon 12y agoThis does quite a nice job of it, for me :) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GcDshWmhF4A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GcDshWmhF4A
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoThat is awesome. I wonder how well that would do for teaching place values to primary school kids - despite having done binary/octal/hexadecimal and other types of number representations with my kids they still struggle to see how decimal uses places and how carrys work.
- t__r 12y agoI find it a bit easier to understand if I imagine similar size and shape objects with a different weight. Say, a bunch of balls with equal radius but different weights. Does a near-zero-weight ball fall with a near-zero speed? Of course not. Etcetera.
- shittyanalogy 12y agoJust imagine the air to be made up of a bunch of tiny physical balls. The bowling ball does a good job of getting them out of the way fast but the feather trips and stumbles on them as it makes it's way. With none of these tiny air balls in the way both objects move unimpeded until they hit the earth.
- bjackman 12y agoI guess this is a pretty superficial complaint, but this is a 2nd-generation clickbait-site link (posted on io9, reposted on thekidsshouldseethis.com). Why not post the Youtube link directly? This isn't really Hacker News material, anyway.
- teach 12y agoEspecially since the linked site is starting to hit resource limits. I had to refresh a few times before it would load. Here's the youtube link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E43-CfukEgs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E43-CfukEgs
- vixen99 12y agoA version without Cox would definitely pile on the views. As it is I will forgo the pleasure.
- norlowski 12y agoExperiment, curiosity, huge NASA buildings, near vacuum. I'd rather read about this than mark zuckerberg.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ghshephard 12y agoA multi-story vacuum chamber on earth is pretty freaking amazing. Certainly stimulated my intellectual curiosity.
- colinramsay 12y ago> What to Submit > If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- 12y ago
- iterationx 12y agoYes, you already know the ending, but its worth watching just to see the massive structure.
- italophil 12y agoThe space and aerospace programs of the sixties produced some really impressive technologies and facilities. Too bad government spending on technology research went down, just imagine what could be possible.
- frozenport 12y agoFrom another perspective, these technologies left us with little science of utility (Tang?) while developing intercontinental ballistic missiles that loom over humanity like the Sword of Damocles. When historians from far off planets visit our nuclear wasteland they will see our thinly veiled space program as the beginning of end. :-)
- baldfat 12y agoQuick list of more inventions that are not Tang http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NASA_spin-off_technologies http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NASA_spin-off_technologies
- noselasd 12y agoEven something as mundane as error correction coding were developed at NASA, for communicating with spacecraft - technology that's now present in e.g. CD/DVDs, and every mobile communication system. Now, if they hadn't developed it, someone else probably would, but perhaps not at that time - leaving us at years behind where we currently are with e.g. the speeds on our mobile devices.
- btoptical 12y agoError Correction Coding is hardly mundane and in modern communication systems far from trivial. There is a lot more to ECC than Reed-Solomon. Basically nothing in our digital world today would work very long without it. You think of it as mundane only because it just works.
- kens 12y agoI think the credit for error correcting codes goes to Hamming in 1950.
- blutack 12y agoSeeing as the original site has now fallen over, the actual youtube link is https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E43-CfukEgs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E43-CfukEgs
- nmeofthestate 12y agoAnd for the violently impatient, the actual drop: http://youtu.be/E43-CfukEgs?t=2m52s http://youtu.be/E43-CfukEgs?t=2m52s
- zwp 12y agoFortunately you beat me to it. I was going to post the later sequence at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E43-CfukEgs&feature=youtu.be&t=4m15s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E43-CfukEgs&feature=youtu.be... But on closer viewing that is a disastrous montage: the first few seconds (before cut away) show the feathers fluttering and the bowling ball starting to accelerate away; the slow-motion segue is under vacuum conditions though. The film editor's intention is that the two shots appear contiguous. We can speculate why they might have done this (no close up shot taken under vacuum conditions?) but it really tramples the whole point of the article :(
- 4ad 12y agoWhat do you mean? The close-up shot at 2:52s is under vacuum. The "fluttering" you see is the elastic wave in the feather caused by the sudden drop in internal tension. The feather is an elastic object (to a first approximation). When the feather is hung, there's internal tension keeping it stationary and giving its shape. When the feather is unhooked, this internal tension doesn't just disappear instantaneously, rather an elastic wave travels through the feather at the speed of sound in the feather. Because the feather is not a perfect elastic medium, the effect you see is a damped harmonic oscillator, but it takes non-zero finite time to dampen sufficiently. This is true for the big ball too, except that the speed of sound is orders of magnitude faster in it, and the spring constant of the material (steel?) is also many order of magnitude larger than the spring constant of the feather. The center of mass of both objects falls at the same rate. At t=0, d^2x/dt^2=0 for the points closer to the ground and d^2x/dt^2=2g for the points that were just unhooked. Also see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mAA613hqqZ0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mAA613hqqZ0
- jgrahamc 12y agoWorth reading http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equivalence_principle http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equivalence_principle if you don't understand the last part.
- fdomig 12y agoI love science. This is a very nice example of it.
- aaron695 12y agoIt interesting some people think a vacuum means a lot of pressure but really it's the same as 10 meters under water at sea level pressure.
- Cthulhu_ 12y ago^, explosive decompression in space also isn't as explosive as coming up from a few meters underwater in one go (it's from 1 to 0 atmospheres, instead of 100 to 1). Not that I advocate explosive decompression in any circumstance, mind you.
- paddyoloughlin 12y agoI wish the producers were less enamoured of their slow-mo and showed us the whole thing in real-time. The "weird" thing is seeing feathers plummet to the ground and I wish we got to see more of that.
- shangxiao 12y agoI actually like the slow-mo as it reaffirms the fact that there is no air in that chamber. When the feathers first drop you see a slight sway in the feathers, but only due to the acceleration. It's actually quite a sight to see feathers accelerate so quickly and stay so still.
- ghshephard 12y agoAccording to this, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equivalence_principle http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equivalence_principle, posted lower, the feathers aren't under acceleration. Which is pretty cool once you think about it.
- paddyoloughlin 12y agoI'm not against them using slow-mo at all. But they showed the drop several times, and I would have preferred them to show it at real speed at least once.
- zelos 12y agoThis is a Brian Cox show we're talking about, not a science show. I'm surprised there weren't more slow mo shots of Cox doing his "boyish wonder" face.
- aragot 12y agoI too though this "boyish wonder" face was phony. And yet the "boyish wonder" face will change the fate of the whole video when I show it to my 7yo. The rest is concrete and iron, not really appealing to kids, despite the potential awesomeness of the huge vacuum chamber.
- joshvm 12y agoAll the best facilities have big buttons labelled "Mega speed trigger". But in seriousness, does the Moon not count? Surely space is the largest vacuum chamber we have access to!
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- paddyoloughlin 12y agoI love how professionals who work at that facility and have probably deeply understood those principles for decades still display so much wonder at seeing this experiment with their own eyes.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- hudibras 12y agoI might be cynical, but I think they were putting on a show a bit. They already had some sort of apparatus set up to do the simultaneous drops. My guess is that it's a standard demonstration for visiting dignitaries and the like.
- JTon 12y agoPerhaps their excitement no longer stems from the experiment itself, but from the reactions of the newcomers. Probably a terrible analogy, but sort of like witnessing a child's first experience hearing a musical instrument live. It can be energizing.
- aylons 12y agoI agree you're being a bit cynical. They are used to the chamber and with experiments in the chamber, but this simple experiment with a feather and a iron ball is very different from what they usually see. They probably usually see only heavy objects and mechanisms for space projects being tested there. Such a graphic and basic experiment must be well outside the norm.
- smackfu 12y ago>They already had some sort of apparatus set up to do the simultaneous drops. Why do you say that? They could have easily made the apparatus for this experiment.
- Too 12y agoThe button he pressed when dropping had a label that said something like "launch jet sequence" (don't remember exactly). They probably have a modular set of actuator and rigs they can easily mess around with . :)
- thearn4 12y agoSPF is an awesome and unique facility, I wish more of the public would get to see it in person. If you want to see more of it in video, it's also where the opening scene to "The Avengers" was filmed. Plum Brook Station has a whole collection of really cool (though mostly single-purpose) buildings.
- Animats 12y agoIf you want to see more of it in video, it's also where the opening scene to "The Avengers" was filmed. It's appeared in a lot of movies, "Futureworld" (1973) being one of the first. That's where the nuclear rocket upper stage for Apollo was supposed to be tested.
- pshinghal 12y agoCertainly a lot of us know what to expect in this experiment, but the thing I never really thought about was a that the feathers would bounce back up after impact. Seems obvious in retrospect, but it was pretty cool to see.
- revscat 12y agoCommander David Scott did this same experiment as part of Apollo 15 in August of 1971, in an even larger vacuum: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KDp1tiUsZw8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KDp1tiUsZw8
- ColinWright 12y agoThat's one reason why I posted the link to this site, rather than directly to the YouTube video, as explained here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8556363 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8556363 The text of the site I submitted has kindly been posted by DanBC[0] here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8556409 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8556409 [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=DanBC https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=DanBC
- revscat 12y agoNo worries, mate.
- rglover 12y agoAnybody else catch the NASA engineer wearing a SpaceX Dragon t-shirt? Nice.
- Marcus10110 12y agoI'm wearing mine to Interstellar tonight!
- rajdevar 12y agoI live in Ohio, Never knew that the biggest vacuum chamber is here until now.
- th0ma5 12y agoYup yup, it is NASA Plumbrook, the old reactor south of Sandusky. On the way to Cedar Point as a kid I was always in awe of the place as it was so big and you could only get within a few miles of it. My sixth grade teacher claimed a three eyed frog he had in a jar came from a nearby pond.
- cryowaffle 12y agoCan someone explain to me the last part about the items standing still and no force acting on them? Isn't gravity acting on them, pulling the earth and items together?
- gradi3nt 12y agoImagine being inside of a closed box like an elevator. Without leaving the box there is no way to tell the difference from being in free fall towards Earth versus floating in interstellar space. Therefor, general relativity take the perspective that gravity is a fictitious force (like centrifugal force) that arises from the shape of spacetime.
- josu 12y ago>versus floating in interstellar space Versus being inside that an elevator that is being accelerated in interstellar space This seems like a pretty good explanation: http://www.astronomynotes.com/relativity/s3.htm http://www.astronomynotes.com/relativity/s3.htm
- bweitzman 12y agogradi3nt had it right Free fall feels like floating Standing still (in the presence of the Earth's gravity) feels like being accelerated.
- kentf 12y agoScience is amazing.
- vertikal 12y agoIts brilliant
- IgorPartola 12y agoSerious question: why do we keep repeating this experiment? Not that I mind, I just am curious why do we keep building bigger and bigger vacuum chambers just to drop a feather and a hammer over and over.
- Ad_Nauseam 12y agoDropping feather and hammer isn't the only use of vacuum chamber
- 4ad 12y agoI seriously doubt they emptied the huge vacuum chamber for this experiment. Most likely it was used for some other experiment and it was very cheap to do this experiment as well. As to answer your actual question, because it's very televisual (this was for a TV show, after all) and sells well. It's something very simple, something (almost) everyone understands yet something almost nobody has ever seen. It's a powerful experiment for the general population. But to answer a more general question. We shouldn't stop repeating experiments just because they were done before. The scientific method works as long as we keep reproducing results. Sure, this is a trivial result, but it's something every kid should have done by its own in the school physics lab.
- mturmon 12y agoI assume the BBC paid a fee for the use of the facility. Maybe they piggybacked onto some testing or scheduled activities that were being done anyway. I'll bet once the location scout saw those huge doors close, the deal was set. ;-) Similar large facilities exist at many national labs, and they are used only sporadically. For instance, in the Bay Area, NASA Ames has a very large (11 foot square) wind tunnel that can reach Mach 1.45 (http://www.nasa.gov/centers/ames/orgs/aeronautics/windtunnels/11x11-wind-tunnel.html#.VFkZIkuYW9A http://www.nasa.gov/centers/ames/orgs/aeronautics/windtunnel...). The inflatable bags that landed Spirit and Opportunity on Mars were tested in Mars air pressure at the Glenn vacuum facility: http://www.nasa.gov/centers/glenn/about/history/marspbag_prt.htm http://www.nasa.gov/centers/glenn/about/history/marspbag_prt... . Many spacecraft undergo "thermal vac" testing meant to simulate space conditions.
- vacri 12y ago
- Shivetya 12y agoI think my favorite part of this is not that they were able to demonstrate it so well but instead the reactions of people expecting it to actually occur.
- z3t4 12y agoSo if they aren't falling. What are they doing?
- Freestyler_3 12y agoThey could also have put a toy helicopter in there, just to add more fun.