3 ms·
> In fact, professors would often use informality as a way to encourage students to actually interact with them, but if you want distance between you and your s
by justin66 12y ago
> In fact, professors would often use informality as a way to encourage students to actually interact with them, but if you want distance between you and your students, formalities are a good way to achieve that.
That's an interesting perspective. It's not universally true. I'm personally bothered by the fakeness of a "hey, just call me Ed" type of introduction from a professor, someone who has a massive amount of power over my future and who is not my friend, and it's going to create a distance and mistrust until I get to know them. On the other hand, it's never been a big issue either way. It's not hard to adapt to local norms, and the macro issues of education are going to dwarf little things like titles soon enough. (I'm currently a CS student, but I'm a comparatively old one :) )
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoMost academic computer scientists are hackers at heart; they are quite genuine in their informality.
- justin66 12y agoIn my view - and I am not positioning this as some sort of universal truth or trying to persuade you of anything at all - they might be genuine in their informality, but that's not where the "fakeness" I mentioned above is coming from. The relationship between teacher and student is a fundamentally formal relationship of trust with (one hopes) clearly defined responsibilities, authority, and so on. It's fake to pretend that the power differential between teacher and student does not exist. I don't feel like a professor who is overly informal right off the bat is honoring the relationship. (but they are sometimes a lot of fun at parties...) I've never been uncomfortable with informality with a teacher once genuine friendship develops. That's different.