3 ms·
Only yesterday there was another submission about a twin who weighs 15 pounds (or kg?) more than his brother. Really, what DO we know about twins? Most twins a
by Tichy 17y ago
Only yesterday there was another submission about a twin who weighs 15 pounds (or kg?) more than his brother.
Really, what DO we know about twins? Most twins also grow up in the same environment and with the same education.
In fact when I looked up some IQ studies of twins, it turns out that there really aren't many cases of twins that have not grown up together. Usually some war happenings were the background. As a result, those studies don't typically look like what you would a scientific experiment to look like. Some separated twins might only be discovered in their 50ies, others in their teens.
You can not just go ahead and say "let's look at 50 pairs of twins, of which one grew up in a poor family and one in a rich family", because you will not find 50 such twins from the same era.
Maybe you find some poor twin who grew up in the 50ies, and another poor twin who grew up in the 80ies, or one grew up in Africa and the other in Europe, so comparison already becomes questionable.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoFrom the other story: "For a start I was 15kg heavier than my brother." but... "Of the thousands of twins enrolled in the research program only 10 were more different in weight than us." So it seems that in general twins weigh roughly the same.
- pbhjpbhj 17y ago15kg is quite a lot. Most men in my street (by sight) would be within 15kg of me, I'm about 83kg ~ 13 stone (slightly over WolframAlpha's reported median USA male weight in 2006). I think the chance of being more than 15kg outside the weight of someone who has grown up in the same lifestyle and with the same food opportunity is probably pretty low.
- xiaoma 17y agoWhen I went back to the states, I saw people that weighed 50kg more than others near them pretty much every time I went out.
- Tichy 17y ago"So it seems that in general twins weigh roughly the same." It should be easy to study the eating habits of these twins. In most cases, why should they differ much, if they have been raised in the same household?