5 ms·
"If our planet was 50% larger in diameter, we would not be able to venture into space, at least using rockets for transport." I thought this was quite though-p
by lordnacho 12y ago
"If our planet was 50% larger in diameter, we would not be able to venture into space, at least using rockets for transport."
I thought this was quite though-provoking from a Drake Equation standpoint. From what I've gleaned, the earth-like planets we know of seem to be a big bigger than Earth. Perhaps if there's civilization out there, they are hampered by the misfortune of being on a planet that's practically impossible to escape from. If they find it hard to put up a Hubble Telescope, perhaps they'll just not be as likely to bother.
My other remark is to the engineering. There's a quip that you have to be an engineer to make something that only just satisfies the requirements. Plenty of people build houses without much in the way of calculation. Even cars can be built by enthusiasts without degrees. This is what makes the space stuff such amazing engineering.
- Sharlin 12y ago> From what I've gleaned, the earth-like planets we know of seem to be a big bigger than Earth. This is entirely a selection effect. Big planets are easier to find, that's why we have mostly found big planets.
- throwawayaway 12y agodegrees are overrated. does john carmack have a degree?
- Leszek 12y agoDoes he build rockets?
- 14113 12y agoeer...yes? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Carmack#Armadillo_Aerospace https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Carmack#Armadillo_Aerospa...
- Leszek 12y agoOh. I stand corrected, should have researched that before commenting.
- acous 12y agoThis exchange made me grin :) To add some value to my comment, here's a cool video from one of armadillo's test rockets: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9u0qlIoSSkQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9u0qlIoSSkQ
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- chton 12y agoWe're still very early in the development of spaceflight. If you compare with the car industry, we're at the early industrialized phase, where large companies carefully start to develop the necessary technology. Now, 100 years later, a lot is standardized and the knowledge is so common that everybody has the basics, and people can build cars in their back yards. It's the same development that happened with airplanes. At its core, a rocket isn't more complicated than a car. The challenges are just different. My dearest hope is that eventually rocket components will be as commoditized as car parts, so people can build and maintain their own spacecraft. I want to see rockets held together with duck tape and spit, because that's the point where spaceflight is available to everybody and gravity stops becoming a hurdle. A quick disclaimer: I have the greatest respect for rocket engineers. They are taking the first steps, the most difficult ones, and I don't believe for a second that they their work is easy. I just believe that eventually, they'll become obsolete to the majority of spacetravel :)
- iliis 12y agoYou might be interested in Copenhagen Suborbitals (copsub.com): A danish group trying to reach space in a DIY fashion financed by donations. It's quite impressive what they've already achieved with not that much more than duct tape!
- chton 12y agoThat is amazing, thank you so much for linking it. I did not know about them, and it does indeed seem like they have made a lot of progress. I'll be following them from now :)
- baq 12y agoas the article says, space != orbit. i don't see how you can get 8 km/s delta-v in a garage. edit: doesn't mean it's not interesting, but orbit is so much more challenging than just space it's not funny.
- chton 12y agoIt's true that orbit is more challenging, but you have no hope of getting there if you can't do a suborbital jump first. Aiming for suborbital first might see them get a lot more funding if they succeed. You need to learn to crawl before you can run.
- kabdib 12y agoYou could still do it with nuclear propulsion. Orion, if you absolutely have to go into space today and don't mind riding a string of atomic explosions.