4 ms·
We already have free self-replicating devices that do just that: plants. Just add water.
by otterley 12y ago
We already have free self-replicating devices that do just that: plants. Just add water.
- IgorPartola 12y agoThe oceans are the largest carbon sinks currently: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_sink http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_sink. My professor in college predicted that at some point we'll start building highly efficient CO2 sinks out of specific types of plankton and dumping them into the oceans to float around and offset our bad CO2 behavior.
- JTon 12y agoDump them into the ocean? That's a bit of a scary thought. Not only tinkering with the oceans ecological balance, but also the idea of our genetically engineered plankton spawning out of the control. I'd prefer to keep them in controlled environments.
- maxerickson 12y agoIron fertilization (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_fertilization http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_fertilization ) is a little less likely to spiral out of control, and once discontinued should stop having an effect in relatively short order. I've brought it up to people and had them say such large scale experiments are too scary to carry out, but we are already engaged in a CO2 experiment of that scale (without much ability to cease the input).
- bduerst 12y ago>once discontinued should stop having an effect in relatively short order Not even close. The largest iron fertilization "experiment" to date was done by Russ George with just 100 tonnes off the Pacific coast of Canada in 2012. It's now 2014 and the salmon population has quadrupled from the algal bloom. We don't know what sort of impact iron fertilization at scale will have on the ecosystem.
- maxerickson 12y agoConsider that you could have provided more information without trying to pin down what I was thinking (or could've asked what I was thinking). I've tried several different ways to say that, this one seems the least whiny.
- bduerst 12y agoWhat?
- maxerickson 12y ago"relatively short" is a pretty fuzzy statement, saying it's "Not even close." invites me to try to argue about what I was thinking when I wrote it (ooh fun), and it isn't all that necessary to your point.
- bduerst 12y agoYes it is, but I have a feeling you're still going to be bitter and worm your way into contonuing to patronize.
- maxerickson 12y agoI was trying to express frustration (I think unnecessary argumentation often damages discussions here), but I take your point, such things can come across poorly.
- aetherson 12y agoWe're geoengineering no matter what we do. Might as well geoengineer in a way that we think has a possibility of success.
- sitkack 12y agoWe need to be sucking CO2 out of seawater, not the air. If we suck it out of the air, it has to come back out the ocean before we can grab it. The atmosphere and the ocean are in balance, so grab where the grabbing is good, the ocean.
- bduerst 12y agoRight. Creating large pytoplankton biomasses would theoretically pull bicarbonate out of the seawater. It's not unlike how carbon deposits were formed for the natural gas and oil we use today. The real downside is that if did it at the scale necessary to have an impact, you're also going to be creating HABs (Harmful Algal Blooms) that could potentially change the Earth's climate themselves.
- aetherson 12y agoYeah, it's a great theory, but in practice there are some obstacles. Most quick-growing plants have a short life-cycle after which they decay and put their carbon back into the atmosphere. The only plants that really lock up carbon for decades or centuries are trees, and growing new forests is slow and daunting. You can solve the fast-growing plant problem by continuously growing plants (so as the old ones die, new ones lock up the same amount of carbon), but that means that a given acre of land has to be devoted in perpetuity to locking up X amount of carbon. And fast-growing, large plants tend to degrade soil quality -- they need rich nutrients to support that fast growth. They also need water, which is not necessarily locally abundant. Reforestation is still probably the best way to capture carbon from the atmosphere. Do something where you build a young-growth forest, cut down trees and do something with the wood other than allow it to decay or burn it, let new trees grow. But it's not just a matter of flinging some seeds on the ground and yelling "Done!"
- nkurz 12y agoMost quick-growing plants have a short life-cycle after which they decay and put their carbon back into the atmosphere. The only plants that really lock up carbon for decades or centuries are trees, and growing new forests is slow and daunting. You sound like you've looked into this, but at a glance this seems implausible. I have a compost pile, and to it I add fast growing plants from my garden. I presume that the carbon mass of the plants has mostly been extracted from atmospheric CO2. Empirically, as time goes on the pile gets larger. I've always presumed that the a significant portion of the resulting pile is carbon. I'd be surprised if any significant fraction of my compost pile were to suddenly evaporate. If I plow the compost into the soil, I'd be even more surprised if it were to disappear. So while there might be considerable loss of CO2 back to the atmosphere during during the composting process, and while (worse) there might be considerable methane released, isn't it safe to say that the increased carbon mass of the pile represents CO2 that has been removed from the atmosphere? And that if this compost is buried and the soil mass increases, the difference can be counted as sequestered CO2? Where's the flaw in my logic?
- Guvante 12y ago