7 ms·
Both geniuses and madmen pay attention to what others ignore
- m52go 12y ago> The most important process underlying strokes of creative genius is the tendency to pay attention to things that normally should be ignored or filtered out. I'd add that it's not only paying attention to these things, but questioning them. Noticing something no one else does is useless unless it incites action. Deciding to act upon something can only happen if there's sufficient curiosity. Curiosity comes from questions. Why? What if? How might one...? Questions are so fundamental to everything from creativity to innovation, management, sales, relationships...I just had my eyes opened by A More Beautiful Question by Warren Berger.
- emotionalcode 12y agoHow can you define action? Is it the summation, selection, and order of thoughts leading up the action, or is a web that connects possibly every observation and thought you've had?
- ChuckMcM 12y agoActing is easy, its simply answering the question, or at least attempting to. That is the part where you can't just ignore it and go on with your life.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- drzaiusapelord 12y ago>I'd add that it's not only paying attention to these things, but questioning them. Personally, I feel the rebellious aspects of intellectualism are far, far overplayed to the point of absurdity. It leads to buying into marginalized, if not discredited, ideas and not doing a proper investigation into mainstream knowledge. I mean, how many more reddit posts about the "evil" Federal Reserve or how terrible of a person Thomas Edison was do we need? Especially when these opinions are tied to politicized propaganda from the opposition and not remotely tied to a legitimate interest into monetary policy or late 19th century industry. I don't think young geeky introverts need to be told to be more rebellious, if anything they should learn to conform more, learn better social skills, understand the power of teams and collaboration, etc. I really wish someone told me this when I was younger. These attitudes did me a big disservice in life and I imagine I would have been much more successful otherwise.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- the_hangman 12y agoThis. It took far too long for me to realize that noticing and questioning something that others have either not noticed or not questioned didn't make me any smarter or better than anyone else. I think that a lot of younger, geeky types are always looking for or being told of reasons why they're better than their more socially-outgoing classmates. It's comforting to sit back and feel like you're winning because you see things that other people don't, but what really puts people ahead in the long run is being willing to confront the things which make them uncomfortable.
- m52go 12y ago> I mean, how many more reddit posts about the "evil" Federal Reserve or how terrible of a person Thomas Edison was do we need? Is that rebellion or groupthink? Either way, yes, most of it probably is useless. But what about the rebelliousness that brought about the hyperlink, the mouse, and the iPhone? Surely those inventions were rooted in questions that sought rebellion against established ways of doing things? There's a time to rebel and a time to conform. Rebellion without conformity leads to thinkers who have great ideas but no output. Conformity without rebellion leads to complacency and no progress. As with everything else, one needs balance.
- drzaiusapelord 12y ago>But what about the rebelliousness that brought about the hyperlink, the mouse, and the iPhone? Are those really rebellions? TBL was a pretty milquetoast guy who built on top of a lot of things before him: TCP/IP, server OS, interconnected networks, and of course text-based predecessors to the web like Archie. He didn't wear all black and call everyone an idiot and magically produce something wonderful. He stood on the shoulders of giants and reached a little further.
- kstenerud 12y agoIt's not so much the question as the pattern (either noticing a new pattern, or the break of an existing pattern). Everything operates in patterns, and some are more pleasing or more jarring than others. In either of these cases, it may spur you into investigating further, which may lead to an interesting discovery. Whether that discovery is useful or beautiful to other people or not is irrelevant.
- sbensu 12y ago> Everything operates in patterns very meta of you :)
- checksum404 12y agoReminds me of the sesame seed trade from Silicon Valley.
- MarkPNeyer 12y agothis difficulty inhibiting thoughts that i know are irrelevant has long been an issue for me. i had to build a "memory palace" style visualizing technique for "disposing" of thoughts that i know aren't relevant, but can't help fixate on. i imagine writing the thought down in vim, then moving the file to a USB stick, then taking the usb stick into a zip-lock bag, putting that into a specific pocket of my backpack, getting on my bike, and riding from my apartment down 101 to the NASA base at AMES, throwing the backpack into a red bin which is loaded into a rocket and shot into space. the visualization is so detailed and specific that it takes all my attention to render that internal movie; after having expressed the thought syntactically (i actually imagine writing the thing down in vim and moving my fingers accordingly), it gets moved from "the thing actively afflicting my consciousness now" to "a thing i was thinking about". often after the rocket takes off, i can remember i was thinking something that bothered me, but i can't remember what it was. my mind will sometimes grab after it, trying to remember - and if it surfaces i get agitated again - but i can usually stay focused enough to distract myself by going for a walk or establishing a small, easily obtainable goal to fire up the ol' task positive network again.
- calroc 12y agoThat's pretty amazing! I sometimes use imagery of a toilet flushing and the thought going down, several flushes if necessary (imaginary water is free!) Also, imagining white noise (visual and auditory) washing out the thought, increasing in power until it wipes away the thought like waves on a beach erasing patterns traced in the sand and then fading out, seems to work well. (I suspect using (imaginary) noise might have some actual biophysical basis for why it works, but that's just speculation.)
- Jacqued 12y agoIt's not quite as detailed as yours, but I use a "trick" of the same kind to chase those obsessive thoughts. I see myself on top of a miles high cliff, standing next to a safe. I somehow extirpate the thought by breathing it out into the vault, which I then lock and push off the cliff. I then have to wait and when I "hear" a distant noise, I can't remember the thought, even though my mind perversely tries to remember. Anyway, I'm glad to see I'm not the only one having to resort to such tactics...
- andrewstuart2 12y ago> Psychopathy, noun > mental disorder especially when marked by egocentric and antisocial activity [1] > Antisocial: adjective > hostile or harmful to organized society; especially : being or marked > by behavior deviating sharply from the social norm [2] So if you're more intelligent (deviating sharply from the social norm) and you know you're intelligent (egocentric), you're kind of a psychopath, by definition of the word psychopath. What's the surprise there? Not being accepted or understood by the society that you excel above would also be expected. [1] http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/psychopathy http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/psychopathy [2] http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/antisocial http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/antisocial
- kstenerud 12y agoThey're being a bit trite in bandying the word "psychopathy" about. I think a better term would be eccentricity. Genius does tend to come with psychological quirks (usually the filtering of mundane things in a way others consider odd), but most of them are usually harmless.
- andrewstuart2 12y agoI guess what I'm trying to point out is that psychopathy, genius, and eccentricity have the same semantic roots. They all indicate some offset from an average.
- calroc 12y agoBut psychopathy is a kind of divorce from reality; while it seems that the genius is somehow closer to reality than the normal person?
- MarkPNeyer 12y agothe article uses the word "psychopathology" which is notably different from psychopathy. the form of pscyhopathology referred to here is psychosis, not psychopathy or anti-social personality disorder.
- adventured 12y ago"Suicide victims like painters Vincent Van Gogh ..." Van Gogh very likely did not kill himself. http://www.bbc.com/news/entertainment-arts-15328583 http://www.bbc.com/news/entertainment-arts-15328583
- kirsebaer 12y agoThat's a nice idea, but most evidence suggests suicide: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Vincent_van_Gogh https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Vincent_van_Gogh
- Fede_V 12y agoAnyone who will unironically define themselves as a genius has issues with ego. Genius is something only history can bestow on people.
- adventured 12y agoYour theory is that, let's say, John Carmack can't self-identify as a genius after all he has accomplished, and given how far out in front of most others he has always been on the technology curve? Bill Gates possesses a genius level intelligence, has the accomplishments and mental demonstrations to back it up, and is apparently fully aware of it. What's the problem exactly? Let's define genius: "exceptional intellectual or creative power or other natural ability." or "a person who is exceptionally intelligent or creative, either generally or in some particular respect." As though it should be difficult for a genius to recognize that their abilities far exceed those of other people. I would argue that being oblivious to that level of blatant genius - having no idea you're so much better than most others - would be more of a negative mental trait vs being aware of it. You'd have to be incredibly ignorant, and almost entirely non-self-aware to miss such a thing across a lifetime. If you can reasonably be defined as to be in possession of X trait, there is absolutely nothing wrong with recognizing that. It is not an ego problem to do so. If my brain is capable of great feats of mathematics, and I can tell that I'm drastically better at math than my peers, there is nothing irrationally egotistical about recognizing it. With there being a critical distinction between recognizing your capabilities, vs. obnoxiously promoting them to others.
- ForHackernews 12y agoI guess it depends what the threshold for "genius" is. Obviously Carmack and Gates are very bright people who've accomplished a lot, but let's be honest, they're not exactly at the level of DaVinci or Einstein, or even Feynman. And I do think it's ego problem if somebody goes around defining themselves as a genius. One of the things I'm always struck by is the fact that many of the smartest people I know are incredibly humble. They're smart enough to realize all the things they don't know.
- 12y ago
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Htsthbjig 12y agoWhen you want to do anything new, you have to go against the flow, and this is psychologically very hard. When I decided to quit my job and create a company I went against everybody. My parents, my girlfriend, my friend, all them thought I was crazy quiting a good position for something so risky. E.g My girlfriend told me that if I was doing my company the relationship was over, so I said to her, ok, go away. The next week she wanted to come back, but I preferred to risk this alone. Of course, when whatever you did works, everybody believes you are a genius, and they always remind you how much they KNEW that. Success is contagious, and once the media says that, you are a genius for everyone. People like Newton, who was a geek, had to suffer isolation all his life in order to do what he felt right. Fortunately today there are two differences with Newton's time: 1-There is Internet. Whatever you do you are not alone. There is a 1 per cent or 1 per thousand people like you, and with Internet you can find them, meet them. In the past getting enough critic mass was only possible in cities, with millions of people. 2-We know a lot more about psychology, you have amazing educational materials to improve your live, be happy and not getting in holes like suicidal thoughts.
- glibgil 12y ago3-Creating a company now makes you feel like the next Newton.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 12y agobut they ought to feel like Edison.
- emotionalcode 12y agoAny advise for a person who had success, then had compound PTSD surface, get mingled with the concept of ego, leading to a negative sorts of ego death, and is still trying as hard as they can to become genius? I can't get the concept of being past my prime, out of my head, and I think that is precisely what is holding me back.
- LanceH 12y ago
- nicklaf 12y agoThis article gives the following quote some context: "Mathematics requires a small dose, not of genius, but of an imaginative freedom which, in a larger dose, would be insanity. And if mathematicians tend to burn out early in their careers, it is probably because life has forced them to acquire too much common sense, thereby rendering them too sane to work. But by then they are sane enough to teach, so a use can still be found for them." --Angus K. Rodgers (The word genius seems to be rather ill-defined, as evidenced by Rodger's reluctance to use it in a context that seems identical to that of the article.)
- nicklaf 12y agoI also like the following quotation of N. Bohr, appearing in an Amazon book review[1] of Dr. Simonton's[2] "Creativity in Science: Chance, Logic, Genius, and Zeitgeist": "We are all agreed that your theory is crazy. The question which divides us is whether it is crazy enough to have a chance of being correct. My own feeling is that it is not crazy enough." [1] http://www.amazon.com/review/RV4Y43WKRK6LO http://www.amazon.com/review/RV4Y43WKRK6LO [2] Dr. Simonton is the UC Davis professor who authored the article.
- cevaris 12y agoInterested in this article, take up a book "Outliers: The Story of Success" by Malcolm Gladwell
- codyb 12y ago"Second, the permanent inhabitants of mental asylums do not usually produce creative masterworks." But how many sedatives are they on?
- eric_h 12y agoIndeed. Sedatives, anti-psychotics, mood stabilizers - all have a decidedly negative effect on creativity.
- Animats 12y agoThe author is talking about idea generation. As Edison wrote, "Genius is 1% inspiration and 99% perspiration." Here are a few ideas I don't have time to pursue. 1. Make extruder-type 3D printing work better by heating the material just laid down, just ahead of the weld point. Use hot air or a small, maybe 5W laser diode. Use 3 heat points 120 degrees apart so you can heat ahead of the direction of travel. Modulate the laser with pulse-width modulation, then read the temperature during the off period with two photodiodes with different IR filters. Go closed-loop on the temperature. 2. Initial application for automatic driving - airport auto rental. Book rental in advance. When customer's phone shows up at destination airport, dispatch car to terminal, timed to show up just after luggage pickup. Use phone to direct customer to car. On return, customer drops off car at terminal, and it head back to rental lot on its own. Self-driving is limited to low speed in known areas. Expand system by adding parking garages at likely car rental destinations, such as convention centers. 3. Conference room automation. Video projector should have camera, find screen, put up test pattern, focus, correct for parallax. Room lights should sense projector/external lighting situation. Microphone system should automatically track speaker from a distance (this exists, using a hemisphere with a large number of microphones and a lot of CPU power) without any effort by speaker. Video feed of talks and classroom should have people tracking and automatically generate a useful video feed. The whole thing should Just Work. Internet of Things crowd, get busy. 4. Integer overflow, both signed and unsigned, should trap in CPUs. If you want modular arithmetic modulo the word size, you should write "x+= (x % 65536)", and the compiler should understand that as an idiom, generating an cheap unchecked unsigned add. 5. Set import duties to recover about half the wage difference between the exporting and importing countries. This escapes the "race to the bottom" problem. Half, so as not to have too much protectionism. Politically difficult, but the current ratio for the minimum wage in Shentzen to the US is 5.6. China is getting close to where this is feasible. Idea generation is easy. Implementation is hard.
- wahern 12y agoRe #5, there's a race to the bottom only in the short term. As you observed, income in China is rising dramatically and rapidly, even median incomes. Free trade reduces wage differences. By stymying trade, you slow down the process. You sustain local wages at the expense of many more poor people elsewhere. Policy attention is better spent addressing workforce mobility and skills gaps. If we could magically fix American policy, I'd raise the taxes and fund programs which address the aforementioned issues. Although an easy hack for improving mobility would be to 1) kill the home mortgage interest tax deduction and 2) government guaranteed mortgages. It's both a blessing and a curse that so many non-skilled, low-wage Americans can be homeowners in this country. We'd need some kind of replacement model which promoted wide-scale access to capital, however. Homeownership is the only way most Americans can get access to cheap financing for small businesses, education, etc.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 12y agoNinety nine percent of genius is genius and not sweat; just ask Gauss.
- beagle3 12y agoOr, as Telsa is rumored to have remarked: "If Edison spent a little more time thinking, he wouldn't have to perspire as much"
- SandersAK 12y ago“Amateurs look for inspiration; the rest of us just get up and go to work.” ― Chuck Close
- CurtMonash 12y agoI had an IQ score higher than Marilyn vos Savant's once. I like to think I'm a more creative thinker than most, but I haven't exactly made any world-shaking discoveries ...