16 ms·
Head-On Crash Test of 2009 and 1959 Cars (video)
- 83457 17y agoMaybe this will finally dispel the myth about older cars being safer in these sorts of collisions because they were built like "tanks".
- phsr 17y agoThis doesn't change the fact that I still want a 1969 Chevelle SS. :-) Also, I love the window title "Default Viral Title Player"
- Retric 17y agoYep, for more info: http://www.autoblog.com/2009/09/26/pics-aplenty-iihs-reveals-before-and-after-of-malibu-bel-air-cr/ http://www.autoblog.com/2009/09/26/pics-aplenty-iihs-reveals... The after pictures clearly show why the 1959 car kills you, while the 2009 let's you live. PS: "The dummy's head struck the steering wheel rim and hub and then the roof and unpadded metal instrument panel to the left of the steering wheel.... The windshield was completely dislodged from the car and the driver door opened during the crash, both presenting a risk of ejection. In addition, the front bench seat was torn away from the floor on the driver side." Ouch.... an instant death according to the IIHS. And the '09 Malibu? "A high acceleration was recorded on the left foot, indicating that foot injuries would be possible. http://www.autoblog.com/2009/09/17/video-iihs-celebrates-50th-anniversary-by-crashing-modern-malib/ http://www.autoblog.com/2009/09/17/video-iihs-celebrates-50t...
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- conanite 17y agoIt would be interesting to see a video of two 1959 cars crashing compared to a video of two 2009 cars crashing. It's nice to have a tank, but if everyone has tanks, maybe I'm not better off.
- radu_floricica 17y agoStill doesn't change the fact that the newer cars absorb the impact before the cockpit. That, and airbags/seatbelts, make the biggest difference. Two newer cars would most likely be unusable after a crash but keep the passengers alive, while two older cars would crash "uniformly".
- jimbokun 17y agoYou're still better off in a tank if you hit a telephone pole or a tree, for instance.
- eru 17y agoBut tank chains are no good for the pavement.
- shpxnvz 17y agoSure they are, that's why they have rubber pads on the treads.
- idm 17y agoDo you mean a tank, literally, as in an M1 Abrams? ...otherwise, did you see the video? Crumple zones, passenger cabin intact, airbags, seat belt, etc?
- jimbokun 17y agoHuh? I took conanite to mean newer cars are "tanks," only in the sense they survive crashes better than old cars. He was saying that it might not be a relative advantage if the other car hitting you is equally impervious. Irresistible force, etc. etc. My only point was that you are much better off in a modern car striking a telephone pole than you would be in a 1959 car, even if it is true that you are somehow worse off when two modern cars strike each other (although I doubt that also). Nothing about literal tanks intended whatsoever. Your comment seems to take the exact opposite meaning from what I intended to say, so I must have expressed myself poorly.
- timmaah 17y agoI like the rust cloud from the 59. Makes you wonder what kind of shape the car was in before they prettied it up to crash. I drive 2 old aircooled volkswagens in the summer and am just about ready to give up the hobby because of this. I don't like the extra amount of risk the hobby puts on my life.
- cninja 17y agoAccording to the senior VP of the crash institute, the cloud was dirt from the 50 year old car, not rust. http://wheels.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/09/18/more-details-about-1959-bel-air-crash-test/ http://wheels.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/09/18/more-details-abou...
- biohacker42 17y agoUp next, a 1950s computer vs an iPhone, a TV from 1950 vs a modern day TV, what else can we compare? Everything! Technology has progressed, how about that! Besides the omg look at the crash shock factor, what does this tell us? The only thing I get out of it, is to be reminded that we should rely on the insurance industry's crash tests, not the government's. The insurance industry is much tougher on cars.
- RyanMcGreal 17y agoIt's a common belief that old "solid" cars are safer than their light, flimsy modern counterparts. This test dispels that belief fairly dramatically.
- maximilian 17y agoSome readers on Jalopnik's site said that the cars actually weigh very similarly. So "lighter" is only perceived.
- RyanMcGreal 17y agoWell, that would explain the disappointing improvement in average fuel economy.
- biohacker42 17y agoIs it really that common?
- randallsquared 17y agoMostly among the 40 and up crowd, I think. I'm not sure I know anyone younger than me who believed that (I'm 36).
- 83457 17y agoI'm 28 and my primary inclination was to think that newer vehicles crumple while older cars do not, leading to more internal injuries for passengers of older vehicles and more vehicle damage of newer vehicles. However it appears that the older vehicles lose on both fronts.
- codyhilton 17y agoYou'd think that after 40 years of automobile safety innovation we could do better than this. In reality there shouldn't even be a scratch on the Malibu let alone even a remote possibility of injury to the passengers.
- tricky 17y agoYou ever take a physics class? There are extreme forces involved in a collision like this. The acceleration numbers alone are astounding. I'd say this is pretty darn good for 40 years of safety innovation driven by consumers who would rather pay for 1000 HP engines than safety belts.
- imp 17y agoConservation of energy hasn't changed in 40 years. The force of the impact has to go somewhere, and consumers don't want to pay for a Titanium car. The driver looked like he was in pretty good condition.
- natrius 17y agoMaybe in 40 more years...
- MikeCapone 17y agoIf the car didn't have a scratch (ie. the energy wasn't dissipated by the crumple zones), a lot more of the impact would be felt by the passengers. What's the point of having a car without a scratch of the driver is turned to jelly...
- tricky 17y agoThis is true even with roll cages in race cars. You'd think you want the strongest metal available, but that's not right. They actually use a softer steel so the cage deforms a on impact. The guy who welded mine said the shock from an impact to a titanium cage would effectively shatter your body. He was far from a doctor, but it made sense.
- 17y ago
- dangoldin 17y agoI think it's unfair to compare cars from 50 years ago against cars today without comparing the behavior of the drivers. Although the cars themselves may be safer, more people may be on the roads and may be driving more recklessly which would lead to a higher number of accidents as well as having the damage be equal. I remember reading something about a study being done that showed people that cars drove much more dangerously around bikers with helmets than bikers without; if you feel that other cars are safer you may drive more dangerously. Edit: Here's the study: http://www.bath.ac.uk/news/2006/9/11/overtaking110906.html http://www.bath.ac.uk/news/2006/9/11/overtaking110906.html
- tomjen2 17y agoThis is a very valid point and raised very well. It does not deserve these downmods.
- jeremymims 17y agoDon't forget that in the 1950's it was socially acceptable to tank up on a few highballs, take one for the road, and get on your merry way. There has been so much more safety education in the last 30 years. It's bound to have rubbed off a bit.
- noodle 17y agowhy? this feels like a red herring fallacy. we're talking about the technology and quality of the cars across time as it relates to safety. you pull in people as drivers and it fundamentally changes what we're talking about. more examples: "I think it's unfair to compare cars from 50 years ago against cars today without comparing the state of modern traffic laws and speed limits" "I think it's unfair to compare cars from 50 years ago against cars today without comparing the quality and ubiquity of roads, highways and interstates" etc.
- dangoldin 17y agoMy general point was that although cars are safer than before, we still need to look at the system they are a part of which affects safety. I don't want people to make the conclusion that it's safer driving now than before - that may or may not be the case.
- SlowOnTheUptake 17y agoWhat isn't clear to me is, do safer cars translate into fewer traffic injuries and deaths? I recall reading an economics paper that indicated that safer cars encouraged more reckless driving and the two competing factors canceled each other out; as cars got safer, the number of accidents increased until the number of deaths and injuries returned to their prior levels. I wonder if we all still drove 1959 cars would we be using cell phones while driving?
- godDLL 17y agoNot directly, no. Since 1959 cars are going faster, there is more of them, and the bar for driving one is lower because of ubiquity and social expectation. So it's about the same. Just more cars, and more people driving them, so we see more crashes. I'd say the percentages don't matter as much because of how many more cars and roads there are. Even if they'd be marginally lower -- you still get many, many more crashes and injuries.
- dmv 17y agoThere is an interesting table at http://articles.moneycentral.msn.com/Insurance/InsureYourCar/crash-test-1959-chevy-vs-2009-chevy.aspx http://articles.moneycentral.msn.com/Insurance/InsureYourCar... "Highway safety then and now" Registered vehicles: 1959 - 71.5 million 2008 - 255 million Miles driven: 1959 - 700 billion 2008 - 2.9 trillion Fatalities: 1959 - 37,910 2008 - 37,261
- Periodic 17y agoA 75% reduction in fatalities per million-miles-driven in 50 years. That's very good to see. Thank you for bringing in the numbers.
- tlb 17y agoThe choice of camera angles seems biased. Most of the shots showed the driver's side of the old car where the impact is and only the passenger side of the new car. I'm not disputing their overall conclusion, but it'd be fairer to start with overhead angles and show equal time on both sides.
- donw 17y agoThey show the same camera angles for both, and an overhead shot of the impact. Both cars impact on the same (driver's) side. The most important two shots in this are the interior shots, and the left-hand door. On the Bel Air, you can see the passenger compartment get crushed -- the steering wheel crushes the occupant against the seat, the door is more-or-less ripped off, and the roof crumples inwards. On the modern car, it does what it's designed to do -- the steering wheel stays put, and the passenger compartment forms a solid cage around the occupants.
- Zak 17y agoI'd like to see some comparisons of active safety (the ability to avoid crashes and retain control in adverse conditions). I suspect the improvements in handling and braking in the average car since 1959 aren't nearly so dramatic. Aside from the SUV craze, the average front-wheel-drive[0] family sedan built today feels like it wants to fall off the road every time it encounters a corner. I have to wonder why the average car buyer doesn't seem to notice or care. I suspect most adults have, at some point in their lives driven a car with decent handling and braking. [0] Front-wheel-drive alone is not to blame for this; I've driven FWD cars that did not feel like that.
- tptacek 17y agoYou think ABS, traction control, and power steering and brakes haven't made things better than '59?
- Zak 17y agoI said "not nearly no dramatic", not that things aren't better now. A quick search suggests that the 1959 Bel Air had power brakes and that power steering was at least optional. I'm not sure power steering is standard on all low-end cars at this point. It wasn't a few years ago. ABS and traction control are effective in some situations for mitigating the effects of driver error, but often get in the way of the corrections a skill driver is attempting to make. Additionally, they don't actually create any more traction, so they don't actually raise the limits of what the car can handle. Sure, the average car is better off with them, but getting the weight balance, suspension tuning and brake balance right matters more. A limited-slip differential is another big improvement that's been well-known for a long time, but is still rare on popular cars.
- tptacek 17y agoMy '94 Nissan Sentra had standard power steering. I'd be surprised to hear about a popular car made within the last 10 years that didn't have both ABS and power steering standard.
- jrussino 17y agoI wonder how much improvement there has been between more recent models of cars. I doubt that there are many people driving the 1959 Chevy Bel Air on today's highways, but there are probably plenty of people driving cars that were built in 1999. I'd be interested to see how much of a difference in safety there is between similar car models from '99 and '09.
- papersmith 17y agoI think the major passive safety features of this decade are better crumple zones and side-impact airbags. IIRC Euro NCAP made their crash tests much tougher recently to adapt to the improved safety across the board.
- InclinedPlane 17y agoActually, I suspect the bigger effect is driver and passenger airbags becoming standard.
- papersmith 17y agoI think that happened in the 90s. :)
- jacquesm 17y agoone of the comments links on another site about this crash test links to this page: http://www.carcraft.com/junkyardcrawl/ccrp_0910_x_framed_chevys/photo_01.html http://www.carcraft.com/junkyardcrawl/ccrp_0910_x_framed_che... There's a bit of a hint why this particular model came of so bad. more info on the car: http://www.thetruthaboutcars.com/ask-the-best-and-brightest-is-this-the-bel-air-the-iihs-destroyed/ http://www.thetruthaboutcars.com/ask-the-best-and-brightest-...