55 ms·
I should get back into doing GPG key signings. I really hope that, sometime soonish, someone does a decent browser email crypto thing. It doesn't have to be p
by davidw 12y ago
I should get back into doing GPG key signings. I really hope that, sometime soonish, someone does a decent browser email crypto thing. It doesn't have to be perfect, it just has to add to the amount of encrypted traffic on the internet.
- atmosx 12y agoThe problem with GPG integration IMHO is not technical, it's practical: Most people (as it happens with tor) do not understand how it works and more specifically why it should work that way to avoid snooping and MiTM attacks. Until we solve that part, Pretty Good Privacy, won't work for most people. As Einstein said: "Things should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler". By making PGP simpler, you're effectively killing it by adding more and more attack vectors.
- davidw 12y agoOh, I agree with that wholeheartedly. I bet you could make a 'serious looking' guide like this: https://wiki.debian.org/Keysigning https://wiki.debian.org/Keysigning And add a few instructions like "now email your private key to ..." and people would just go through the motions and do it. Still though, adding to the traffic out there would probably help - at least a little bit - privacy efforts.
- BillFranklin 12y agoKeybase are doing something cool for keysigning - https://keybase.io/ https://keybase.io/
- fossuser 12y agoI think Keybase (https://keybase.io/ https://keybase.io/) could really be the answer to this. Once there's a real public key directory and API things can really start to happen on the backend without most users even realizing it.
- th0br0 12y agoThey recommend you to upload your _private_ key to their servers though! (Ok, encrypted with scrypt... but still...) ... a very bad thing to recommend users to do.
- dllthomas 12y agoI mostly agree (and my key never leaves my computer, though I've been considering sticking something in a safety deposit box), but I'm not entirely unsympathetic to the desire to offer more functionality. Is there a good solution involving delegation and short-lived keys?
- ef4 12y agoAgreed, but this is all part of the core usability problem: it's too hard for users to reliably not lose their keys, and it's too hard to safely access them from all the places they're needed.
- fossuser 12y agoIt's optional and encrypted, for most users it's the right choice. If you think of security as a spectrum - on one side you have protecting against dragnet collection and on the other you have protection from targeted attacks. Too often security discussions only talk about perfect security and while that is important, in the general case I think this is a good thing for most people.
- dllthomas 12y agoOne thing that worries me about GPG's trust model is that marginal trust doesn't actually stack very well. If three of my friends go to a key signing party, and each check some guy's ID to his face, I'm not really that much more confident that it wasn't a fake ID. The same holds, albeit weaker, over more spread out interactions... Only signing keys when I've known the person interacting in public under that identity for a protracted time seems a solution, but dramatically limits the growth of the network.
- DanBC 12y agoThere's a well known problem with manufacturing inspction called "the two inspector problem". Ann ispects units, then hands them on to Bob who performs a final inspection. Ann is falling behind so she gives the units a quick short less thorough inspection. She knows that Bob will catch the problem. Bob gets a sudden extra load of units, so he too gives them a less rigorous inspection. Bob knows that Ann has previously inspected them. It happens surprisingly often although not quite in that form. There's a whole bunch of research shwoing what a group of people do when estimating numbers - they tend to clump around whatthe first person says. I suspect three people checking and ID would be subject to both of these problems.
- dllthomas 12y agoOn point. Seems related to diffusion of responsibility.
- acqq 12y agoVery problematic is the potential of signers spam. Imagine people who blindly sign the keys only to appear listed when somebody looks for somebody well-known. Imagine ads in PGP keys.
- dllthomas 12y agoInteresting. Potentially problematic, but it should be something we can deal with. Requiring acceptance of a signature for it to be posted seems like it does the job.