3 ms·
'would' is ambiguous because the author is describing something in the past. For example, you would write 'would' regardless of whether the original question wa
by gwern 12y ago
'would' is ambiguous because the author is describing something in the past. For example, you would write 'would' regardless of whether the original question was "Ma'am, do you think Clinton's appearance yesterday on America's Got Talent will damage his legacy?" or if the question had actually been "Miss, do you think Clinton accepting his recent invitation to appear on AGT would damage his legacy?" But either way, the question is false...
- Dylan16807 12y agoStill not bluffing, because they are only speculating on the self-contained scenario, not bringing in fake details.
- gwern 12y agoIt is still bluffing because the scenario is not being presented as a hypothetical.
- Dylan16807 12y agoIf you don't pretend you've heard of it before, it's an abstract scenario that might as well be hypothetical. You're answering based on the question and only the question.