3 ms·
The lawyers that I used to work with would advise merely putting the letter in a filing cabinet and taking no action on it ("Even if they have no case, having y
by patio11 17y ago
The lawyers that I used to work with would advise merely putting the letter in a filing cabinet and taking no action on it ("Even if they have no case, having you flapping your lips in print just makes my job potentially more difficult later").
That said, I'd be inclined to write him something like this:
Dear CEO:
I received your letter regarding your belief that ma.gnolia.com is in violation of your trademark for "Magnolia" in the United States.
In the future, you may find that when sending a cease and desist letter, it is helpful to include pertinent details of your trademark registration such as reference numbers, a detailed sample of the registered mark, and what classification you are registered under. Your legal representation can explain the significance of these to you. Without them it is impossible for me to conclusively evaluate whether ma.gnolia could possibly infringe on your registered trademark.
As a matter of US law, your trademark is likely not to the word "Magnolia" in all senses, but probably scoped to its use in CMS software. As ma.gnolia does not sell CMS software, there is no possibility of market confusion with regards to the purchase of CMS software. We both have presences on the Internet, but frankly, trademark law is not a guarantee that you will be the only mention of the word Magnolia on the Internet.
You claim that "[ma.gnolia's] graphic appearance can be totally related to our CD". It is unclear to me that you are making a claim here based in trademark law. If you are, I would need a copy of your registered specimen to compare it to our logo to determine whether the claim is valid. That being said, a cursory inspection of the logo present on your website shows the word Magnolia. A cursory inspection of our logo shows the word Ma.gnolia with a giant flower on it. Your claim that these are confusingly similar is baseless as a matter of law.
Your lawyers are welcome to contact my lawyers if they have any other questions.
Cordially yours,
- patio11 17y agoOh, I found their registration: http://tess2.uspto.gov/bin/showfield?f=doc&state=4004:riq7f.2.2 http://tess2.uspto.gov/bin/showfield?f=doc&state=4004:ri... Their trademark is for [Magnolia] is scoped to "in the field of content management".
- ErrantX 17y agoThe search session expires :) But (for everyone else) if you run a search for Magnolia on that site it is the first (or second) one on the list. I cant find the supposed Europe one.
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoThe Nice classification ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_(Nice)_Classification_of_Goods_and_Services http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_(Nice)_Classifica... ) is not CMS but "classes 9,42" which encompasses computing and lots of other [sort of] related things. In the UK at least any other use of a similar mark to your RTM in that classification is potentially infringing. Whilst USA is a signatory to the Nice Classification I don't think that means anything beyond the requirement to use the Nice terms as classifiers, presumably finer classification can be used as the region of exclusivity. Four EU and UK results from ipo.gov.uk in classes 9,24: http://www.ipo.gov.uk/madridEU?madridEUnum=U00000909350 http://www.ipo.gov.uk/madridEU?madridEUnum=U00000909350 - Magnolia Int. Ltd. http://www.ipo.gov.uk/domestic?domesticnum=2510591 http://www.ipo.gov.uk/domestic?domesticnum=2510591 - Magnolia Hi-Fi, Inc. http://www.ipo.gov.uk/domestic?domesticnum=2422850 http://www.ipo.gov.uk/domestic?domesticnum=2422850 - Jayne Nation (Dr) http://www.ipo.gov.uk/madridEU?madridEUnum=U00000898571 http://www.ipo.gov.uk/madridEU?madridEUnum=U00000898571 - Boehringer Ingelheim International GmbH
- yuvouv 17y agoTrademark law generally requires them to defend their trademark or lose it. This means lots of letters from Apple inc's lawyers to small orchards in the middle of nowhere. The general response is either to ignore it or send back a simple letter saying "thank you - we don't believe there is sufficent similarity" If they mean it they will try an take you to court, then you can decide wether to fight or change your name. At the moment they probably don't expect you to do anything - this is just something they have to send out in case anyone ever does a direct copy of their software and calls themselves magnolia. In which case they have to prove they have always protested.
- mbrubeck 17y ago"Trademark law generally requires them to defend their trademark or lose it. This means lots of letters from Apple inc's lawyers to small orchards in the middle of nowhere." No, it doesn't. You don't automatically lose a mark through lack of enforcement. There are specific ways that marks may be weakened (genericization, tarnishment, dilution) depending on the action or inaction of the trademark holder, but someone defending an alleged infringement would still have to argue in court that one of these specific cases applied. And in no case does it mean that Apple Inc. has any reason to contact fruit growers. (This should be obvious from the fact that Apple does not in fact send cease-and-desist letters to fruit growers.)
- yuvouv 17y agoYou can lose a trademark case if you have been too selective in who you complain about. Especially if you are seen to be ignoring small time infringers but only going after those with big pockets, the case can be thrown out. Lawyers tend to err on the side of sending C+D letters to anyone, such as the case of Sun and the island of Java tourist authority. The apple/orchards bit was irony - it's in the dictionary. The other problem is judges/juries and computers. The trademark has to be in the same field, but the courts aren't always as tech savvy as HN readers and frequently regard all 'computer stuff' as the same field. So while we would see a CRM package and a forum website as completely different as a magnolia plant shop and a magnolia paint company - a judge might not.