6 ms·
Chimpanzee Intelligence Is Heritable [pdf]
- ytturbed 12y agoFascinating stuff but the concept of intelligence is rather nebulous. Their operational definition is cobbled together from things that people have intuitively considered important like eye tracking and tool use. But these aren't connected to any deeper explanatory theories. Personally I'd be inclined to selectively breed chimps on the basis of how well they follow instructions (since instructions are perforce couched in abstract symbols and language is the quintessentially human trait).
- wyager 12y ago>how well they follow instructions It is possible to be intelligent and unwilling to follow instructions. In fact, I would not be surprised if there was an inverse correlation between the two in humans.
- ytturbed 12y ago>It is possible to be intelligent and unwilling to follow instructions True. But whether an instruction has been followed is easy to measure and relates directly to language, unlike the other criteria in Table 1. Also, note that chimps are capable of tearing limbs from humans. So if people could be bred from them I would like them to be basically friendly and cooperative.
- jsnk 12y agoI feel like every chatter about intelligence comes down to arguing over the operational definition of intelligence. Isn't it obvious that abilities such as simple arithmetics, memory, linguistic ability, recognizing patterns have at least something to do with intelligence?
- ytturbed 12y agoNo, it's not obvious. If it were then we'd have programmed an AGI by now.
- JamesArgo 12y agoSo basically, we can't make a photodetector without first being able to create a sun?
- ytturbed 12y agoWe can't measure things we don't understand. Note that a photodetector detects light, not suns.
- JamesArgo 12y ago>We can't measure things we don't understand. What? Was everyone blind before the discovery of quantum mechanics? If we can't measure things we don't understand, how the heck would we come to understand them? Through their affects on the world? "No, you say, "we can not perceive things whose causes we don't understand." Where did you get your epistemology? Was it The Secret?
- ytturbed 12y ago>Where did you get your epistemology? Karl Popper. >If we can't measure things we don't understand, how the heck would we come to understand them? We get new ideas, such as the concept of distance, by guessing them in response to problems.
- Humjob 12y agoVery interesting. This topic has some rather pertinent parallels to our current civilization. Suppose: a) Human intelligence is heritable. b) Less intelligent humans are more fertile than their brighter peers. c) The breeding of the less intelligent is subsidized by society over a long period of time. What are the long term consequences going to be? I'd bet Peter Thiel has secretly considered this among his theories of why innovation has slowed, but wouldn't dare say so in public.
- JamesArgo 12y ago>Human intelligence is heritable. This is indisputable. Denying IQ and its heritability is equivalent to denying global warming. It’s settled science. Dysgenics is certainly possible. I think technology like iterated embryo selection and genetic engineering will come into common use before dysgenics kicks in. China is already investigating these possibilities, and their culture does not have the same memetic immune response to such ideas. After one country makes it legal, competitive pressures will force the rest of the world to do it, too. Iterated embryo selection could conservatively raise IQ by 60 points, likely much much more: http://www.nickbostrom.com/papers/embryo.pdf http://www.nickbostrom.com/papers/embryo.pdf A government would have to be supernaturally incompetent to allow such a gap to develop.
- rational-future 12y agoVery interesting arguments. That link is quite hard to understand. Is it saying that by throwing out embryos, until you hit a lucky, intelligent one, you can raise the average IQ to around 160?
- JamesArgo 12y agoSlightly-misleading TLDR: Iterated embryo selection is sort of test tube reproduction and selectiong. If you can create gametes from stem cells, then create many more embryos with these gametes and then score each embryo, repeating the process selecting for those that have the best genetic correlates of cognitive ability, you can perform the equivalent of a 2000 year eugenics experiment in a test tube in about six months. You could potentially get far, far higher IQs than 160. Prerequisites for this are cheap-gene sequencing, very, very large databases of genomes tagged with their donor’s cognitive measures, and advances in human stem cell research.
- tormeh 12y agoHow is this stuff still controversial?
- wyager 12y ago>How is this stuff still controversial? Because people are scared to make claims about trait heritability in humans. The moment someone publicly says anything about e.g. genetics influencing human intelligence, someone flies out of left field and accuses them of being a racist. The absolute inanity of political correctness has turned certain areas of scientific inquiry into political minefields.
- 1ris 12y agoYou are probably correct about political correctness, but it's not that easy. As a start: There is proper definition of intelligence. A friend of mine currently is evaluating current standard tests for emotional intelligence as part of a midsize project (I think several Ph.D.s and various bachelor/master thesises) and from what he tells the state for the art is more guesswork then science.
- riffraff 12y agois the "more guesswork then science" related to emotional intelligence or intelligence tests in general? (I have no idea how either tests work, but I'd be inclined to believe it's harder to test for "tactfulness" than "ability to recognize patterns")
- 1ris 12y agoI only know about emotional intelligence, but I think other forms of intelligence are more reliable. But I want to stress that the idea that intelligence is multidimensional, and that there is such a thing as emotional intelligence is scientific consensus.
- clarkm 12y agoFor the same reason that it's still controversial that chimps go to war even with not threatened. Some scientists see findings like this as an affront to their closely-held beliefs about humans and human nature. And since these beliefs often have political implications, human tribalism takes over. What begins as a benign debate over, e.g. the validity of research methods, often devolves into controversy that's actually a proxy war for some tangentially related idea.
- lumberjack 12y agoSlightly related but I always wondered why is it that children of geniuses rarely if ever reach the same level of accomplishment as their parent(s) despite having a better chance over all than their genius parent(s) had.
- dnautics 12y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regression_toward_the_mean https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regression_toward_the_mean
- JamesArgo 12y agoThis is just regression toward the mean.
- api 12y ago"... while the wealthy are no more likely to be born stupid than the poor , a wealthy upbringing compounds stupidity while a hardscrabble childhood dilutes it, if only for Darwinian reasons. This is why the elite need a prophylactic barrier of shitty state schools, to prevent clever kids from working-class post codes ousting them from the Enclave of Privilege." Mitchell, David (2014-09-02). The Bone Clocks: A Novel (p. 179). Random House Publishing Group. Kindle Edition.
- tokenadult 12y agoI read this article earlier when it was first published. I have also read most of the prior literature cited in the article's references. A review article, by some of the same authors the article kindly submitted here cites, gets at the nub of the issue. "Moreover, even highly heritable traits can be strongly manipulated by the environment, so heritability has little if anything to do with controllability. For example, height is on the order of 90% heritable, yet North and South Koreans, who come from the same genetic background, presently differ in average height by a full 6 inches (Pak, 2004; Schwekendiek, 2008)."[1] It is completely unremarkable that chimpanzee studies show "heritability" for what counts as intelligence (by this study's model) among chimpanzees. In general, for any trait, closely related individuals show a stronger resemblance than less closely related individuals, and that is what "heritability" means, nothing more. Eric Turkheimer (one of the authors cited in the article submitted here, and a co-author of the review article I have just quoted and cited) declared as the "first law of behavior genetics" that all human behavioral characteristics are heritable, and that is very close to being literally true. But he also writes, in a later commentary article, "Heritability isn't an index of how genetic a trait is. A great deal of time has been wasted in the effort of measuring the heritability of traits in the false expectation that somehow the genetic nature of psychological phenomena would be revealed. There are many reasons for making this strong statement, but the most important of them harkens back to the description of heritability as an effect size."[2] The chimp research is interesting, and I suppose other researchers will try to replicate or refine it, but it still leaves us a long way from understanding the genetics of human intelligence. Human intelligence is indubitably influenced by hundreds of genes, each of small effect size, and many with unknown pleiotropic effects. We are so far nowhere near understanding what genes do to influence human intelligence. "At the time most of the results we attempted to replicate were obtained, candidate-gene studies of complex traits were commonplace in medical genetics research. Such studies are now rarely published in leading journals. Our results add IQ to the list of phenotypes that must be approached with great caution when considering published molecular genetic associations. In our view, excitement over the value of behavioral and molecular genetic studies in the social sciences should be tempered—as it has been in the medical sciences—by an appreciation that, for complex phenotypes, individual common genetic variants of the sort assayed by SNP microarrays are likely to have very small effects. Associations of candidate genes with psychological traits and other traits studied in the social sciences should be viewed as tentative until they have been replicated in multiple large samples. Doing otherwise may hamper scientific progress by proliferating potentially false results, which may then influence the research agendas of scientists who do not appreciate that the associations they take as a starting point for their efforts may not be real. And the dissemination of false results to the public risks creating an incorrect perception about the state of knowledge in the field, especially the existence of genes described as being 'for' traits on the basis of unintentionally inflated estimates of effect size and statistical significance."[3] Meanwhile, we know that even monozygotic ("identical") twins can be discordant for IQ or for any other human behavioral trait (this observation is also called a "law of behavior genetics"), so the one thing we can be sure of is that something other than genes matters for the expression of absolutely every trait that a human being can have. This being well known, those of us who have already received our shuffle of genes may as well devote time, money, and effort to finding out what environmental factors may help us engage in problem-solving about important human problems. [1] Johnson, Wendy; Turkheimer, Eric; Gottesman, Irving I.; Bouchard Jr., Thomas (2009). Beyond Heritability: Twin Studies in Behavioral Research. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 18, 4, 217-220 http://people.virginia.edu/~ent3c/papers2/Articles%20for%20Online%20CV/Johnson%20(2009).pdf http://people.virginia.edu/~ent3c/papers2/Articles%20for%20O... [2] Turkheimer, E. (2008, Spring). A better way to use twins for developmental research. LIFE Newsletter, 2, 1-5. http://people.virginia.edu/~ent3c/papers2/Articles%20for%20Online%20CV/Turkheimer%20(2008).pdf http://people.virginia.edu/~ent3c/papers2/Articles%20for%20O... [3] Chabris, C. F., Hebert, B. M., Benjamin, D. J., Beauchamp, J., Cesarini, D., van der Loos, M., ... & Laibson, D. (2012). Most reported genetic associations with general intelligence are probably false positives. Psychological science, 23(11), 1314-1323. DOI: 10.1177/0956797611435528 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3498585/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3498585/ http://dash.harvard.edu/bitstream/handle/1/9938142/Most_Reported_Genetic.pdf?sequence=1 http://dash.harvard.edu/bitstream/handle/1/9938142/Most_Repo...
- dengnan 12y agoThis is off topic: Is it the typical length of a biological paper? I mean in computer science field, a full paper would be 10~14 pages. Composed of 5~7 pages of experiment results. On the other hand, this paper only contains one table of result and a figure with quite large fonts. I would like to know if this is normal in this field? Edit: typo
- gwern 12y agoIt really depends on the journal and format. I've seen some very long articles and also biology articles in Nature which are maybe 2 pages, including references in teen-tiny font (and nigh-incomprehensible). In this case, there's something similar: a lot of the information a CS paper might include inline has been shunted aside to "Supplemental Information includes one figure, three tables, and Supplemental Experimental Procedures and can be found with this article online at http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2014.05.076 http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2014.05.076 ", and much of the background here (eg the development of the test battery) is in previous papers. This is more reporting the apex of their work, if you will.