3 ms·
I think this is at the root of what really bugs (some) U.S. Americans about soccer, but they are unable to express it. Sports popular in the U.S. almost seem d
by jimbokun 17y ago
I think this is at the root of what really bugs (some) U.S. Americans about soccer, but they are unable to express it.
Sports popular in the U.S. almost seem designed to allow for statistical analysis. Baseball is the ultimate game for a statistician, as you have data for every single pitch thrown and the outcome. American Football breaks the game down into series of discrete events (downs) each of which has a numerical outcomes (yards gained or lost). Basketball generates 10s of events every game with a definite outcome that can generally be assigned to a single player (shot made, missed, turnover, free throw, rebound, etc.).
All of this gives fans ways to analyze and rank individual players and teams in a fairly objective way. Thus, the immense popularity of fantasy leagues.
Soccer is inherently more subjective, as there are far fewer events with an objective outcome. With scoring a rare event, and no obvious ways to assign numerical values to all the things that happen between scoring chances, subjective analysis is all that's available.
Which ties back into the original article in that freak occurrences and dumb luck can have a much larger impact in soccer. One team can play much better for most of the game, but a freak goal, controversial call or uncharacteristic error can have an outsize impact in a low scoring affair. This is mitigated in the round robin format rounds with accumulated wins and points, but is very much a factor in one-and-done games.
I believe I read before that at one time even the final round was a multi team affair, with the champion determined by cumulative totals against the other teams, but it was done away with because fans wanted a definitive championship match between just two teams.
- philwelch 17y agoDumb luck plays an even bigger role in American football though. In American football a small amount of turnovers can dictate the result of the whole game. It is way more unpredictable than even soccer, which has some 90 minutes of uninterrupted play where each team continuously tries to either hold or gain possession and make an attack. Plus, soccer has more statistics than you'd realize: proportion of possession, number of corner kicks, number of crosses, number of shots, percentage of shots on target, possession per area of the field, etc.
- mdg 17y agoWhen discussing a players career though, typically its goals, and appearences per club.
- sfg 17y agoYou can get a lot of statistics from a game of cricket, but it does not seem to have taken off in the U.S.
- Perceval 17y agoCricket and baseball are substitute goods. If you have one, you don't really need the other. For example, baseball hasn't taken off in the Commonwealth either.
- hughprime 17y agoRight. Likewise, American football and soccer are substitute goods as well. Americans don't dislike soccer because of any particular quirk of its scoring system, they just dislike soccer because they already have another sport which fulfills the same function. It's just a historical quirk.
- dasil003 17y agoHow is American football at all like soccer? It's much more like rugby, and you don't see rugby displacing soccer.
- hughprime 17y agoIt's like soccer in that it's an outdoor game that we play on an open field in winter. Doesn't rugby displace soccer? The only place I know where rugby is taken seriously as a spectator sport is Australia (maybe NZ and South Africa as well?), and sure enough soccer is a niche sport played by students and amateurs, only being seriously watched when Australia is competing in an international competition. In Britain, on the other hand, soccer is the main spectator sport in winter, and it's rugby that's confined to high schools and international competitions. Is there anywhere that rugby and soccer are both equally (or almost-equally) popular?
- jimbokun 17y agoWikipedia suggests all three (and other sports) have a common history, and that the word "foot" in the names of these games might have originally come from the fact that these games were played "on foot," as opposed to horseback games. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Football#Etymology http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Football#Etymology