4 ms·
"But the panic turned out to be overblown" No it wasn't. The panic caused changes that fixed the problem. A self fulfilling prophecy in reverse if you will. Y
by ars 12y ago
"But the panic turned out to be overblown"
No it wasn't. The panic caused changes that fixed the problem.
A self fulfilling prophecy in reverse if you will. Y2K was the same way - because of the panic people fixed things and there was no problem.
- latch 12y agoThe panic was that the situation would cause drastic harm, not that it wasn't a real issue. The fact that they fixed the problem is exactly the reason why it was overblown. (according to the article, anyways).
- pyre 12y agoWith (e.g.) the Y2K example, things were fixed due to massive amounts of money invested in fixing the problem. If every says "Y2K wasn't a big issue, we really shouldn't invest in fixing the next problem" that will cause issues down the road...
- bryanlarsen 12y agoThe high prices fixed the problem. The high prices caused profit seekers to reopen old mines and users to search for alternatives.
- tuan5 12y ago+1
- TheSoftwareGuy 12y agoTL;DR It turns out that the principles of supply & demand worked. hooray for the free market.
- gd1 12y agoNo, Y2K really was horrendously overblown. Is it too much to ask to have the panic and the response be proportional to the problem? You seem to be arguing that an overblown panic is ok as long as it achieves something. The panic can cause more damage/costs than the underlying problem.
- lnanek2 12y agoIt wasn't overblown. You should see some of the systems large businesses use. Marriott still uses green screen terminals, for example, others use mainframes. ATMs often run archaic versions of Windows CE. If all air carriers shutdown because their archaic systems couldn't have handled the change over, then it would have been a disaster. It wasn't because it made news and everyone knew about it and remedied the systems. Clueless people sitting in front of modern mac books running modern OSes have no clue.
- gd1 12y agoMate, I'm probably older than you. It was 90 % overblown nonsense. Countries like Russia spent pretty much zero 'fixing' it and had no issues. Meanwhile the US had 'Y2K consultants', shysters selling $20 'patches' to fix your windows install, breathless documentaries about how your toaster and VCR would explode, planes would drop from the sky, the financial system would collapse...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- lucozade 12y agoIn many cases it was overblown. We were forced to upgrade to Y2K compatible versions of pretty much every OS and 3rd party software we used. We also had to show that we were taking it seriously which, effectively, meant showing we were spending a lot of money on it. We spent about a week proving we weren't affected then spent about a year testing and shipping all the random upgrades. Ironically, the effect of all the change was much more risky than the original issue would have been even if we had been susceptible. On the plus side, we ended up with the latest versions of tooling etc which we didn't usually get budget for but it had nothing directly to do with Y2K.
- antimagic 12y agoYup. I personally patched an air traffic control system that would invariably crash because of Y2K - in other words without the patch, there was no ATC... Some people miss this - the only thing we were doing with that date was showing it onscreen. But someone had written code into a fixed length buffer, expecting the year to only be two digits long, and that year was calculated as (current-year - 1900), so when 2000 ticked around, boom! Buffer overflow, system crashes and you're screwed. It went from being a minor bug to being a system destroyer. The problem was real, and even if the patch to fix it wasn't rocket science, it still took time to track down the problems. Much of the affected code was more than 20 years old, and no-one had looked at it or even compiled it in years. Bringing that code back to life to be able to insert a fix was no small issue that could be corrected in the middle of a crisis. Multiply that by all of the other potentially critical systems, such as power transmission, medical equipment, factory plant, and you're staring down the barrel of a potential disaster. I don't understand why some people today want to pretend that there wasn't ever a real problem for Y2K - I saw failing systems with my own eyes.
- ddlatham 12y agoA self preventing prophecy, perhaps?