10 ms·
China no longer has a stranglehold on the world's supply of rare earth metals
- ars 12y ago"But the panic turned out to be overblown" No it wasn't. The panic caused changes that fixed the problem. A self fulfilling prophecy in reverse if you will. Y2K was the same way - because of the panic people fixed things and there was no problem.
- latch 12y agoThe panic was that the situation would cause drastic harm, not that it wasn't a real issue. The fact that they fixed the problem is exactly the reason why it was overblown. (according to the article, anyways).
- pyre 12y agoWith (e.g.) the Y2K example, things were fixed due to massive amounts of money invested in fixing the problem. If every says "Y2K wasn't a big issue, we really shouldn't invest in fixing the next problem" that will cause issues down the road...
- bryanlarsen 12y agoThe high prices fixed the problem. The high prices caused profit seekers to reopen old mines and users to search for alternatives.
- tuan5 12y ago+1
- TheSoftwareGuy 12y agoTL;DR It turns out that the principles of supply & demand worked. hooray for the free market.
- gd1 12y agoNo, Y2K really was horrendously overblown. Is it too much to ask to have the panic and the response be proportional to the problem? You seem to be arguing that an overblown panic is ok as long as it achieves something. The panic can cause more damage/costs than the underlying problem.
- lnanek2 12y agoIt wasn't overblown. You should see some of the systems large businesses use. Marriott still uses green screen terminals, for example, others use mainframes. ATMs often run archaic versions of Windows CE. If all air carriers shutdown because their archaic systems couldn't have handled the change over, then it would have been a disaster. It wasn't because it made news and everyone knew about it and remedied the systems. Clueless people sitting in front of modern mac books running modern OSes have no clue.
- gd1 12y agoMate, I'm probably older than you. It was 90 % overblown nonsense. Countries like Russia spent pretty much zero 'fixing' it and had no issues. Meanwhile the US had 'Y2K consultants', shysters selling $20 'patches' to fix your windows install, breathless documentaries about how your toaster and VCR would explode, planes would drop from the sky, the financial system would collapse...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- lucozade 12y agoIn many cases it was overblown. We were forced to upgrade to Y2K compatible versions of pretty much every OS and 3rd party software we used. We also had to show that we were taking it seriously which, effectively, meant showing we were spending a lot of money on it. We spent about a week proving we weren't affected then spent about a year testing and shipping all the random upgrades. Ironically, the effect of all the change was much more risky than the original issue would have been even if we had been susceptible. On the plus side, we ended up with the latest versions of tooling etc which we didn't usually get budget for but it had nothing directly to do with Y2K.
- ddlatham 12y agoA self preventing prophecy, perhaps?
- higherpurpose 12y ago> Not long after China restricted exports, other countries quickly began producing their own rare earths — or finding ways to reduce their reliance on the metals. As a result, China's control of the market is much diminished today. This reminds me of how Google Reader had near ubiquity in the RSS reader market, and as soon as they announced the shutdown 20 new RSS readers popped up.
- ck2 12y ago"Rare earth" metals aren't rare. The USA has plenty, we just don't have the underpaid labor to mine it and actual regulations that make it more expensive to mine. Ironically some of the best land for it in the USA is owned by Canadian corporations. Why are we selling something considered a national resource to foreign owners?
- evgen 12y agoBecause Canadians are easy to keep under control and the actual land containing the rare earth metals is in the US, which means that we can take it back if that ever becomes necessary.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoYou seem to be saying here that the USA isn't economically able to use certain natural resources but that these unprofitable resources should not be open to purchase on a free market by Canadian companies. That sounds a lot like a soviet style planned economy.
- _delirium 12y agoYou don't have to be the USSR to manage at least substantial portions of a country's infrastructure and natural resources in a rational way, designed to maximize national welfare. It's a reasonably common way to operate in prosperous western democracies: Statoil (Norway), Hydro-Québec (Canada), DONG Energy (Denmark), Vattenfall (Sweden), Électricité de France (France), LKAB (Sweden), Deutsche Bahn (Germany), are all well-run state-owned companies, with no gulags in sight.
- shiven 12y agonational welfare Now, now! You are one step away from being labeled a Socialist and then, a Commie! In the US of A, we don't ever say national, unless the next word is defense, and welfare is a dirty word you know, just a step from thievery. Dangnummit!
- lotsofmangos 12y ago
- davidw 12y agoFor some things, markets work pretty well. Prices go up, people have a big incentive to supply the good.
- vince_refiti 12y agoImagine if the Chinese were able to patent the process of mining and processing the rare metals. And bombarded everyone with frivolous lawsuits. Good thing these crazy scenarios don't happen.
- davidw 12y ago> patent the process of mining and processing the rare metals If they were to make big and non-obvious improvements that allow everyone to mine and/or process more efficiently, then that's exactly what patents are supposed to do: they get a temporary monopoly on those improvements in return for sharing them with the world. But I have the feeling you're just spouting off a bit :-)
- thescrewdriver 12y agoSince when did only non-obvious improvements get patented?
- briantakita 12y agoI suppose you don't agree with the phrase "standing on the shoulder of giants". The fact that, through history, people create novelty & discovery without the "incentive" of ownership, invalidates the "need" for patents to provide an "incentive" of exclusivity. Re: patents, those who own the capital also own the patents. It's simply a mechanism to control others by restricting who can use an idea originally developed by "standing on the shoulder of giants". So if you own lots of capital, patents allow you to control others. If you don't own lots of capital, patents are oppressive.
- davidw 12y ago> The fact that, through history, people create novelty & discovery without the "incentive" of ownership, invalidates the "need" for patents to provide an "incentive" of exclusivity. But are they creating at an optimal rate? Without patents, would they still create nearly as much stuff? It's a fascinating question. My view is that it's all a bit of a messy compromise, and neat, clean answers like "abolish patents" are probably a bad idea. I'd be in favor of some major reforms, and severely limit them in some fields.
- wnevets 12y agoUntil china decides to sell those metals at a lose again driving these other companies out of business. Power of the free market
- seanflyon 12y agoIf China wants to give us some free money for a while, I'm not too concerned. We can start these companies back up faster next time and anyone concerned with a temporary future price increase can either pay a premium to keep some of these companies going, or stockpile the metals.
- lnanek2 12y agoMuch like how high enough oil prices mean processing oil shale and digging deeper/sideways start to make economic sense, which then prevents further price rise.
- oftenwrong 12y agoI guess I shouldn't be surprised that the mostly-American HN will upvote an article with such a blatant anti-Chinese bias. From the first sentence this article paints China as the "bad guy". China is not the only country that has used economic pressure to protect its interests.
- hyperpape 12y agoMaybe some people feel this way, but you're assuming far too much. I don't want any country (including mine) to have a monopoly on any resource. At best, it enriches that country to no one else's benefit. At worst, it leaves room for threats to the world economy. Sure, I trust China less than I trust Denmark (but I also trust Denmark more than the US), but that's not even the point.
- jp555 12y agoCapitalism is the pursuit of monopolies. Does it matter if there's cheap minerals when a patent, exclusive licence agreement, or lack of adequate engineers blocks any possibility of making a competing product? Raw materials are not the only resources that can be subject to monopolies. There is only one Gordon Ramsey, and he uses this monopoly to get asymmetric profit out of the horribly competitive restaurant market.
- Symmetry 12y agoNo, capitalism is a system wherein the means of production are privately owned and can be bought and sold. Capitalists can pursue anything they wish and still be capitalists, including monopolies, but usually they try to maximize their profits rather than their market share.
- jp555 12y agoMaximizing profit is the pursuit of monopolies. In a market with perfect competition there are no profits.
- kelvin0 12y agoI am not that familiar with the CFR. But it seems the article has been written by someone who is a member (or at leasy associated with it). Is anyone familiar with the CFR from an insider`s perspective? What biases should I expect when reading content from their web site? http://www.cfr.org/energy-and-environment/rare-earth-elements-national-security/p33632?cid=nlc-press_release-press_note--link3-20141021&sp_mid=47239399&sp_rid=ZHJvYmVydHNAZ3Jpc3Qub3JnS0 http://www.cfr.org/energy-and-environment/rare-earth-element...
- arca_vorago 12y agoRegarding the author: " Eugene Gholz is an Associate Professor who works primarily at the intersection of national security and economic policy. From 2010-2012, he served in the Pentagon as Senior Advisor to the Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Manufacturing and Industrial Base Policy, where he led initiatives to better understand the complex defense supply chain and to apply that understanding in the budget process. He also focused on policy regarding reimbursement of industry's Independent Research and Development (IR&D) expenditures. Before working in the Pentagon, he directed the LBJ School's master’s program in global policy studies from 2007–10. Dr. Gholz works on innovation, defense management, and U.S. foreign policy. He is the coauthor of two books: Buying Military Transformation: Technological Innovation and the Defense Industry, and U.S. Defense Politics: The Origins of Security Policy. His recent scholarship focuses on energy security. He previously taught at the University of Kentucky's Patterson School of Diplomacy and International Commerce. He is also a research affiliate of MIT's Security Studies Program, a member of the Council on Foreign Relations, and associate editor of the journal Security Studies. His PhD is from MIT." So he seems to be the pretty standard international power academic. As for the Council, what you can always expect is a globalized view biased towards big business interests. That's who started it, and that's who have run it ever since. It's essentially the non K-Street American government "mind lobbying" program for the international elite. If you are still curious I would highly recommend research along the following lines. Paris Peace Conference, Woodrow Wilson and Edward House, and the Reece Committee.
- kelvin0 12y agoThanks, but I did read that bit from his paper (at the end of it). What troubles me is that it seems that the CFR is referred to a lot by some alternative news outlets (in not so glowing terms). Also it seems to try hard to portray itself to be a non-partisan think tank. I will look at the references you gave me, much appreciated ...
- madaxe_again 12y agoForget about the more exotic rare earths for a minute. Tantalum. Tungsten. We use these in all consumer electronics - Tantalum is a major component of capacitors and resistors. Here are a pair of amazingly short lists, which show all of the known, non-war-fuelled, smelters in the world: http://www.conflictfreesourcing.org/tungsten-conflict-free-smelters/ http://www.conflictfreesourcing.org/tungsten-conflict-free-s... http://www.conflictfreesourcing.org/tantalum-conflict-free-smelters/ http://www.conflictfreesourcing.org/tantalum-conflict-free-s...? Yes, there's no national stranglehold, but it's an area of risk that nobody really seems to be aware of - it wouldn't take much to completely disrupt the global materials supply chain for the electronics industry.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- badsock 12y agoTantalum capacitors are increasingly rare, and are trivial to substitute. Tantalum resistors I would say are downright exotic. And other than lightbulbs, I've never heard of tungsten used in electronics.
- nickff 12y agoTantalum capacitors are only "trivial to substitute" in some applications; as someone who works in electronic hardware, I can assure you that it is often impossible to use any other part, and achieve the same performance.
- badsock 12y agoSorry, you're right - tant caps are irreplacable in some applications. I overcorrected on madaxe_again's assertation that tantalum used universally in electronics, when really the number of places that it's used, and couldn't be replaced if supply was cut off, isn't huge. That number certainly isn't zero though.
- tsomctl 12y agoTIG welding (Tungsten, Inert Gas) is pretty common. To substitute it, you would have to find another metal with a similar high melting point.
- ytturbed 12y agoRocks are passing by us all the time at distances comparable to the moon's orbit. Some of them are rich in rare metals. Some of them threaten the Earth itself. So let's deflect them onto the moon, noting the crash sites. This will (a) teach us how to defend the Earth, (b) create an incentive for mining companies to build a moon base, (c) increase the supply of rare metals.
- andrewflnr 12y agoSince you talk about deflecting asteroids, you may find this perspective interesting. http://qntm.org/asteroids http://qntm.org/asteroids
- ytturbed 12y agoThe perspective is that humans can't be trusted with asteroid deflecting technology in case they use it to attack Earth. But this ignores the fact that nature has already placed an asteroid out there with our name on it. Which will kill us if we don't do our duty and prevent it!
- ChuckMcM 12y agoI was not surprised at the rise in production, I spent my college years driving by the old rare earth mine at Mountain Pass[1] but what really surprised me was that China totally blew it on this. They had a near monopoly on the production of rare earths, and if they had just moved the prices up slowly, I believe they would have captured far more value before it triggered a ramp up of external suppliers. [1] Las Vegas to LA and back. Got out to look around once when the workings were basically abandoned but decided against it after seeing all the radiation warning signs :-)
- stcredzero 12y agoChina totally blew it on this. They had a near monopoly on the production of rare earths, and if they had just moved the prices up slowly, I believe they would have captured far more value before it triggered a ramp up of external suppliers. I think this is a valuable observation with respect to how well the Chinese government works with regards to long term decisions.
- briantakita 12y ago> in the 1980s, China ramped up production massively, driving out competitors and cornering the market. (China could do this, in part, by going easy on environmental oversight of mining, which can be a horrifically dirty process.) > When China decided to restrict exports in 2010, that drove prices up and suddenly made it profitable for other countries to start boosting their own production again. This in an example where "free markets" cause major environmental issues.