3 ms·
Singapore is an extremely small, very rich country with hyper population density. I don't see how that's a great example. They should have some of the fastest I
by adventured 12y ago
Singapore is an extremely small, very rich country with hyper population density. I don't see how that's a great example. They should have some of the fastest Internet speeds on the planet.
How about in Russia, Canada, US, China, Brazil, Australia, India, Argentina, Kazakhstan, Algeria, Congo, Saudi Arabia, Mexico, Indonesia, Sudan, Libya, Iran, Mongolia, Peru, Chad, Niger, Angola?
Those are the largest countries in the world. Presents a drastically different challenge wouldn't you say?
- stephen_g 12y agoIn Australia at least it's not actually a problem. While we have an incredibly low population density, it turns out that almost all (92 to 95% or something) of the population actually live in fairly highly populated cities and towns. The vast majority of the country is mostly uninhabited apart from a thin strip around parts of the coast and then a few inland cities. This is why the previous Australian Government set out to build a wholesale-only fibre network that the private carriers could competitively deliver services over, to reach 93% of the population (the remaining 7% is a combination of satellite and fixed wireless). This was to fix a problem that had been created by a past Government when the old Government-owned monopoly carrier had been privatised into a single huge anti-competitive company who doesn't do any upgrades unless somebody else does - such as when another company put in an HFC network, the monopoly (Telstra) overbuilt almost the exact same areas with a competing network, not touching anywhere else... Unfortunatley the new Government is dismantling the new plan, and replacing it with a token FTTN effort to "save money" because of a fallacious "budget emergency", even though financial modeling shows that the FTTP plan actually had a better chance of making a profit (which was to be re-invested in expanding the fibre footprint and upgrading the network). Strangely enough, it's the party who created the Telstra problem last time they were in power...
- jquery 12y ago> Singapore is an extremely small, very rich country with hyper population density. I don't see how that's a great example. They should have some of the fastest Internet speeds on the planet. Why shouldn't at least New York and Bay Area be comparable? Rich and hyper-dense. --submitted from an 4 megabit connection in SF.
- rhino369 12y agoNew York and the Bay Area aren't all that dense by major city standards. But the real reason for the difference isn't really density. It is government telecom policy. The countries that deployed fiber have, for the most part, either heavily subsidized it via direct subsidies or tax breaks. In Sweden's case, for example, forced state run utilities to build the backbone for the telecoms. The US expects the telecom investment to be 100% privately funded. That means it has to be profitable enough to attract capital investments. Unlike say Sweeden, were everyone has to use the single telecom provider's network, in the US there is no such mandate. Verizon's FIOS network has to compete with the cable companies network (which is vastly cheaper). Fios is only getting around 25% of people who have potential access to sign up. The Singapore network probably gets 90% or more. If you really want fiber in the entire USA. Give Verizon, ATT, Century Link, and the other incumbent local loop carriers huge tax incentives to do it. Otherwise it'll happen slowly when people are willing to pay a premium for higher speed.