11 ms·
How Wizards of the Coast distributed equity as a startup
- nwhitehead 12y agoIt's funny how everyone seems to have a different view of how equity should work. I'm reading Felix Dennis "How to Get Rich" (highly recommended, much better than the title makes it sound). He made his fortune in magazine publishing which is actually somewhat close to Wizards of the Coast in business model. His view is exactly opposite; fight as if your life depended on every share, and pay people bonuses to incentivize performance.
- joelrunyon 12y agoGreat book. Probably the best value to cheesy title ratio I've seen. I was hesitant to pick it up initially, but very happy I did. Really interesting to see how his view on equity shaped his businesses.
- ianferrel 12y agoHow does that apply to Wizards? They clearly didn't have any money to pay bonuses.
- kauffj 12y agoI love the idea of small scale stock offerings, but isn't this illegal? My understanding was that selling stock like this is a private equity offering and that private equity offerings are limited to a small number of people unless the investor is sufficiently rich (the government likes to use the term "accredited investor").
- mathattack 12y agoGiving in lieu of services isn't illegal. I believe that selling them without some kind of legal preparation is. (Strange) Another challenge is you are limited to the # of owners you can have in a pre-IPO company.
- sgk284 12y agoThe "accredited investor" restriction usually only applies if you're shopping the stock around. If the person getting the stock qualifies as a "friend or family", the restriction doesn't apply. Hence the term "Friends and Family Round".
- tptacek 12y agoThere's a whole mess of exceptions to the rule you're referring to, but equally importantly, it's not so much "illegal" as "unlawful". For instance, many of the bad things that happen if you flout this rule only happen if you have disgruntled (or ruthless) shareholders. It's a very bad idea to ignore the "reg D" type rules, but it's not the kind of thing where random people are likely to be able to report you to the SEC and get you fined.
- gcb0 12y agohe did mention they had disgruntled shareholders. e.g. complaining about paying $300k for a $100 item. couldn't they have used that to halt the payment to the small (and illegal) shareholders of the past?
- tptacek 12y agoI don't know, but the sense I got is that those stakeholders were larger, more formal investors, in which case RegD doesn't help them --- they're assumed to be sophisticated.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- matthewmcg 12y agoThe Securities Act has existed since 1933.
- teachingaway 12y ago>> the very beginning, I wanted all my friends to be shareholders. If I had a deep, intellectual conversation with someone, I’d give them 10 shares. Yeah, it probably violates some securities laws... but when everyone makes lots of money on the deal, there's rarely an issue. When investors lose money, they're all too happy to bring up securities law violations and fraud claims. Better to do everything by the book and not give anyone an excuse to sue you later. I'm not a securities lawyer, but in a nutshell, startup companies should prefer a very small number of professional (and accredited) investors.
- dnautics 12y agoI think most of the accredited investor rules deal with solicitation. If someone approaches you and makes an offer and you agree to it it's okay (pitching to friends and family), but I am not a lawyer.
- zaroth 12y agoThe most basic provision on a private sale of private stock places no restrictions on the sale that 'does not involve a public offering'. So in theory it's only when you start "looking" for investors, when you are "publicly" selling the shares, then you want a Reg D 506 exemption, and accredited investors. However, in practice the Section 4(a)(2) exemption is often not strong enough protection (since we're talking potentially significant civil and criminal charges) so companies go for the Reg D safe harbors even when not technically required. Particularly for unsophisticated / unaccredited investors, the courts have found that 4(a)(2) is not good enough, even when the sale was arguably private. See, for example, SEC v. Ralston Purina Co., 346 U.S. 119 (1953). [1] Following the path of Reg D 506 is actually quite simple, and carries no downside. But even with Reg D 506 you generally try to avoid unsophisticated investors, since then you get into scenarios where you are supposed to provide 'access to the kind of information that a registration statement would disclose' which is very difficult. The crowdfunding regs in theory are supposed to help alleviate this. [1] - http://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=6019539454143305122 http://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=6019539454143305... [2] - IANAL
- zaroth 12y agoJust going to follow up on this to excerpt part of that Supreme Court decision; Exemption from the registration requirements of the Securities Act is the question. The design of the statute is to protect investors by promoting full disclosure of information thought necessary to informed investment decisions.[10] The natural way to interpret the private offering exemption is in light of the statutory purpose. Since exempt transactions are those as to which "there is no practical need for [the bill's] application," the applicability of § 4 (1) should turn on whether the particular class of persons affected needs the protection of the Act. An offering to those who are shown to be able to fend for themselves is a transaction "not involving any public offering." I truly dislike the logic, why can't we stick with the plain meaning of the text, but they are trying to protect people from swindlers so I can understand their goal. The end result is selling shares to the night janitor is almost certainly not allowed by 4(a)(2) but glad it turned out alright this time.
- rbcgerard 12y agoThere are a lot of exemptions - for example rule 504 of reg d is pretty liberal regarding how you raise funds as long as you raise less than $1m in a given 12 month period... I recall that if you raise money from people in only one state you may be able to rely on state level rules and registration requirements
- dtparr 12y ago>If I had a deep, intellectual conversation with someone, I’d give them 10 shares. At $0.50 per share, that was only $20 of fictional value, certainly a fair trade at the time! Is his multiplication bad, or am I misunderstanding something terribly?
- apetresc 12y agoHe multiplied by 2 instead of dividing. He meant $5.
- dtparr 12y agoOk, I thought that was the most likely, but didn't want to discount some sort of option-style benefit.
- mathattack 12y agoThis goes hand in hand with his admitting he didn't know how to price them. :-)
- cwh 12y agothanks, thought i was also crazy.
- DonHopkins 12y agoWell he did say "fictional".
- GeneralMayhem 12y agoThis is a great story, and I'm glad it worked out for them, but it's important to keep in mind that it's only one data point. This is exactly the sort of "I'll pay you in equity, and once my great idea makes it big you'll be rich!" approach that HN usually hates, because 99% of the time said payout never comes.
- mathattack 12y agoTrue. But it's nice to hear these stories. My brother gave our old man $5K in his startup in appreciation for several months of sleeping on the couch when money got tight. During a downturn my brother lost it all. When the dot com bubble hit, my old man realized he still had the stock, which was now in a parent of a parent, and got out with a 20x return.
- metaphorm 12y agoI think its not directly comparable. Wizards of the Coast was never a "my big idea that will change the world!" type of company. It was a a games publishing company. They didn't even have one particular game in mind when they started up. Magic came later. Initially they were doing pretty much any board game and RPG that wanted to cut a license deal with them. In fact, they still operate this way to a certain extent, even with Magic as the flagship product. Because Wizards was never an idea based company I don't think its fair to put them in the same bucket with the usual suspects who try to exploit naive young developers by not paying them for hard work.
- tptacek 12y agoAnother possible big difference between WOTC and a typical tech company is that there weren't as many professional financiers involved in WOTC's fundraising. Every round of "institutional" funding taken by a tech company revalues all the previously issued shares, and companies planning to go this route are structured to make that process as frictionless for the company as possible.
- tehwebguy 12y agoAnd there was no vesting
- benmathes 12y ago"But most of the value in this company came from two things: Richard Garfield creating Magic: The Gathering, and the employees. Not investors. It’s only appropriate that the distribution from the sale reflects that." Hear hear. Investors say that founders and employees are what make startups. I wish the cap tables reflected that.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- joshu 12y agoso how do you propose that change?
- bmajz 12y agoThis. Having been on both sides of the table (early employee and later a founder), I still struggle with what the right distribution would and should be. There are just so many factors to consider (pivots, investors, acquirers, risk) that it seems unlikely that a simple formula or blanket rule will guide people right. Probably case-by-case basis and a realization that information asymmetry + control in early stage companies leads to a slight, but correctable, favoring of founders/investors' interests.
- benmathes 12y agoYeah, I don't know the right breakdown. I just know that your run-of-the-mill founding teams (not founders, the teams) are relatively shafted.
- javajosh 12y agoI always feel dumb asking - but doesn't the total number of shares matter? The real thing you're buying is a fraction of the pie when someone buys your company, and it would seem to matter quite a lot whether the pie was cut into 10^3 or 10^6 pieces. Indeed, I wish we could just talk about ownership percentage instead of shares to remove the ambiguity. Why is there a reluctance for people to talk about this openly?
- georgeecollins 12y agoThe number of shares should be figured into the estimated price. If they figure the company is valued at $100, and a share at $0.50, then they should be issuing 200 shares. You should be completely mistrustful of anyone who offers you shares and doesn't tell you the # of shares outstanding. Alternately, if they tell you the value of a share, they should tell you the estimated value of the company. The alternative is presented in Mel Brooks' The Producers.
- ryanburk 12y ago> You should be completely mistrustful of anyone who offers you shares and doesn't tell you the # of shares outstanding. this is an amazingly important point that many people I've seen new to the startup world ignore to their peril. it is too easy to get big eyes when you hear you are getting 50,000 options not realizing that it is only 0.000001% of the company since you don't know # of shares outstanding, across all classes of shares.
- aetherson 12y agoIt's maddening, too, because nobody ever just tells you the actual shares. EVERYONE says, "You'll get 50,000 options!" My answer is always, "Okay, and what percentage of the company is that?" and the answer is always, "Um... I'd have to go look it up." Just once, I'd like someone to provide that information for me proactively. It would instantly increase my estimate of their integrity by 150%.
- 12y ago
- binarymax 12y ago"We did no mathematical analysis of how the stock should be priced; we didn’t have the skill to do that" Folks may not realize it while doing so, but developing complex gameplay that is perfectly balanced can be considered a feat of linear algebra. So that quote made me smile :)
- Beltiras 12y agoThey actually did a horrible job at making a balanced game as can be seen in the multiple revisions since. I loved it and I'm calling it a roaring success in most respects, but balance is not something I would attribute to the first several incarnations.
- pchristensen 12y agoThey knew that it was unbalanced and that some cards (Moxen, Ancestral Recall, etc) were too powerful, but that was on purpose because they expected scarcity to be a part of the metagame. If you were playing with your own group of friends who owned a few cards, the small total number of overpowered cards would be a fun diversion. They didn't anticipate the huge success and scale the game achieved. With a worldwide metagame and market for buying/selling cards, scarcity vanished as top players would pay up to get 4 of whatever card gave them an edge, so revisions had to be designed in balance, rather than rely on scarcity to create balance. Source: I read way too much MtG history a few years ago when I was working on my own card game.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoThere's more to it than that. They've re-released edition after edition to obsolete the previous. Used to be 1 mana got you a 1/0 or 1/1 creature with nothing else. Now you can get cards with 1 or two features, flying etc. Anybody using the old ones is a sucker. Its easy to think its all about the money, you have to buy new cards to keep competitive. In fact this is why our game club designed their own card game (Orion Empire, check it out on Kickstarter!) The idea is, new cards will always be different in some way from old ones, so no card is ever completely eclipsed. So you can buy new decks to keep it interesting, but your old one is probably still competitive.
- herbig 12y ago"So Do You Wear a Cape" is an excellent history of the founding and success of Magic: the Gathering and written in a way that you don't have to understand the game to grasp everything. I highly recommend checking that out.
- kenrikm 12y agoI think the most important takeaway is that he did not try and screw over the early shareholders, integrity is important. The story about the $280,000 drafting table is relevant, they needed the drafting table it contributed to the success, If you were to go down that line of thought I wonder how much each can of Soda bought for early Facebook employees "cost".
- LanceH 12y agoThere were a lot of drafting tables and tons of other stuff purchased totaling some unknown amount. But it was that drafting, in that place, with those cards which made a company. It's easy to criticize it for being $280k because we don't know the scenario where they don't have a table. Maybe that scenario is, "fuck it I'm not working on the floor any more" and the whole company is worth zero. Then there is the economics of it. Hindsight makes it all easy when you only question the costs of the winners.
- mproud 12y agoPeter says again and again how he did it might not have been the safest way, that perhaps he was lucky it worked out, that there could have been a better approach. He does recognize it’s all water under the bridge, that in the end, he got success. But just keep this in mind — the way they did it is probably not the best way. Edit: Read Blog Entry 2, Part 1: http://www.peteradkison.com/blog-entry-2-wizards-of-the-coast-equity-distributions-part-1/ http://www.peteradkison.com/blog-entry-2-wizards-of-the-coas...
- ryanburk 12y agocan you go into why this wasn't "the best" or "safest" way or the alternatives?
- 8_hours_ago 12y agoOffering stock instead of money for goods and services to your friends is risky. If the stock becomes worthless (which is very common for startups), your friends may not be your friends anymore. Of course, that doesn't mean much for an investment as small as a $100 drafting table, but losing your life savings is devastating.
- ryanburk 12y agothanks. totally get the life savings risk - the risk to the investor. I read it as risk to the company, so didn't know how this would be any riskier than standard round raises.
- mproud 12y ago• He hired an alcoholic for a lawyer • He didn’t know about Founders’ Stock • He only ended up with 4% of the company after his divorce • The board of directors took pity and helped him out financially, but they didn’t have to Rereading this, I realize that this story might sound like sour grapes, and perhaps some of you are thinking, “What an idiot!” But, no, I’m not bitter in the least. That’s life; these things happen, and it was a valuable learning experience. I share it because, well, it’s a part of the history here. And yeah, I’m an idiot. If you keep reading this blog, you’ll see that proven again and again! But we’re all idiots. We do dumb things: we trust people we shouldn’t, we make decisions based on emotion without regard for logic, or sometimes logic without regard for emotion. It’s the human experience, and the story of Wizards of the Coast is a very human story.
- random_pr 12y agoThis is a good related article on the early days of WotC: http://www.salon.com/2001/03/23/wizards/ http://www.salon.com/2001/03/23/wizards/
- diziet 12y agoThis sounds like a terrible idea and not 'inspiring' at all.
- alexose 12y agoThe next generation of startups is going to have to address some employee equity problems, I think. This notion that early hires are going to share a small piece of the 10% employee pool needs to stop. Being employee #1 of a startup can be one of the worst positions a young developer can ask for. Long hours, high stress, low job security, and for what? 0.5% of a company that, if it survives, will most likely dilute its shares? A startup could really set itself apart by advertising more progressive structure-- One where shares in the company aren't treated like a lottery ticket, but an actual piece of value that is worth growing. Too bad VCs don't see it that way.
- tptacek 12y agoProbably not, or that already would have happened. It hasn't. One problem is that a lot of people look at equity grants as a meritorious service award. But that's not at all what they are; they're compensation for risk. Developers look at risk compensation and say, "well, I undertook a lot of risk to work long hours for a lower wage". That's true, but the market prices that kind of risk, and the market cares a lot about substitutes, and the typical developer taking basis points for their participation is eminently replaceable by other developers. On the other hand, the market has no replacement for an entity legally authorized to trade $1MM for X% of the company, so that risk is priced highly. Similarly, the market has fewer substitutes for the people who actually start the company; or rather, those substitutes tend to react to the mispricing by simply starting their own companies, and thus aren't competing with the founders for equity. Pithier: * there's a lot of ground to be made up in how founders/operators promote startup jobs to developers! * there's probably some marginal ground to be made up for developer equity compensation * it probably won't dramatically alter the way startup cap tables look * developers who genuinely (in a market sense) are poorly served by how startups allocate equity should start their own companies * developers who can't start companies probably aren't being as screwed as we think they are by small grants --- or, if they are, they're being screwed by being persuaded to work at startups when they should instead work for larger companies that can pay them better wages.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- gcb0 12y agoi love to put this annecdote on top of facebook's if the same people were handling WoC, they would have called in the janitor, made her sell her stock for peanuts before the new stock price set in. garanteeing that only the suits made any big return of it.
- MattHeard 12y ago> I was successful as a CEO not because of my own brilliance, but because I built a team of people far smarter than me who were willing to buffer my shortcomings. This attitude defines a good CEO.