20 ms·
The key results from the paper: After adjustment for sociodemographic and health-related characteristics, sugar-sweetened soda consumption was ass
by mikeyouse 12y ago
The key results from the paper:
After adjustment for sociodemographic and health-related
characteristics, sugar-sweetened soda consumption was
associated with shorter telomeres (b = –0.010; 95%
confidence interval [CI] = −0.020, −0.001; P = .04).
Consumption of 100% fruit juice was marginally associated
with longer telomeres (b = 0.016; 95% CI = −0.000, 0.033;
P = .05). No significant associations were observed between
consumption of diet sodas or noncarbonated SSBs and
telomere length.
Shortened telomeres are one way to measure genetic 'age'. So they saw 'aging' with sugar-sweetened soda, the opposite with fruit juice, and no significant difference with diet sodas or non-carbonated sugary sodas.
The study was pretty substantial with ~5,300 participants with no history of cardiovascular disease or diabetes. It's nice to have another datapoint against some of the bro-sciencey "Fruit juice has as much sugar as soda" arguments.
Late Edit:
Here's a pretty good summary of telomere aging:
http://learn.genetics.utah.edu/content/chromosomes/telomeres/ http://learn.genetics.utah.edu/content/chromosomes/telomeres...
- danielki 12y agoDid they describe how they controlled for behavioral habits? It seems like, as a group, the type of people who would drink large amounts of sugary soda would be less likely to make healthy behavioral choices in other aspects of their life, compared to people who drink fruit juice or diet soda. This could also explain the disparity between soda and non-carbonated sugar-sweetened beverages This study doesn't seem to show that soda ages you (as the article states), but instead that sugary soda consumption indicates a tendency towards other activities/habits that may prematurely age you.
- mikeyouse 12y ago> This study doesn't seem to show that soda ages you (as the article states), but instead that sugary soda consumption indicates a tendency towards other activities/habits that may prematurely age you. No offense, but the authors are very accomplished public health researchers. If their study showed what you suggest, I think that would be their headline. What they showed with (relative) certainty is that those who drink sugary carbonated drinks have shorter telomeres than those who don't. There will be follow-up work to determine the mechanism and the causes. In either case; > Epel is co-leading a new study in which participants will be tracked for weeks in real time to look for effects of sugar-sweetened soda consumption on aspects of cellular aging. Telomere shortening has previously been associated with oxidative damage to tissue, to inflammation, and to insulin resistance.
- aaron-lebo 12y agoI don't see any reason to discount the authors, but a couple of things to keep in mind: 1) This is Time's popularization of their study, so Time is naturally going to put forward the most interesting and least nuanced claims of theirs. 2) They may be accomplished researchers, but if you are well-versed in an academic discipline and read material in it, it quickly becomes clear that sometimes points which seem obvious have not actually been accounted for whether by mistake or because they don't allow for interesting publishable material. Again, I'm not saying that is the case, and my points above are overly cynical, but the original poster's question is valid.
- anigbrowl 12y agoThe Time article is actually a very dry summary of the study's key finding, written in colloquial but not sensational language. It also has a link to the study in the very first sentence. I found the full text very easily: http://www.chc.ucsf.edu/ame_lab/pdfs/Leung%20et%20al%202014a.pdf http://www.chc.ucsf.edu/ame_lab/pdfs/Leung%20et%20al%202014a... The poster above could easily have satisfied his/her own curiosity on this point. 'Did researchers control for [extremely obvious thing]?' is becoming like 'correlation is not causation' - a smart-sounding thing to say instead of going to the effort of engaging with the material. It only took me 2 minutes to track down the paper and find that the covariate factors are discussed in detail over a full page of the paper.
- qu4z-2 12y agoIn fact, in this case it's more or less exactly like 'correlation is not causation'.
- Arnor 12y ago1. Some of us aren't subscribers to APHA or aren't interested in spending $22 on the article. 2. Why so confrontational? If you know the answer to the question, why not summarize it? Is the answer to the question so complicated that it would take more time and energy than the two paragraphs you composed in derision?
- harpastum 12y agoI just looked through the study. They controlled for Smoking, Alcohol, Energy Intake, Alcohol Intake, Healthy Eating (via "Healthy Eating Index"), Body Mass Index, and Waist Circumference. Relevant Section: Health-related variables included smoking status (never, former, current), pack-years of smoking (0, < 30, 30---60, and > 60), physical activity assessed from questionnaire (some activity, no activity), total energy intake, alcohol intake, and Healthy Eating Index 2005 (HEI 2005) score, which is a dietary pattern de- veloped by the USDA to measure compliance with national dietary guidelines. The HEI 2005 is scored out of 100 points and comprises 12 components: total fruit, whole fruit, total vegetables, dark green and orange vegetables and legumes, total grains, whole grains, milk, meat and beans, oils, saturated fat, sodium, and calories from solid fats, alcoholic beverages, and added sugars. We collapsed HEI 2005 scores into gender-specific quartiles: for men, the cutpoints were 42.1, 45.9, and 50.5; for women, the cutpoints were 44.4, 48.6, and 53.5. We defined alcohol intake as low (0---0.5 drinks/day for men and women), moderate (0.5---2.0 drinks/day for men; 0.5--- 1.5 drinks/day for women), and heavy ( > 2 drinks/day for men, > 1.5 drinks/day for women). Adiposity measures included body mass index (BMI) and waist circumference. We calculated BMI from self-reported height (in meters) and weight (in kilograms squared), measured by trained personnel using a stadiometer and Toledo weight scale (Toledo Scale, Honolulu, HI). We defined BMI categories as underweight (BMI < 18.5 kg/m2), normal weight (BMI = 18.5---24.9 kg/m2), overweight (BMI = 25.0---29.9 kg/m2), and obese (BMI ‡ 30 kg/m2). Waist circumference (centimeters) was measured at the upper lateral border of the right ilium. We defined elevated waist circumference as 102 centimeters or greater for men and 88 centimeters or greater for women.
- manicdee 12y agoEdited from the report: Potential confounders included sociodemographics (participant’s age, gender, self-reported race/ethnicity (white, black, Hispanic, other), highest educational attainment, ratio of family income to poverty, and marital status. Health-related variables included smoking status, pack-years of smoking, physical activity assessed from questionnaire (some activity, no activity), total energy intake, alcohol intake, and Healthy Eating Index 2005.
- wiredfool 12y agoI wonder what would happen with half fruit juice, half carbonated water.
- nkozyra 12y agoGiven that the effects were not seen in diet soda, it's fair to discount the possibility that carbonation plays a role. Since fruit juice has a mild lengthening effect, it might be minimally positive.
- kalleboo 12y agoThe effect were also not seen in sweetened non-carbonated beverages, so it must be some interaction between the sweetening and the carbonation.
- nkozyra 12y agoI would be careful with words like "must" when there are this many variables involved. It could be fiber, the types of sugar, etc. We do know that carbonation alone isn't causing this and fruit juice doesn't cause this.
- spikels 12y agoYou are proposing an experiment that would be almost impossible to run. Little if any nutrition research is actually run like a traditional science experiment (i.e. do something specific and observe results). Unfortunately outside of the prison camps on North Korea it is impossible to control the diet (or behaviors) of enough people for long enough to get useful results. Instead we observe people uncontrolled behavior (almost never directly but through questionnaires) then observe health outcomes (usually not directly) or in this case something (telomere length) believed to be associated with health outcomes. Attempts are then made to adjust for all these potential problems using additional data (usually questionnaires) - usually difficult to say how effective. These neccesary compromises introduces a whole host of potential problems that have contributed to all the confusion over what is good/bad nutrition. I've given up on having much confidence in medical research until it is repeatedly confirmed in additional studies - which may never happen.
- toomuchtodo 12y ago> So they saw 'aging' with sugar-sweetened soda, the opposite with fruit juice, and no significant difference with diet sodas or non-carbonated sugary sodas. What compounds in soda are most likely causing this? If they're not seeing the results in fruit juice, its not sugar causing the damage.
- izzo 12y agopossibly sodium benzoate: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21130826 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21130826
- legomylibrum 12y agoThat's also in diet and non-carbonated sugary sodas; it's used as a preservative in just about everything.
- mikeash 12y agoCould it be that sugar is responsible, but other stuff in fruit juice somehow inhibits it or compensates for it?
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoI was thinking in the opposite direction, that maybe sugar is responsible but the effect is triggered/compounded by the bubbles [or C02 or carbonic acid] in some way? There's a joke in here about muddy waters [a cocktail made variously with coke and OJ] somewhere ...
- iribe 12y agoI bet Deepak Chopra knows, and it has something to do with quantum energy.
- awakeasleep 12y agoNutrition doesn't work like that- there are too many variables. It could be something that fruit juice has and soda doesn't, it could be a confluence of factors that require lateral thinking.
- tbrownaw 12y agoTheir confidence intervals include 0 or nearly-0, their P-values are at or near the .05 cutoff, and they tested a bunch of different things and got results on a few that don't really make sense. In related news, green jelly beans cause acne: https://xkcd.com/882/ https://xkcd.com/882/
- mikeyouse 12y ago> Their confidence intervals include 0 or nearly-0, their P-values are at or near the .05 cutoff They ran two different models and found across all cohorts (correcting for age, race, BMI, marital status, smoking, history, physical activity levels, and education) that those who regularly consumed sugar-sweetened soda had statistically shorter telomeres -- and that this affect is correlated with the amount of consumption. > Because of the model-based estimate in this sample of the age-associated rate of telomere shortening of 13.6 base pairs per year, this was equivalent to 1.9 additional years of aging for an 8-ounce serving of sugar-sweetened sodas. For a daily consumption of the current standard 20-ounce serving size for sugar-sweetened sodas, this corresponds to 4.6 additional years of aging. This is good science, and treating it as less than that to set up a joke is pointless.
- Scientist007 12y agoThe "joke" points out an important flaw.
- mikeyouse 12y agoIt really doesn't though. Something tells me green-account "Scientist007", that you might not actually be a scientist.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoNo, you have got it all wrong. They must surely be a secret-agent-scientist. That's why nobody understand them. They are using secret-science learned at spy-school that nobody else knows about.
- DanBC 12y ago> It's nice to have another datapoint against some of the bro-sciencey "Fruit juice has as much sugar as soda" arguments. Go careful, that's not all broscience. Children especially should not have undiluted fruit juices.
- a8da6b0c91d 12y agoChildren have massive metabolic demands for sugars to support growth. Children should have as much undiluted fruit juice as they want.
- DanBC 12y agoYou are wrong and you should declare your weird shilling for the sugar industry. http://www.child-smile.org.uk/parents-and-carers/birth-to-3-years-old/drinks-for-healthy-baby-teeth.aspx http://www.child-smile.org.uk/parents-and-carers/birth-to-3-... > Small amounts of pure, unsweetened fruit juice should be diluted half and half (50% juice to 50% water), or with a greater proportion of water to juice if your child is thirsty. > Juice should be restricted to mealtimes only in a free-flow cup, not a feeding bottle.
- anigbrowl 12y agoCastigating someone for shilling for the sugar industry in the context of unsweetened fruit juice makes no sense. The guidelines you cite are obviously infants and toddlers. I suspect the poster above is thinking of more active older children. Accusing him/her of being a paid PR person is unjustified and unnecessary.
- DanBC 12y agoDo a search - the poster frequently recommends adding refined sugar to the diet; and responds to requests for cites with abuse. In this thread they've called citing your claims as "a game for retards". The poster holds a view which is so weird it may as well be shilling. (And I say this as someone who has said that Lustig advocates go too far).
- therobot24 12y ago> It's nice to have another datapoint against some of the bro-sciencey "Fruit juice has as much sugar as soda" arguments. I was under the impression that this expression was used more with regard to dental health
- pc2g4d 12y agoFruit juice may be good for your telomeres, but there are plenty of other reasons to be suspicious of it---"bro-science" it is not. For example, Google "fruit juice and obesity" or see http://blogs.plos.org/obesitypanacea/2012/03/09/shout-it-from-the-rooftops-juice-is-not-natural/ http://blogs.plos.org/obesitypanacea/2012/03/09/shout-it-fro... And besides, who says a "bro" can't science? ;)
- mikeyouse 12y ago> And besides, who says a "bro" can't science? ;) Very fair point. I guess I've been exposed to too many paleo "all sugar is equally evil" bros lately. They can certainly science with the rest of them. Hell, Kary Mullis won a Nobel for inventing PCR which he practically did from his surf board. Although his later absurdity^ re: AIDS / Astrology / Climate Change might give some more credence to keeping the bros out of science ;-) ^Absurdity not absurdism
- theoh 12y agoAbsurdism is something quite different...
- mikeyouse 12y agoYeah, wow, thanks for the correction.. Can you tell that the Myth of Sisyphus is on my bedside table right now?
- Freestyler_3 12y agoAnd how about sugar in honey? I just wonder.
- colechristensen 12y agoBoth honey and high fructose corn syrup are > 85% water, fructose, and glucose in ratios similar enough to not make a difference. Unless something in the remaining few percent is protective for honey and or harmful for HFCS, it's doubtful that there's a difference health-wise.
- weinzierl 12y agoNo significant associations were observed between consumption of diet sodas or noncarbonated SSBs and telomere length. I don't understand how the carbonation can have an effect. It's just CO2 and a little bit of H2CO3, neither of which is metabolized.
- mikeyouse 12y agoThe results probably vary due to the different classes of beverages, it's not like they make a Coke Zero-Carbonation. I'm actually having a hard time coming up with non-carbonated sugar-sweetened beverages as I don't drink any, but I'm picturing stuff like Honest Tea or those Starbucks Frappuccino things.
- Symbiote 12y ago> non-carbonated sugar-sweetened beverages Bottled "tea" seems the right kind of thing. Common in the UK are sweetened fruit juice drinks. Obvious examples are Sunny D and J2O, but there are also plenty of drinks sold in very similar packaging to pure fruit juices, which are actually diluted and sweetened (with sugar). They have to say "juice drink" on the label.
- thaumasiotes 12y agoThe Arizona, Gatorade, and Snapple brands would be appalled. SoBe, too. (I'm not a huge fan of carbonation, except, oddly, for pineapple-flavored drinks. But mostly I just don't get why you'd want to take a perfectly good drink and add pain to it.)
- akgerber 12y ago"Juice Drink" e.g. http://www.welchs.com/products/chillers-juice-drinks http://www.welchs.com/products/chillers-juice-drinks, sweetened teas, and lemonade are pretty common. Hawaiian Punch is available in many soda machines.
- frozenport 12y agoLooks like its the carbonation?
- clouden 12y agoA p-value of 0.04 is not very strong evidence of an effect, though it is significant at the 0.05 level. This study says at most that the effect should continue to be studied.
- jongraehl 12y agoPoor people do prison time and hard drugs more often (both of which might shorten a telomere). I also expect that physically measurable psychological stress is worse for poor (than for type-A work-stress junkies - probably that's more eustress due to control).
- new_test 12y agoAlso, could someone comment on the effect size of b = -.001, which is within the 95% CI. Because if that translates into a day in a hundred years in "longevity" terms or something like that, than I wouldn't call the result "significant", even though the 0 is not technically crossed.
- Shivetya 12y agohow do carbonated sugary drinks become less safe than non carbonated sugary drinks if carbonated non sugary drinks are safe? It seems there is a missing item somewhere.
- tripzilch 12y agoAlso, you can mix fruit juice 50/50 with water and it'll taste great (depending on thirst, possibly even better). This works with apple juice and OJ[0], but really not with soda (I tried). Of course it helps that I live somewhere where the tap water tastes indistinguishable from bottled water. Years ago, I was in Austria a lot, where it was a perfectly normal thing to order "Apfelsaft mit Leitungswasser" (apple juice with tap water). Which you'd get for the regular price of an apple juice, in a twice as big glass, that they'd top off with tap water. [0] also, grapefruit.
- tripzilch 12y agoAlso, you can mix fruit juice 50/50 with water and it'll taste great (depending on thirst, possibly even better). This works with apple juice and OJ[0], but really not with soda (I tried). Of course it helps that I live somewhere where the tap water tastes indistinguishable from bottled water. Years ago, I was in Austria a lot, where it was a perfectly normal thing to order "Apfelsaft mit Leitungswasser" (apple juice with tap water). Which you'd get for the regular price of an apple juice, in a twice as big glass, that they'd top off with tap water. [0] also, grapefruit.