9 ms·
Congrats founders, YC, and other shareholders! But still, I just started using Firebase, and this news makes it clear to me that I should move off them as soon
by skrebbel 12y ago
Congrats founders, YC, and other shareholders!
But still, I just started using Firebase, and this news makes it clear to me that I should move off them as soon as I can. Firebase was an interesting technology supplier: When they were a small company, I could count on it that as a customer, I would count. Google is known to not give a damn about paying customers (ref: all the Google Apps customers who lose their email (for whatever reason) and get redirected to a FAQ page with answers to unrelated questions). Google is also known to Be Evil: I'm not sure I dare waiting until the terms change such that my user's data is subject to googlebot scanning.
Firebase's business model is aligned with my interests: the more users I have, the more I (hopefully) earn, so the more I pay Firebase. I strongly doubt, however, that Google is buying Firebase because they think they can get very rich selling Firebase subscriptions. It's either going to turn out a acquihire, or it is some part of a grand ecosystem plan. Acquihire means they'll pull the plug sooner or later, grand ecosystem plan means vendor lock-in. While I'm happy to be locked in to the services of a small independent business, I'd think twice before becoming entirely dependent on a company that could lose me as a customer and not even notice the slightest impact on their bottom line.
I know all of the Firebase guys are reading this, and I don't mean to piss on your parade. I'm certain you're not lying when you say that things are only going to get better. But I'm also certain that your jobs don't depend on that anymore, and when higher-ups decide to move the big boat's direction, Firebase might be over sooner than any of us wants it to.
That's a pretty big risk to take as a startup that fully depends on Firebase for their data storage.
- johns 12y agoStartup dilemma pre-acquisition: "they're just a startup! how will I know they'll be around in 12 months?! so risky!" Startup dilemma post-acquisition: "they're no longer in control! how can I trust they'll be around in 12 months!? so risky!"
- skrebbel 12y agoGood point. As a startup owner myself, I somehow feel more comfortable depending on startups than on BigCo's (hence the rant), but maybe you're right that that's more emotional than rational.
- jgable 12y agoSolution: "They're a stable, growing business that is profitable and intends to be in business for themselves for a long time! Not as risky!" Not under the control of the customer, obviously.
- georgemcbay 12y agoBeing acquired by Google almost solves the dilemma in that statistically you can be nearly certain that whatever product or service a newly acquired company provides will be a dead project within 2 years. I know that the acquirees are saying otherwise in this case (and Google is surely saying the same to them), and they might be right this time, but "nothing will change" is virtually always the line, until it suddenly isn't. FWIW, I'm not even knocking Google (or Firebase) for this state of affairs; just noting that anyone paying attention will have seen this play out dozens of times in a way that is unpleasant in the medium to long term for anyone relying on the acquired company's technology.
- ggreer 12y agoThe solution I've come up with is a pledge to release the source code if the product dies.[1] We've done this at Floobits, and it makes our users' lives less stressful.[2] 1. http://geoff.greer.fm/2012/09/19/a-responsible-product-sunset-pledge/ http://geoff.greer.fm/2012/09/19/a-responsible-product-sunse... 2. https://floobits.com/pledge https://floobits.com/pledge
- baddox 12y agoWhat good is a pledge? Once the product dies, there's presumably little incentive to abide by it.
- ggreer 12y agoLittle incentive? Even assuming sociopathic tendencies, it doesn't make sense to renege on the pledge and be branded a money-grubbing liar. The internet has a long memory, and people would not trust you in the future.
- baddox 12y ago> Even assuming sociopathic tendencies, it doesn't make sense to renege on the pledge and be branded a money-grubbing liar. But that's just the same incentive for a company to continue providing the same level of service after being acquired.
- sliverstorm 12y agoHow about the pain-in-the-butt that is organizing, packaging, and releasing an organic network & development environment when you have other bigger things on your plate? I'm sure there are a few companies here and there with everything already nicely packaged. Yet, most places I've worked, it would be a herculean effort to pull the tangled jungle that is the internal network & development environment into one halfway-functional package. It's less than ideal, but it is usually extremely low on the list of priorities as well as virtually untestable, unless the business model involves a large number of functionally identical VLAN's. Also, names of people are usually not very strongly attached to products.
- polarix 12y agohttps://sandstorm.io/ https://sandstorm.io/
- christiansmith 12y agoI'd like to take that devil by the horns and strongly suggest that companies like Firebase, who clearly deliver a critical infrastructure dependency for anyone using their service, should open source their platform as an act of good faith toward their customers. No one wants to run yet another cluster, but anyone with an eye to business continuity ought to want the assurance that they can migrate to and from their own servers if that need should arise. That might not be in the short term interests of Firebase, but it's definitely in the long term interests of their customers. Why would anyone ever base the future of their own business on the exit needs of another company's investors? It is a ridiculous risk. As much as I love what Firebase has built, I'd never use it for anything more than a toy project for that exact reason. Basho, ElasticSearch and Docker(?) seem to be on a good path with commercial open source models. Is there any reason that a startup like Firebase couldn't do both? Offer their open source product as a service with non-critical value adds? GitHub is another example that comes to mind. If they were to get bought and shut down, it would be a pain in the ass to set up new remotes, but no one would have to stop using git.
- Nevraeka 12y ago+1 to open source the platform
- dude3 12y agoNode.js + Socket.io + Bootstrap + AngularJS + Angular Socket.io + 1000 lines of code
- matthewmacleod 12y agoBut that's a thousand lines of code I don't have to write. And integrations I don't have to do. And libraries for lots of platforms. I think you're undersstimating the added value – the point is that people don't have to bother setting up and maintaining all of those moving parts with a service like firebase. Case in point, I was building a small real-time web serice this weekend; it's exactly the sort of thing that Firebase would be great for. But given that I couldn't run it locally, and that there's no migration path if they were to acquired and shut down, I had to implement a half-assed solution on my own. If Firebase had been open-source, I'd almost certainly have ended up forking over cash for them to host it anyway.
- Lewisham 12y agoI'm an engineer on Cloud SQL. Support is much, much different from the wider Google reputation in Cloud[1]. We have a long leash to talk directly to people, and we do: Cloud SQL team, at least, monitors the google-cloud-sql tag on Stack Overflow and replies with help when possible. If you pay, you get telephone access to support reps who have a bunch of experience, and when they can't get something done themselves (rare), they can and do file bug tickets with the engineering team directly to get issues resolved. We are developers and you are developers, and we're all trying to work towards making cool things :) I don't see that changing any time soon, everyone from in Cloud from Urs down gets it. We have to earn your trust, and we do that be providing the best product we can, interacting in communities directly, providing great support, and not creating vendor lock-in. I wouldn't work on this team if we didn't do those things, because I believe in them as being necessary parts much as you do. [1] I can't speak to the rest of the company because I don't have experience with it, but I had very good support experience with Play too, so it's my hope that support in general at Google has turned a significant corner in recent years.
- ky3 12y agoWe have to earn your trust Who's "we"? You, an honest guy, I'm willing to trust. But not Larry nor whoever the next CEO will be. Where the buck drops is where mine won't cuz the other guy is your boss.
- mattzito 12y agoIsn't the same true of firebase as a company as well? Even pre-acquisition, all you need is for them to bring in an outside CEO who wants to monetize their userbase to screw things up.
- joelthelion 12y agoThat's pretty much true of any online service as opposed to software you control.
- general_failure 12y ago
- DanBC 12y ago> Google is known to not give a damn about paying customers (ref: all the Google Apps customers who lose their email (for whatever reason) and get redirected to a FAQ page with answers to unrelated questions). Just in case any Googlers are reading: you have a contact form for adsense questions that rejects my email address because my real name has "Cocks" as a part of it.
- rybosome 12y agoIs it this[1] form? If so, I'll find the owner and file a bug. [1]: https://support.google.com/adsense/contact/contactsales?hl=en https://support.google.com/adsense/contact/contactsales?hl=e...
- imron 12y agoJust imagine what businesses based in Scunthorpe have to go through ;-)
- danellis 12y agoIt's okay, there's nothing important based in Scunthorpe anyway.
- notatoad 12y ago>That's a pretty big risk to take as a startup that fully depends on Firebase for their data storage. Fully depending on any third party for any important part of your business is a risky strategy. If you're contracting out something as core as data storage, you'd better have a good plan B regardless of the provider's economic situation.
- yuhong 12y agoGoogle is also known to Be Evil: I'm not sure I dare waiting until the terms change such that my user's data is subject to googlebot scanning. I don't believe that claim, especially nowadays.
- eitally 12y agoJust an fyi in case you weren't trying to snipe on purpose, but there haven't been any data loss "issues" (e.g. stupid decisions by Google) with Apps for several years now. That said, if I were using Firebase I'd be concerned, too. Google is well known as a place startups go to die, or morph into something The Borg wants rather than something aligned with the startup's original vision and the expectations of their paying customers. Good luck and godspeed!
- jhallenworld 12y agoWould you purchase a company which was dependent on this Google service? Hmm, well Google might.
- magicalist 12y ago> That's a pretty big risk to take as a startup that fully depends on Firebase for their data storage. Er, versus fully depending on a startup that could run out of money or be acquired at any time?
- bradgessler 12y agoWe've had a lot of vendors, like Firebase, approach us at Poll Everywhere over the years. Despite how awesome they are as people, a company, and the huge problems they solve, I've always avoided it getting in bed with any vendor for something that I think is fundamental to a realtime web application. As a result, we developed our own realtime web framework at http://firehose.io http://firehose.io, open sourced it under the MIT license, and made ourselves immune to these circumstances.
- JacobHarrington 12y agoThat's an excellent observation. I often feel that in the rush to acquisition the future of the product line can get lost. For example, one of the previous non-profits I worked with used myfamily.com for communications. Myfamily.com was bought out by Ancestry.com not too long ago, and progress on the MyFamily site - a completely separate but corollary product line - stagnated until they simply ended the product's run with just a few week's warning. After a while, when the acquired company's goals no longer apply for the new parent - or when they simply become too much of a hassle - they are simply left to twist in the wind.