5 ms·
The Chromecast continues to be perhaps the best value in tech
- AndrewDucker 12y agoIt's a great shame that it doesn't use an open API. Having a standard way of telling devices to play media would be very useful. As it is I backed the Matchstick on Kickstarter because I wanted a more open device.
- thibauts 12y agoThese links might be of some help : https://github.com/thibauts/node-castv2#protocol-description https://github.com/thibauts/node-castv2#protocol-description https://github.com/thibauts/node-castv2-client https://github.com/thibauts/node-castv2-client
- eclipxe 12y agoYeah, except for the fact that Chromecast sender apps perform a cert check now, so open implementations don't work. https://github.com/thibauts/node-castv2/issues/2 https://github.com/thibauts/node-castv2/issues/2
- thibauts 12y agoOpen server implementations don't, open clients do. I wrote this issue.
- zanny 12y agodevices to play media would be very useful. rtsp://foobar.net/pictures/pic.jpg rtsp://192.168.1.15/Public/video.mp4 And I know at least mpris2 exists as a standard media controller API. I don't think it has file picking though.
- dataminded 12y agoIf anyone from Google is listening, please release a version with an ethernet cable. Wi-fi is not reliable everywhere.
- gergles 12y agoSure, assuming it even works. It has gigantic swaths of incompatibility with many televisions and they don't seem to care about it. It works for a while then fails to display anything, no matter how much you reset it or anything -- until you move it to a new TV, then back to the original one, upon which time you'll get a few more hours/days of use. The 'support' sends you through the same canned troubleshooters then tries to authorize RMAs, which don't work either - it's some sort of software bug or (more likely) some sort of DRM lockdown bullshit incompatibility.
- jzwinck 12y agoFear of this sort of "DRM lockdown bullshit incompatibility" is what stops me from buying devices like Chromecast. I have a high-end receiver and a high-quality mini-DisplayPort-to-HDMI adapter. If I plug these together, iTunes hangs (sometimes requiring a reboot of the entire Macbook!) when I start playing a movie I paid for, seemingly because of the DRM lockdown bullshit. I then have to connect the HDMI cable to the TV directly, which prevents true surround sound from working (because most TVs cannot output AC3, only stereo). All this happens despite all my equipment being about the same age (2-3 years). It all says "HDMI" on it, it all supports DRM to some extent, and yet it doesn't work together.
- chez17 12y agoIt plugs into the HDMI slot, how are you having compatibility issues? If your tv takes an HDMI cable, that's all you need.
- georgemcbay 12y agoHDMI isn't like composite video -- it is more than just a physical connection, it is a highly complex set of protocols with DRM and version numbers and everything. I haven't run into Chromecast issues with my TV, but I have seen dozens of cases where two devices that ostensibly both supported "HDMI" refused to work together while the individual devices would work fine with (most) other devices. So I find it perfectly plausible that the OP's situation is very real even if I haven't experienced that particular one myself.
- Mithaldu 12y agoI live in the middle of a big city. From my apartment there are at least 50 different wifi routers visible. The Chromecast simply cannot maintain a stable connection under these circumstances. My parents do not have internet. These are two situations where this device is, entirely needlessly so, completely without value. That said, when it works it is a charm.
- jordanthoms 12y agoYeah, hopefully a 5ghz version will be released soon. 2.4ghz is awful in dense areas.
- bane 12y agoGoogle desperately needs to release a wired version as well as upgrade the existing wi-fi versions to let you stream direct to the dongle instead of using the internet as an intermediary.
- soylentcola 12y agoI agree with the need for a wired option. It's one of the things I had hoped for in the Nexus Player and might have been enough to get me to buy one (even though I haven't run into any issues with WiFi with my Chromecast, it would be preferred). As far as the second part, I'm admittedly not a Chromecast "expert" by any means (only had it for a month now and only use it occasionally) but it seemed to me that I had both options depending on what I'm "casting". When I'm using on online media source like Netflix or Youtube, I prefer using my phone or laptop as more of a remote control so it's not constantly draining the battery in order to actively stream as a wireless extender. Still, I can cast my screen directly if I want to do that. I haven't done that too much since it seems less useful in my personal usage cases but the option is there. The only thing I'd love to see is something more along the lines of Miracast where you have the option of sending content over an ad-hoc connection between your device and the Chromecast. I considered something like a Chromecast for conference rooms at work but since you need to be on the same WiFi network, that's not really an option since the accessible WiFi network at the office has restrictions and limitations that would make Chromecast unusable. It would be nice if I could purchase several of these inexpensive devices that could easily enable streaming from online media providers but could also receive content directly from devices within range (like the laptops and tablets of people in a meeting) without needing to install separate access points just for Chromecast.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- MartinCron 12y agoEthics aside, copyright infringement is always your best entertainment value.
- smacktoward 12y agoEthics aside, shoplifting is always your best shopping value.
- mappu 12y agoShoplifting is risky, which is a type of non-zero cost. But a sleepwalking child could probably safely torrent a movie.
- spikels 12y agoCopying is fundamentally less unethical than stealing. When you steal something you deprive its owner of actual property. When you copy something you deprive the copywriter owner of a potential sale. So not only is there no actual loss of anything often there would never have been a sale anyway. More like blocking the line at the cash register than taking the merchandise.
- brownbat 12y agoYeah, as noted by the Supreme Court in Dowling v. United States (1985), "...interference with copyright does not easily equate with theft..." For some reason people think this is a controversial copyleftist idea, rather than something the highest court has already acknowledged.
- MartinCron 12y agoDon't fall into the trap of thinking that "less unethical" means that it is actually ethical. Plenty of things that one shouldn't do have analogs that are much worse.
- finalight 12y ago" I decided I wanted a cloud-powered digital photo frame in my house, to retroactively justify my tendency to over-photograph every event, and because I had a ton of digital photos but no way to display them in my house. " wow, just wow....
- Jedd 12y agoWhat was your wow bit? The fact that cloud is a term no one understands (okay, no two people can agree on), that it can't actually power anything, or that up until Chromecast there was no way to display your photos in your house?
- ekianjo 12y agoFor about the same price, I feel the Raspberry Pi provides much better value in tech. It's way more versatile.
- davidholmesnyc 12y agoI like the Chromecast.I brought 3 when they had a sale at staples for $30/each a few months back. It really is the best value for a TV device that supports Netflix and Youtube that you can control with your phone. I also have been having fun hacking on it the past few months using node.js. I just wish more apps supported it.
- superflit 12y agoI really wish I be able to set the DNS servers on ChromeCast.... wink
- plicense 12y agoI just wish I had an LCD TV at my home..
- Jedd 12y agoI looked at the Chromecast, but as others have mentioned, the frequent reports of fragility, along with the DRM-laden aspects deterred me. I've bought the Netgear Push2TV (PTV3000) but haven't received it yet. And then Samsung have their own variant, which I believe is WiDi standards-compliant. Is the compelling thing with the Chromecast just the price, then?
- bane 12y agoIt's a bit fragile. I'll lose connections every once in a while or whatever -- usually just reconnecting to the current thing the chromecast is doing will solve it. But for ~$35 and the unbelievable ecosystem of support it has, it's really hard to beat. I use mine frequently (basically daily) with youtube, plex and podcast addict and pretty often to mirror tabs from chrome and mirror my android device. Most of the time the issues are with my home wifi setup and not with the device. But it's not so complicated a platform that there's lots of fiddling to do. I've tried various other systems to get my media to my tv and bar none, chromecast is the best one.
- Pxtl 12y agoI'm actually surprised google launched the new nexus player device instead of doubling down on chromecast. I'd think a boxed-set of a chromecast and a minimalist cheap $60 4" wifi-only device would have fit more with the existing android ecosystem, and would give the users similar functionality to the nexus player.