6 ms·
The U.S. has done the prohibition experiment twice now, and it was an unmitigated disaster both times. The data are unambiguous: prohibition doesn't work, neve
by lisper 12y ago
The U.S. has done the prohibition experiment twice now, and it was an unmitigated disaster both times. The data are unambiguous: prohibition doesn't work, never has, never will. And yet we're still arguing about it.
Funny thing, though, we've done a similar experiment with tax cuts for the wealthy three times now: once in the 1920's, once starting in the 1980s, and most recently in Kansas. The results have been similarly disastrous all three times. And yet we're still arguing about that too.
- canjobear 12y agoIt is not unambiguous that Prohibition didn't work. http://www.nber.org/papers/w3675.pdf http://www.nber.org/papers/w3675.pdf Whether or not it was worth the cost is a separate issue; I think it's pretty clear that it wasn't. But the argument can be made that it did "work" in reducing alcohol consumption.
- lisper 12y agoI didn't say that it didn't work, I said it was an unmitigated disaster. A program can achieve its ostensible goals and still be disastrous. Jim Crow "worked" too.
- jMyles 12y agoOf course alcohol prohibition didn't even achieve its ostensible goal of eliminating alcohol from the American diet. Whether it reduced consumption at all (by volume of alcohol) is in dispute. There's no dispute that it lead to consumption of stronger beverages, in the same way that poppy prohibition has eliminated the use of poppy tea (an utterly benign preparation) in favor of heroin and even stronger drugs. As for Jim Crow 'working,' it's notable that drug prohibition has 'worked' as a Jim Crow as well.
- ddingus 12y agoActually, given all the attention on the well known, controlled substances, making a little Poppy Tea flies well under the radar, and sometimes happens with Grannie's decorative flowers. That aside, the parallels regarding stronger formulations and compounds is spot on.
- orionhenry 12y agoSorry. The link isn't working for me. Does the study properly account for percent alcohol by volume? Studies I have read showed people just switching beer for whiskey. The consumption difference was negligible once normalized.
- tjradcliffe 12y agoIf I showed data that shooting a person in the head was an effective means of removing brain tumours, it would be very unlikely that anyone anywhere under any circumstances would ever agree with the proposition, "shooting a person in the head words in removing brain tumours". It's just not the way "worked" is used, and falling back on the most literal, narrow meaning of the term actually signals conceding the argument.
- cracell 12y agoThe relevant point of your link is "We find that alcohol consumption fell sharply at the beginning of Prohibition, to approximately 30 percent of its pre-Prohibition level. During the next several years, however, alcohol consumption increased sharply to about 60-70 percent of its pre-Prohibition level." If I was trying to prohibit something but could only manage to prevent 30-40 percent of it compared to when it was legal I would certainly feel I had failed. This is without factoring in all the other problems Prohibition caused.
- brasky 12y agoDoes government itself work? I think that is what people need to ask themselves.
- lukifer 12y agoAlcohol prohibition is an apt historical lesson, especially regarding violence and black markets, but there is a significant difference: the intended targets. Alcohol was outlawed primarily to target men, particularly the violent and alcoholic, and was a stand-in for women's issues. It was the first time domestic violence began to be (indirectly) talked about, and was a major driver for women's suffrage and activism. Cannabis prohibition, on the other hand, has historically been targeted explicitly at minorities (and later expanded as a way to scare young people out of counter-cultures). In a sense, it has been extremely effective at its intended goal: systematic oppression of The Other. (The fact that early demonization of marijuana was intertwined with fears of white women being seduced by jazz culture or raped by "reefer madness" also signals an evo-psych component: removing competitor males from the gene pool by locking up as many black men as possible.) In addition to reducing undue U.S. interference with other countries' affairs, legalization is badly needed at home to reduce the prison population and address the racial injustices of the legal system.
- guard-of-terra 12y ago"Cannabis prohibition, on the other hand, has historically been targeted explicitly at minorities" In the USA. And the rest of the world inherited that for free. Which is kind of sad actually, living by other people ideosyncrasies.
- dragontamer 12y ago"Cannabis prohibition, on the other hand, has historically been targeted explicitly at minorities" Note: targeted at minorities by minorities. The African American community was hugely supportive of the "War on Drugs", until it became clear that it wasn't helping. But seriously, in the 1960s through 1990s, plenty of powerful African American politicians supported the War on Drugs. http://prisontime.org/files/2013/07/oberia-dempsey-war-on-drugs.jpg http://prisontime.org/files/2013/07/oberia-dempsey-war-on-dr... . The "War on Drugs" was built with huge support from the African American community, we Americans as a whole thought it would be good for us. It was believed that the white man oppressed African Americans through the use of drugs. Therefore, by declaring the war on drugs, the Black man would become freer. Things didn't turn out that way :-( Today, the "War on Drugs" is clearly not helping. Eric Holder / President Obama ordered the FBI / Justice Department to go easier against drug offenders. So it is clear to our current leaders (as well as African American leaders) that we need to end the "War on Drugs".
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- adventured 12y agoThere's absolutely no inherent problem with tax cuts for the wealthy - or anybody for that matter. The problem has always been deficit spending. That spending wasn't cut with the tax cuts; or that tax cuts weren't paid for out of surplus (which obviously the modern US Govt. has rarely had). For example, had George W. Bush not gone on a massive spending spree, there would have been zero deficit problem during his presidency in relation to the tax cuts. The problem was the extreme spending increases during his eight years, combined with cutting revenue. There's no inherent moral basis to claim rich people should always get soaked on taxes, even when there's plenty of revenue such that you have a surplus - it's a question of balancing. I'd argue unchecked spending expansion, drastically faster than the rate of population increase (ie what has happened in the last 13x years), is far more destructive than tax cuts for the wealthy. If you run a disciplined budget, and an efficient government, you will more than likely be able to bring down taxes for all people over time. The US has done the exact opposite lately, as have so many other failing welfare states across the globe.
- lisper 12y ago> There's absolutely no problem with tax cuts for the wealthy The data say otherwise. > The problem has always been deficit spending No. In Kansas they cut spending along with taxes (no choice -- a state can't run a long-term deficit). The result has been such an unmitigated disaster that even many prominent Republicans are now supporting the Democratic candidate for governor.
- Vernon092 12y agoAssuming the goal is to reduce revenue and spending, the tax cuts in Kansas have been a huge success.
- lisper 12y agoYes, of course. Just like Jim Crow laws are a success if they keep the races segregated. And ultimately this will be up to the people of Kansas to decide on the quality metric they want to apply to their state's economic policy. But I think it's telling that many prominent Republican politicians are endorsing the Democratic candidate for governor. I don't think they'd be doing that if there was a consensus that the results of Sam Brownback's experiment have been a "huge success."
- musername 12y agoI tried to understand your comment twice, but it doesn't work for me. Figures, the comment is wrong.
- HelloMcFly 12y agoFantastic contribution - thanks for showing up. What about the comment is wrong to you? It made perfect sense to me, but if you've got another perspective then feel free to share it.
- vegedor 12y agoYou could pose that question to the GP as well, that's the point. Your sarcasm-detector failed.
- HelloMcFly 12y agoIndeed it has, indeed it has.
- yodsanklai 12y ago> The data are unambiguous: prohibition doesn't work, never has, never will Does it mean that all drugs should be freely sold? I have no doubt that cannabis should be legal: not only is it relatively harmless, but it's very easy to grow. But what about other more addictive and dangerous drugs?
- MartinCron 12y agoWe are always drawing lines of what things are and are not permissible. You can move the line to the other side of pot without erasing it entirely.
- lisper 12y ago> Does it mean that all drugs should be freely sold? No. Ron's First Law still applies: all extreme positions are wrong.
- SnacksOnAPlane 12y agoI would say yes. Most of the problems we have with drugs are a result of drugs being illegal. If heroin addicts were able to buy a known product, unadulterated, at a reasonable price, we would have less crime and fewer ODs. And absolutely no one would try "bath salts" when they could get safe, researched, legal highs. If the argument is that everyone would just become drug addicts, I would argue that a hell of a lot of us already are drug addicts, just addicts to more socially acceptable drugs. And if reality can't compete with drugs, reality should step up its game.