11 ms·
>> Each genetic variant slightly increases or decreases cognitive ability. Because it is determined by many small additive effects, cognitive ability is normall
by bhouston 12y ago
>> Each genetic variant slightly increases or decreases cognitive ability. Because it is determined by many small additive effects, cognitive ability is normally distributed, following the familiar bell-shaped curve, with more people in the middle than in the tails.
> How do we know these genes have an additive effect on IQ?
I came to post on the same topic. Some gene effects are additive but those are the simple ones and there isn't that many of them. In something complex like a human brain, there are going to be tons of interactions between genes, so that maybe genes A+B makes someone smarter and C+D also make someone smarter, but the combo A+C makes someone actually less smart. The interactions are likely to be insanely complex -- eventually solvable but it will be a while.
To use a computer metaphor, the optimization landscape is not smooth and it doesn't only have a single optimal peak, it is highly complex with lots of local hills (which are caused by the interactions.)
> The breeding of domesticated plants and animals has changed some populations by as much as 30 standard deviations. Broiler chickens, for example, have increased in size more than four times since 1957. A similar approach could be applied to human intelligence, leading to IQs greater than 1,000.
This chicken metaphor is very wrong in that that was achieved via artificial selection, not genetic engineering. Artificial selection can make directed fast movement through an optimization landscape, but it does this without actually trying to figure out the interactions at the gene level, rather it looks as the results and selectively breads for those. When you do this to human it is called eugenics, and, to put it mildly, it likely isn't going to come back into fashion:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugenics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugenics
- readerrrr 12y agoWhen you do this to human it is called eugenics, and, to put it mildly, it likely isn't going to come back into fashion. Surprisingly we do it all the time, on animals, and we call it breeding. It is very successful and if applied to humans could produce real geniuses without any new tech or research in a handful of generations. Too bad the word has such negative association.
- brohee 12y agoLast I checked, most people mated with a partner of their choosing. That you call it love and not "selection of the most desirable traits" doesn't change the facts ;-)
- readerrrr 12y agoYou are using the same mistake as most people when they associate the word eugenics with mass forced extermination of certain traits. Because of fear and certain individuals in the past. The word can be used in a modern context, where eugenics is performed voluntarily, on a very small population, and under scientific supervision for causes that benefit the entire humanity. The rest can live and love whoever they want. Genetic manipulation functionally falls in the same category, but it is better accepted because it doesn't have the negative history attached to it.
- Dewie 12y agoIt isn't voluntary for the offspring that are created through such efforts. Sure, that's not the case for procreation to begin with... but the difference is that these people would effectively be bred for a specific purpose. Then, to keep it voluntary, I guess we would lightly suggest to them at some tender age to consider going into field which requires high intelligence? Or do we not interfere at all, and just observe them from a distance (since you mention scientific supervision)?
- crazypyro 12y agoNobody has a voluntary choice in their birth and eugenics doesn't have to breed people for a certain position or job. It may be something as simple as egg/sperm analysis that calculates a favorable (in whatever way the technology designers determine that) gene sequence and then the child would be raised normally. Eugenics doesn't mean the decay of the moral fabric of society or the loss of basic ethics in research. Why is it so hard to imagine eugenics integrating into modern society? This fear is really surprising to me.
- Thieum22 12y agoGenetic Testing is well and growing. Leads to embryo selection implicitly, which is not so far from eugenics. A good example is French Canadian region Lac St Jean where parents are allowed to select their embryo considering rare diseases present in the region : http://www.procreacliniques.com/en/genetic-testing/french-canadian-panel/ http://www.procreacliniques.com/en/genetic-testing/french-ca...
- Someone 12y agoAt the fringes (if one can call it that), it already is in fashion. See for example http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Down_syndrome http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Down_syndrome: "About 92% of pregnancies in Europe with a diagnosis of Down syndrome are terminated." "About 1.4 per 1000 live births in the United States and 1.1 per 1000 live births in Norway are affected. In the 1950s, in the United States, it occurred in 2 per 1000 live births with the decrease since then due to prenatal screening and abortion" (See also http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prenatal_screening http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prenatal_screening) I think the border between what is deemed acceptable and what isn't is moving towards more selection, and it wouldn't surprise me that, in a few centuries, we would be abhorred to learn how far it moved, and those who live then will look in horror at our primitive ways. Kids with Huntington's disease or genes that make it likely they will develop breast cancer still get born all the time, for example. EDIT: Down syndrome, not being hereditary, isn't the best example, but the message still stands.
- novaleaf 12y agoDown syndrome actually is hereditary. For some reason, some groups like to obfuscate this. Most cases are due to random mutation, but the cause is genetic, and can be passed on to children.