31 ms·
Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming
- ams6110 12y ago"optimistically, this might someday be possible" Seems a bit less certain than the title.
- buraksarica 12y agoThen post wouldn't show up in the first page. HNO (hacker news optimization :P)
- Beltiras 12y agoIt's been known since antiquity that sometimes geniuses sire idiots. The hyperfocus on genetics as the source of IQ is probably wrong. Let's remember that we are well educated apes and if not for the education we would still be looking at sticks and flint without realizing their combined value.
- csallen 12y agoThere's a very large gap between your first two sentences, especially since it's quite common for there to be large variations in intelligence among people raised/educated in similar environments.
- Beltiras 12y agoI'm not maintaining there is no genetic effect. I see plenty of indicators around me pointing both ways. I think it's a mix of things. I wished someone would have pointed out Plato's writing to me when I was a kid. It would have accelerated my intellectual development tremendously.
- mo1ok 12y agoAt the same time, there's a tendency for people of similar environments to have higher intelligence of people in other environments (the achievement gap).
- jsilence 12y agoSee also: Flynn Effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flynn_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flynn_effect
- Beltiras 12y agoThat was super interesting! Thanks. The most interesting part to me is that it might be coming to an end!
- lhnz 12y ago>> The hyperfocus on genetics as the source of IQ is probably wrong. Substantiate this please because just the other day I read "We know from many decades of research in behavioral genetics that about half of the variation across people in IQ is due to genes." [0] A lot of people want to believe that genetics doesn't play a big part in differentiation between human abilities but as science is not supporting that viewpoint it might be a good time to begin re-educating people on the limits of education. [0] http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/science/2014/09/malcolm_gladwell_s_10_000_hour_rule_for_deliberate_practice_is_wrong_genes.single.html http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/science/201...
- Shinkei 12y agoAmong twin-twin studies of the effects of nature/nuture, I recall mathematical ability as being the most highly heritable at something like 50%. Even eye color is not that high, and so it seems to be true that intelligence (at least in maths) is very heritable.
- bhouston 12y ago> I recall mathematical ability as being the most highly heritable at something like 50%. Even eye color is not that high Actually, heritability of eye color is 98%. A somewhat complete listing of heritability according to SNPedia (which doesn't include intelligence): http://www.snpedia.com/index.php/Heritability http://www.snpedia.com/index.php/Heritability
- cariaso 12y agohttp://www.snpedia.com/index.php/Eye_color http://www.snpedia.com/index.php/Eye_color does have extremely high heritability, but the mechanism is more complex than what we were usually mistaught in schools, which I think is the origin of Shinkei's comment. http://snpedia.com/index.php/Intelligence http://snpedia.com/index.php/Intelligence is not being well captured by GWAS. All current associations are probably false positives. I've not seen any evidence specific to mathematical ability.
- Rapzid 12y agoThis is... Not true. We HAVE attempted to educate apes after all...
- Beltiras 12y agoI did not mean that literally. Of course there are differences between apes and us. It's not a lot thou and the distinction between the species is not so old either.
- ap22213 12y agoTechnically, wouldn't it be a strange thing for a Human (or any species) to help perpetuate DNA within their own species that is not their own? I can see raising a child that is not one's own - because it's enjoyable and fulfilling to have a child. But, wouldn't the creation of 'Super-Anything' Humans be one step closer to the Human hive mind?
- ibisum 12y agoI think we don't acknowledge just how much of the Human Hive Mind we already have. I mean, there are individual humans: and then there is humanity. In between, many, many hives and collectives and corporations and aggregates, and so on. This, I believe, points to a 'higher, greater good' which is the species itself. So to answer your question, no: its not strange at all to be perpetuating human DNA in spite of ownership. Its the species which owns you, not the other way around. None of us exist without others.
- kghose 12y agoThis is an interesting question. We have evolved, but evolution is so slow that we do not notice that our children are actually inching away from us genetically (hopefully for the "better"). However, if we inject large artificial changes, what will happen? Will we reject our children? For a certain period in development, children reject their parents, naturally. But then we often come back (often when we are parents ourselves). But, if our children have large genetic changes from us, artificially done, how will our children look upon us? As pets, perhaps? Or mere caretakers? An interesting (and scary) thing too, is whether higher intelligence - as measured by these metrics - leads to "colder" humans, who make more rational decisions, such as euthanizing the old and weak, which would then include the parents.
- rheide 12y agoThe article assumes that if 1000 positive gene changes are responsible for increasing intelligence, you'll get 1000 increases of intelligence. It's much, much more likely that a lot of those gene changes overlap, meaning combined changes won't affect the IQ any more than either/or changes would.
- vixin 12y agoPossible to check this out. Society is polarizing and smart people are now tending to associate with other smart people to an extent that did not occur earlier. How are their progeny performing?
- ap22213 12y agoIsn't it true that children regress toward the norm? For example, two very tall people will more likely have a child that is shorter. Or, is that wrong?
- bhouston 12y ago> Isn't it true that children regress toward the norm? There isn't perfect heritability of all traits because they are influenced by multiple genes. Two tall people likely have different genes that are making them tall, and there are likely interactions happening with other genes in their genome. When you get a child, they have some genes from each parent but they also get lot of novel interactions between the genes of tallness and the rest of their genome. This tends to reduce the heritability of traits that are modulated by complex interacting gene networks. But it isn't a regression to some imaginary norm, it just means that that genes are not simply additive, they context dependent. But if you were to isolate 100 tall people from the population and had them breed for generations, and 100 short people and have them breed for generations, their offsprings likely will continue different in height still, they will never regress to the same "norm" because there are more tall genes or short genes in their respective populations.
- rjsw 12y ago
- electrograv 12y ago> Each genetic variant slightly increases or decreases cognitive ability. Because it is determined by many small additive effects, cognitive ability is normally distributed, following the familiar bell-shaped curve, with more people in the middle than in the tails. How do we know these genes have an additive effect on IQ? The causal relationship asserted by this quote is very strange. They claim: Because these effects are additive, IQ is normal distributed. What...? IQ is a test. It's normal distributed, like most tests are. They're referring to the central limit theorem here, I assume[1], which not a bad insight. However it should be obvious that this normal distribution phenomenon arises out of such tests being scored additively from a number of relatively independent questions (whose answers can be thought of as independent random variables of unknown distribution). In any case, I don't see how they can justify a causal link (in either direction) between some alleged additive effect of genes and the IQ test itself. Personally, I'm mostly interested in this claim on additive intelligence genes, since I'm not an expert on this. It would be fascinating and exciting if there were additive "intelligence genes". However, as someone working on artificial neural network research as a hobby, I'm highly skeptical of this. It seems much more likely that human intelligence is a delicate balance of many interacting factors relating to the architecture and "algorithms" of the brain. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central_limit_theorem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central_limit_theorem
- bhouston 12y ago>> Each genetic variant slightly increases or decreases cognitive ability. Because it is determined by many small additive effects, cognitive ability is normally distributed, following the familiar bell-shaped curve, with more people in the middle than in the tails. > How do we know these genes have an additive effect on IQ? I came to post on the same topic. Some gene effects are additive but those are the simple ones and there isn't that many of them. In something complex like a human brain, there are going to be tons of interactions between genes, so that maybe genes A+B makes someone smarter and C+D also make someone smarter, but the combo A+C makes someone actually less smart. The interactions are likely to be insanely complex -- eventually solvable but it will be a while. To use a computer metaphor, the optimization landscape is not smooth and it doesn't only have a single optimal peak, it is highly complex with lots of local hills (which are caused by the interactions.) > The breeding of domesticated plants and animals has changed some populations by as much as 30 standard deviations. Broiler chickens, for example, have increased in size more than four times since 1957. A similar approach could be applied to human intelligence, leading to IQs greater than 1,000. This chicken metaphor is very wrong in that that was achieved via artificial selection, not genetic engineering. Artificial selection can make directed fast movement through an optimization landscape, but it does this without actually trying to figure out the interactions at the gene level, rather it looks as the results and selectively breads for those. When you do this to human it is called eugenics, and, to put it mildly, it likely isn't going to come back into fashion: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugenics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugenics
- coldcode 12y agoThey would simply be averaged out by people elected to public office, a place where a super-intelligent human would never be welcomed.
- bhouston 12y agoSome US presidents have been really intelligent. It is easy to knock them, but recent presidents Bush Sr., Clinton and Obama are all extremely bright. Romney also is really smart given his work in the financial industry. Bush Jr., who wasn't that bright, is more of an exception than the rule I think for US presidents.
- crazypyro 12y agoI am almost 100% certain Bush Jr. would be considered bright when compared with any cross section of say 1000 US citizens. People try to compare him with previous presidents, but it is all speculative. Even though I disagree with his presidential policies, I find the baseless, tiring insults on his intelligence to be more grating.
- socialist_coder 12y agoOnly because the general public is so... average (pretty dumb). If the average person had a 10 or 15 point higher IQ, I think people would put a higher value on intelligence in their elected officials. I think that the world would look a lot different (better) if the average intelligence was raised by this much. So many things would change. A dawn of a new era.
- peterfirefly 12y agoIsrael sounds like it would be a natural experiment for that hypothesis. I hope you are right but it doesn't quite look that way.
- kingkawn 12y agoThe depth of control over raw genetic material that occurs within each living thing is complex to an order not yet close to a meaningful understanding. Gene methylation alone can render a gene meaningless for you, your children, and theirs. It is the scope of the remaining unknowns in this field that allow us to project our speculative hopes onto them.
- lettergram 12y agoThe largest impact on our brains isn't our genetics. Our ability to recall information has become moot, I know I personally just store an index of all the information I lean in my brain. Then if I'm like, "Oh, this can be solved with <insert solution>" I just look it up, since I have all the worlds previous knowledge literally a few typed words and 2 - 3 clicks away. Further, every gene we alter effects other genes, if we alter a large portion to increase our brain capacity we really have no idea what else will be effected. Worse yet, we really don't have a "good" measurement of IQ to begin with. Is being able to do spacial tasks really intelligence, perhaps we should focus on memorization a bit more... it is really all arbitrary. The only real genetic benefits to our brain come from improved wiring, i.e. able to complete concurrent tasks, storing memories more efficiently, etc. The only way I see any of this being improved are from significant advances in neuroscience and genetics, and we make the assumption that we can simulate all of this or experiment on humans (pretty large assumption here). Everything is possible given enough time, but I do not think we are anywhere near close enough to do genetic modifications to improve the brain. Perhaps we could do some bio-machine hybridization, i.e. connect my brain to the internet or something, that's a bit closer, but still 20+ years out (if I had to guess). FYI, I actually am trying to start a company to gather more accurate information and augment the brain: http://synaptitude.me/ http://synaptitude.me/
- bhouston 12y ago> Further, every gene we alter effects other genes, if we alter a large portion to increase our brain capacity we really have no idea what else will be effected. I agree completely. There are tons of interactions. It is a incredibly complex process to genetically engineer improved intelligence in any significant fashion. > Worse yet, we really don't have a "good" measurement of IQ to begin with. Is being able to do spacial tasks really intelligence, perhaps we should focus on memorization a bit more... it is really all arbitrary. I disagree. We have a decent measurement, but we do not have a good understanding of the neurological basis of it all: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G_factor_(psychometrics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G_factor_(psychometrics) > The only real genetic benefits to our brain come from improved wiring, i.e. able to complete concurrent tasks, storing memories more efficiently, etc This is pretty simplistic and I think wrong. Our brains wiring is the only real difference between us and monkeys (and every other animal for that matter), but that different "wiring" (more and different structures) makes a massive difference. To dismiss "wiring" differences like this is insane. > Perhaps we could do some bio-machine hybridization, i.e. connect my brain to the internet or something, that's a bit closer, but still 20+ years out (if I had to guess). Sounds like an https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exocortex https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exocortex
- Morgawr 12y agoDid anybody else notice that the chicken in the picture is possibly the same chicken at different stages of growth?
- bencollier49 12y agoIf 1000 genes have an impact on intelligence, "activating" them all is likely to result in illness. We've seen something similar with Schizophrenia - get one related gene variant and you get someone with creative flair or good pattern recognition. Inherit 5 and they become paranoid and hear voices.
- Taek 12y agoThere are a lot of open questions with regards to intelligence manipulation, both scientific and ethical. We're like a child accessing the internet for the first time. We don't know what it is, how it works, and we've been told there are things we should never do. Genetic engineering of humans is likely to be an extremely powerful tool, and we aren't going to understand it until we start playing around. We've already got some cognitive baselines for other species, perhaps we can start trying to manipulate their intelligence and see what happens. And we can try to perform 'ethical eugenics' on ourselves. Imagine having 15 or 100 embryos, and picking your favorite. If you only intended on raising 1 child in the first place, I don't see how this is wrong. It's less grey than abortion. Having sets of 'chosen' babies will give us a ton of information about our genetics, even if we don't start manipulating their genes directly. I'm within a decade of having children, and I really hope that I can 'optimize' at least one of the multiple children I intend to have. I feel like the potential scientific progress is worth the risk.
- wtbob 12y ago> In the former case, parents choosing between 10 or so zygotes could improve the IQ of their child by 15 or more IQ points. Well, yes—if you kill the bottom 90-93% of people ranked by intelligence, then the remainder are going to be quite smart. Of course, that doesn't account for the possibility that there might be other good things about the children the parents never see. And in fact, if it's true that there's a strong correlation between high intelligence and problems, then such an approach might lead to more problems than it solves.
- netcan 12y agoArtificial selection also appears to work in unusual ways. We don't really understand the mechanics of it. Foxes were selectively bred in several experiments (and for the fur trade) for tameness. Basically breeding only foxes that don't bite or recoil from people. The breed developed a whole range of dog like characteristic, behavioral and morphological. They whine and bark (which neither wolves or wild foxes do). They develop a diversity of coloration. I've even heard some had cute floppy ears. Obviously there is a corollary to dog evolution, which we don't really understand either. Selecting for a trait or a family of traits in humans will probably have unexpected side effects.
- falcor84 12y agoJust putting a relevant wikipedia article here - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domesticated_silver_fox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domesticated_silver_fox
- htns 12y agoWolves not barking is a myth, at least if I believe my first google hit.
- netcan 12y agoAt the very least, dogs bark much more.
- wtbob 12y ago
- netcan 12y agoI normally balance on the relatively skeptical side on most things. But topics like this make me giddy. No doubt consequences and roadblocks will abound. But if superhuman intelligence is coming in some form (and I think it is), I'm excited. Embarrassingly so. The 'what will happen?' story is hard to pin down. What are the emotional impacts of owning a 100X better than Einstein brain? What are the social impacts? Does collaboration work better? Human intelligence enabled a step change in mammalian collaboration during the paleolithic revolution. Genetic engineering is not the only potential path either. Technological access to information extends the human cognitive potential. The interface between mind and machine may reach revolutionary points. Our minds have different learning capabilities at 20 days, 20 months or 20 years old. Can that be hacked? Can we have all these capabilities at once, for extended periods? Like I said, giddy.
- wahsd 12y agoSeems we are more likely to move into rather dark conjecture. For some reason, humans seems to be rather convinced of themselves, in spite of there really being no evidence for any kind of justification. We are facing a future that is being wholly underestimated where the USA is ushering in an existence that is dominated by control and oppression and abuse; how can that be any kind of indication that there are, let alone will be super intelligent humans. I think someone has been reading too many scifi novels and listening to bamboozlers. There is no objective evidence that we are getting any more intelligent than past intellectuals even if we are simply just building on top of previous achievements. Just alone the notion that you would not realize that our "achievement" is just building upon achievements of the past is proof enough that there really has been little to no improvement. Call me when humanity has been able to wrestle itself away from the mental parasite that is religion. Then we can talk about the possibility of super intelligent humans. Let's the get the blatantly obvious mental health issues out of the way first.
- chadgeidel 12y ago"There is no objective evidence that we are getting any more intelligent than past intellectuals..." Doesn't the Flynn Effect (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flynn_effect http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flynn_effect) counter that claim?
- kachnuv_ocasek 12y agoNo, that only concerns intelligence test scores.
- peterfirefly 12y agoReally? How about the part of the Flynn effect that is caused by improved (micro) nutrition? In other words, adding iodine to salt improved IQ scores (in areas where the soil was deficient) -- but it also improved real intelligence. I consider it likely that some of the Flynn effect is an artefact due to schooling, newspapers, books, TV, computer games, etc, but some of it seems to be very real.
- 12y ago
- McDiesel 12y agoCan we just work on increasing the amount of intelligent human beings before we jump to super-intelligent? Thanks.
- thisjepisje 12y agoReminds me of that Outer Limits episode. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sixth_Finger http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sixth_Finger
- tempodox 12y ago1. I'm skeptical that we can actually give a sensible definition of “intelligence” / “smartness”. 2. Even if we could do (1), I'm still skeptical we can inflate that intentionally. 3. Even if we can do (2), I'm extremely skeptical the outcome is desirable, for any definition of “desirable”, either from our own point of view or our augmented offspring's. Other than that, the idea seems like a perfect example of stone-cold megalomania.
- threatofrain 12y agoSee how you might like this definition: intelligence, including artificial intelligence (which just means intelligence resting on non-organic materials), means general and arbitrary analogical ability. I think this definition fits what people mean when they say "general mental ability", which I think is what people mean to measure when they use IQ. I think this is a really good definition of intelligence for communicating what we want to talk about here. And personally I think it's fine to accept a useful definition, even if it is not perfect, and even if its proliferation means some people get unjustly damaged, insofar that the pragmatism of the construct is adequately useful. From there, you have a community tool that can undergo refinement or challenge. It seems very plausible that we could raise whatever people are trying to invoke when people say words like "intelligence", IQ, g, or arbitrary analogical ability. I'm surprised you are extremely skeptical that we could desirably raise intelligence. Even a noisy and brutish eugenic pressure in the environment would push a population towards a direction, and I'm convinced that this will happen with or without explicit policy.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoIsn't that trading one number for one word? I've got to believe that intelligence is multi-dimensional. Its silly to correlate IQ points with genes. E.g. you can probably correlate genes with phone numbers too, but it doesn't mean anything about the individual. Its got more to do with the system that assigned them that IQ. E.g. taller people are perceived as smarter, for no good reason.
- threatofrain 12y ago
- AJ007 12y ago"Superintelligence" by Nick Bostrom is well worth the read on this topic. Thanks to Elon Musk for recommending it. Roughly speaking, Nick suggests that human biology does have a limit, and AI will jump far ahead in the time that it does take to use eugenics to boost human intelligence.
- madaxe_again 12y agoInteresting article, but I feel it misses the simple fact that any individual with an IQ of 1000 is likely to be "insane" by any modern measure of the world - they certainly wouldn't have a world-view that has much in common with their "fellow men". As it stands, many of those who have exceptionally high IQs or high "intelligence" struggle to exist in a world that isn't geared for them. These "hyper-intelligent" individuals, should they ever exist, would likely be stoned by their fellow men, or would choose to be the other variety of stoned rather than suffer the stupid of the world.
- a8da6b0c91d 12y agoIQs over about 115 are plainly maladaptive from an evolutionary standpoint. You get far sub replacement fertility, and this has been noted for ages.
- madaxe_again 12y agoThis is true - otherwise we'd have consistently growing intelligence over the generations - and instead we find the inverse - dysgenic fertility rules the day.
- gwern 12y agoThis is untrue. If it really were a universal, why would there be such high IQs in the first place? As well, it's not empirically obvious: some samples show dysgenics, others show eugenics. I'm sure you're familiar with Clark's claims about England and China, but you can also find eugenic samples in a number of modern samples (iirc, post-WWII Baby Boom was eugenic) collated in Richard Lynn and Tatu Vanhanen, Intelligence: A Unifying Construct for the Social Sciences, 2012; and some HBDers crunching the GSS claim that current trends are eugenic for men but dysgenic for women.
- madaxe_again 12y agoWhat about the reaction time series that suggest a consistent decline in g?
- kingmanaz 12y agoAs in Dungeons and Dragons, perhaps a distinction exists between man's wisdom and intelligence. If so, a novel genius might profitably be tempered by a common-sense practicality.
- cpwright 12y agoThe chicken analogy doesn't sit right with me because there are far more generations of chickens over a given period of time; and additionally the trait that you want to select for in a chicken is clear. You want the biggest chicken in the least amount of time. Intelligence is only one trait out of many that you would like to select for. Attractiveness, strength, health, etc. all matter just as much. Balancing competing concerns is harder than just making a fat chicken.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Gravityloss 12y agoThere was an article about a study which suggested that people with IQ above 140 tended to be lonely. Raises ethical issues (among other reasons that obviously do).
- wolfgke 12y ago> There was an article about a study which suggested that people with IQ above 140 tended to be lonely. Indeed: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8320331 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8320331
- gwern 12y agoThe nice thing about proposing to manufacture lots of >140 people is that the loneliness problem fixes itself. :)
- onetimeusename 12y agoI am curious about the motivations for this kind of research. It seems to me that the assumption is that a super intelligent human being would be a saviour to humanity of some sort. I really just see that humans are all in competition with each other, which may be a good thing. So engineering a super human would actually be a form of outsourcing. So first there is the assumption that the superhuman would be better and second there is the problem of why people would want to bring about their own outsourcing.
- LLWM 12y agoIn other words, "We should never have invented that damn cotton gin." All evidence supports the idea that this kind of research will lead to improved quality of life for practically everyone.
- onetimeusename 12y agoWhat evidence is there that superhumans will lead to "improved quality of life"? Even though you are just dispensing snark, I am glad you used this example so I could show what I meant. "we should never have invented that damn cotton gin" said the cotton pickers. "we should never have invented those damn superhumans" said the humans. What is being outsourced is the entire spectrum of human ability by what is essentially another species and not just machines that we are fundamentally in control of or own.
- LLWM 12y agoGood. I look forward to doing more interesting things with my additional free time.
- tucosan 12y agoThe author of that piece on Nautilus also published a paper on the topic: http://arxiv.org/abs/1408.3421 http://arxiv.org/abs/1408.3421
- flyrain 12y agoI hope somebody could improve dogs IQ, so she can talk to me or just understand me better.
- amjaeger 12y agoReading the article I could only think of the past failures with eugenics, like Nazi Germany, or even some stuff that happened in the US. I think we should be wary of the consequences.
- Houshalter 12y agoThis is editing the genome to be smarter, not sterilizing stupid people.
- dreamweapon 12y ago"I have always thought that von Neumann's brain indicated that he was from another species, an evolution beyond man." --Nobel laureate Hans E. Bethe Yet we have no evidence that von Neumann's supergenius intelligence was due to any specific genetic traits that he inherited. And even if some of these could be genetically isolated, we have no basis at this point to believe that any of these (as of yet unspecified) traits can be "engineered", singly or collectively. The article gets worse from there. Presumably the author is aware of the Fallacy of Linear Extrapolation, yet he boldly goes on to say: Given that there are many thousands of potential positive variants, the implication is clear: If a human being could be engineered to have the positive version of each causal variant, they might exhibit cognitive ability which is roughly 100 standard deviations above average. This corresponds to more than 1,000 IQ points. This aside from the fact that no one really what (high) IQ is, or what an IQ of 1,000 points (or even "100 standard deviations above average") could possibly mean (or even be measured).
- Houshalter 12y agoThis is totally false. Intelligence is strongly genetic. Traits are very often genetically additive. Although we won't be certain until do a huge survey of genetics, all the author is saying is that it might be possible. And if it is, then we do have the technology to "engineer" a child with the genes we want.
- dreamweapon 12y agoAll the author is saying is that it might be possible. No; he doesn't merely say that it "might be possible." He says that it will happen. In fact he's so sure it will happen that it's basically inevitable. So sure that he takes great pains to say so, in bold letters (hundreds of pixels wide): "Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming"
- Houshalter 12y agoThat's just the title, and that claim is much weaker than the "1,000 IQ" claim I was referring to. The author is very clear this isn't a certainty.
- neotoy 12y agoMore like: A new generation of humans who think in a way that a previous generation of humans who are considered subjectively 'less intelligent' consider to be 'super intelligent' is coming. Many lolz will be had as they all perish due to their objective stupidity.
- hyperion2010 12y agoI see many posts here asking about the genetics of intelligence. Here is the best review to date (it is open access) [1]. The authors have been studying the genetics of intelligence for over 30 years. The tl;dr is that we know if no single genetic switch that can increase intelligence, there seem to be many little switches that give rise to the normal IQ distribution. 1. http://www.nature.com/mp/journal/vaop/ncurrent/full/mp2014105a.html http://www.nature.com/mp/journal/vaop/ncurrent/full/mp201410...
- tokenadult 12y agoAs I commented on this interesting article when it was a submission to Hacker News, "Robert Plomin and Ian Deary are mainstream researchers on the behavior genetics of human intelligence, the authors of well regarded textbooks (Plomin), popular books (both), and primary research articles (both) on various related topics. Their joint point of view as expressed in the review article published today is not the exact point of view of all researchers in the field, but I thought it would do as a discussion-starter here on Hacker News. "A crucial detail (Deary and Plomin would both agree about this, but it hasn't come up in the discussion here yet) is that heritablity has NOTHING to do with modifiability. It is quite possible in principle that a novel environmental intervention might be discovered that could boost most people's intelligence. It is even possible that the most effective intervention might have a gene-environment (G × E) interaction such that the intervention would most help people with lowest IQ, and least help people who already have high IQs. No such intervention that human beings can direct purposefully has yet been found, but it is clear from the Flynn effect[1] that something in the environment can have powerful effects in raising average IQ levels of whole countries, as has happened in the developed world throughout the last century (for as long as IQ tests have been around). "It is correct that people marry and have children on bases other than just shared level of intelligence. (But living in the same town, and completing higher education at similar ages, and pursuing compatible occupations for marriage, etc. is correlated with IQ.) It is still far too early to say how rapidly human populations might see noticeable effects from assortative mating by IQ. It is reasonably clear that often-feared dysenic trends probably are NOT happening--the lowest-IQ people in the world population don't reproduce at all, and high-IQ people actually have reasonable numbers of children to replicate their genes. In any event, the favorable environmental trends have SWAMPED whatever genetic trends are going on for IQ in the whole human population, and people are getting smarter all over the world, according to the research on the Flynn effect. "It is still a hard problem to identify anything at all meaningful and replicable about how gene differences influence IQ differences, even though it is now settled wisdom that they do. Human IQ, as the article says, is influenced by MANY genes, and many of those genes interact with one another in ways that are not understood at all yet." [1] https://www.ted.com/talks/james_flynn_why_our_iq_levels_are_higher_than_our_grandparents https://www.ted.com/talks/james_flynn_why_our_iq_levels_are_... http://blog.ted.com/2013/09/26/further-reading-on-the-flynn-effect/ http://blog.ted.com/2013/09/26/further-reading-on-the-flynn-...
- tokenadult 12y agoI somehow missed this thread at first. Reading through the comments here, I see several comments that express the correct idea, but without the key word, of "pleiotropy," that is a gene (or gene assemblage) having more than one effect on phenotype. Some of the breeding examples mentioned in other comments already provide the warning: if we select human gene assemblages to maximize IQ scores (or something that can link even more directly to what we call "intelligence" in the real world outside the testing room), we may or may not produce healthy human beings, depending on what the pleiotropic effects of those gene assemblages are. Right now we just don't know. An article in the Nature Scitable collection explains what pleiotropy is in more detail.[1] I see that the author of the article kindly submitted here has just joined HN to join the discussion. I would respectfully suggest that the idea of "Crudely speaking, IQs of order 1,000, if the scale were to continue to have meaning," should be amended with a discussion of how IQ scores of 1,000 can't possibly exist, and surely wouldn't have meaning. That's because IQ scores are not derived from an interval scale, but rather an ordinal scale.[2] I read the story "Flowers for Algernon" when I was a kid too, and it was a very moving story, and the author did a reasonably good job of researching theories of psychology for his era. But his account of a mentally retarded (today we would say "intellectually disabled") adult having some kind of treatment that raised his IQ immensely is, at bottom, a made-up story, and the author was actually more clever than many of his readers in suggesting what is uncertain about what IQ scores mean. (He has some of his characters debate with one another about that, as I noticed when I reread the story in the last year.) We know Richard Feynman's IQ as a historical matter.[3] Feynman's IQ of 125 was above average, of course, but not astoundingly high. There are several Nobel Prize winners in physics with an IQ at a similar level, and plenty of physicists with higher IQs who never achieve as much in physics research as a Nobel laureate does. The uniform conclusion of ALL researchers who have looked at the relationship between IQ scores and scientific research achievement is that other personal qualities besides IQ matter a lot for research breakthroughs. One personal quality that is too little tapped by IQ testing is the habit of mind called "rationality." Amazing, that does not correlate especially strongly with IQ.[4] Improving "mindware," the ways that people think and how they reality-check their own thinking, may have a more powerful effect for human progress than merely increasing IQ. James R. Flynn, the dean of living researchers on human intelligence, suggests some strategies for improving thinking.[5] Being old enough to remember many gee-whiz promises about human genetic investigations that didn't pan out, for the moment I will bet on Flynn's approach providing more long-term benefit for humankind than the approach of looking for genome-wide associations with IQ.[6] [1] http://www.nature.com/scitable/topicpage/pleiotropy-one-gene-can-affect-multiple-traits-569 http://www.nature.com/scitable/topicpage/pleiotropy-one-gene... [2] See the references collected at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Level_of_measurement#Ordinal_scale https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Level_of_measurement#Ordinal_s... or https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IQ_classification#Variance_in_individual_IQ_classification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IQ_classification#Variance_in_... and note the diversity of cited authors, who all agree that IQ scores are ordinal rather than interval numbers. [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IQ_classification#IQ_classification_and_genius https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IQ_classification#IQ_classific... [4] http://www.yalebooks.com/yupbooks/book.asp?isbn=9780300164626 http://www.yalebooks.com/yupbooks/book.asp?isbn=978030016462... [5] http://www.wiley.com/WileyCDA/PressRelease/pressReleaseId-104556.html http://www.wiley.com/WileyCDA/PressRelease/pressReleaseId-10... [6] "Most Reported Genetic Associations with General Intelligence Are Probably False Positives" http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3498585/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3498585/ "Understanding the Genetics of Intelligence: Can Height Help? Can Corn Oil?" http://apsychoserver.psych.arizona.edu/JJBAReprints/PSYC621/Johnson%20Current%20Directions%20Psych%20Science%202010%20(G%20and%20E%20in%20IQ).pdf http://apsychoserver.psych.arizona.edu/JJBAReprints/PSYC621/...
- swalsh 12y agoI stopped reading the article about halfway through, because it didn't seem like anything radically new... but the one comment i'd make is that it's clear a combination of genetics and environmental factors affect intelligence, and frankly both are improving. The article seems to go on about how genes are improving, however the internet is having a pretty significant effect too. A well built house can be renovated from something that looks terrible, to something people will pay loads of money for. A fully functional brain can be renovated too. People can learn how to think, and while there are parts that are quite degenerate, there are a greater number of parts that help people learn.
- Detrus 12y agoI remember from a documentary about IQs that it gives no advantage to hunters. At least hunters who use hunter gatherer technology. It may be correlated to better brain quality or whatever, but it is an adaptation that gives an advantage only in the modern world. Some tasks are done better by a lesser mind.