13 ms·
I'm not seeing any top physicists working in this program (McGuire is not one). I would be willing to bet 1000 EUR that their math and modeling does not add u
by nabla9 12y ago
I'm not seeing any top physicists working in this program (McGuire is not one). I would be willing to bet 1000 EUR that their math and modeling does not add up, or they have skipped some details.
Problem with fusion research like this is that the closer you get self sustainment or energy generation, the harder it gets and problems pile up. This project looks like many other similar projects that have gone bust. They start by solving the easiest problems first, get some funding and hit the wall.
The main problem with any reactor design is how to handle the 14 MeV neutrons produced by the fusion reaction (no mention in the article). They tend to damage the reactor and make it economically unfeasible. At this point being able to create fusion reaction is not the main challenge. It's the sustainment and economics of limiting the damage. If they really have solved all the problems and demonstrate economically sound fusion in 5-10 years, they will be handed Nobel price in physics for sure.
- cswhatt 12y agoBetting on a math error from Skunkworks? Highly unlikely. If anything, scalability will be the issue, as it always is
- gh02t 12y agoIt's a very safe bet. Well, probably not a math error as they are quite a fine institution, but what he says is probably the case. The challenges of fusion power are largely fundamental nitty gritty engineering issues. We know fairly well how to design most of a fusion reactor; in a lot of ways they are conceptually easier than fission reactors. The two main hurdles are the materials problems and how to keep the reaction critical with radiative heat loss. These are big problems that so many times have been ignored by people claiming to have solved fusion power. You just can't get away from them, but solving them would be truly revolutionary. I'm not saying they don't have something novel here as they really are some fine researchers at Skunkworks. Just temper your expectations.
- noir_lord 12y ago> The challenges of fusion power are largely fundamental nitty gritty engineering issues. I'm not saying they've done it and extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof but this is the place that made a Mach 3.5 jet with wings that leaked out of titanium in the 60's. Nitty-gritty engineering is something they are fairly good at.
- gh02t 12y agoIndeed, believe me I hope I'm wrong and that fusion power really is around the corner. It's just that, according to the article, they aren't even at the prototype phase yet. That's where the real problems for fusion reactors arise. I'm sure that they've done something interesting, but my (semi-expert, I'm a nuclear engineering PhD, but not in fusion technology) opinion, this doesn't look like The Big Discovery.
- TrainedMonkey 12y agoTokamaks were perfect on paper till they were fired up, and then we realized that there is a lot about high energy confinement we did not know about. So I think the math is correct according to current models, but whether those models are close enough to reality for this to work is another question entirely.
- tonyplee 12y agoHow much dangerous are the neutrons from such device? Similar to radiation, worst? Time sell any oil company stocks, mutual fund holding?
- adventured 12y agoTime to buy airline stocks. If you can put a miniature fusion power plant on an 747 equivalent, airline profit margins will skyrocket. Actually even if you believed there's a chance this Lockheed concept can work, the time to buy airline stocks would be on the back end of this dead bull market that's about to fall off a cliff. And then there's the 20 year wait before it's finally deployed to a commercial airplane.
- graycat 12y agoA fusion powered 747 might be the result, but maybe not! Instead, let's see: With the CFR, we've got dirt cheap electric power. Okay, then we can also use that power to make dirt cheap, very clean water. Then, yup, we can take that water, more of that power, and coal and make jet fuel. And maybe that is what the 747s would continue to use! Maybe!
- rybosome 12y agoIf we get a working CFR as described, I'd be shocked if the cost of coal extraction and usage remained low enough for this to be a sound idea. In the face of extremely cheap, clean power, I'd sincerely hope that the government would incentivize its use. Coal and oil lobbies might be able to fight this to some extent, but once a safe and economically viable alternative is present, the days of fossil fuel reliance are numbered. This can't happen soon enough.
- tonyplee 12y agoAccording to "neutrons make other things radioactive", anything that carry by that fission 747 "might" be radioactive after a flight. True?
- 12y ago
- jsmthrowaway 12y agoIt's always a safe bet that the top Hacker News comment will always be "won't work, it's too hard." It's like sitting around for a year trying to sell a project at my current employer, with everybody and their lead telling you "that'll never work," then you implement in a weekend and those same people start nitpicking what you've come up with. (What happened to it'll never work? "Well, your CSS isn't great.") Honestly, those folks that stand back with their arms crossed watching you fail, and reminding you the whole way that you might fail, are the biggest pains in my ass in this profession. By a mile. Maybe you can contribute your wisdom by going to Lockheed, instead of Internet commentary in which you bet against them?
- protonfish 12y agoAnd it's always a safe bet the top response to that comment will be somebody criticizing it without any solid facts or reason but with fuzzy "you just need to believe harder!" kind of nonsense.
- jsmthrowaway 12y agoActually, I subtly said "get the hell out of the way if you don't think it'll work," not warm and fuzzy smarminess. But it's much easier for you to mock if you read warm and fuzzies out of it, and I get that. What I said, reworded, was the people who sit on the sidelines of anything and tell you, while you are trying something, that it won't work are among the worst people in the profession. I didn't say believe harder. I don't give a damn what you believe and don't need you reminding me, constantly, that my project has a chance of failure. Keep it to yourself or get on board. That's my point. I am not a kind person, so that you'd ascribe feel-good nonsense to me is downright hilarious. I can handle it but a lot of people can't, and it's really, really tiring to keep a team from becoming demoralized when there's a naysayer popcorn gallery in every thread and watercooler discussion.
- Kalium 12y agoThe naysayers do us all a valuable service. They remind us that hope, dreams, and belief do not solve engineering problems. You know what demoralizes a team like nothing else? And endless litany of projects that failed because nobody wanted to listen to the people pointing out problems.
- graycat 12y agoThe Skunk works has one heck of a good reputation. So, I have to guess that the Lockheed suits had this guy's work and PR reviewed with a microscope from tip to tail, math, physics, materials, software, experiments to date, etc., including reviews by people who would have loved to have found something wrong.
- guelo 12y agoIf you have to periodically throw away your reactor and buy a new one because of neutron damage that would be a positive thing for a company like Lockheed.
- Zikes 12y agoMaintenance costs alone would be astronomically lucrative.
- thrownaway2424 12y agoBut solving fusion will cut into Lockheed's mainline oil wars revenue stream.
- Zikes 12y agoThat'll do for now, but CFRs are a sustainable strategy that will keep the pensions rolling.
- RogerL 12y agoYou can't stop progress just because it alters your cash flow. If you don't make the product, someone else will, and end up positioned to take the future cash flows. No (rational) company stops investing in new products just because it challenges their current offerings.
- Crito 12y agoOil wars are old hat. They were useful for bootstrapping the system, but now that that is done we don't need them anymore. Oil wars are not preferred because they are fairly transparent and therefore give bad approval ratings for politicians. The new system: Find a war torn area (perhaps one decimated by oil wars), dismantle their army and replace it with a wildly incompetent one. Make an earnest but fruitless attempt to train them (how humanitarian!). Give them American weapons (cha-ching) without actually solving any of the issues that were destabilizing the region. Local strive escalates to war, the incompetent army is crushed and their American weapons are seized. Use American owned and operated weapons (cha-ching) to bomb the seized American weapons back into the stone age (how humanitarian!). Rinse and repeat. War machine get's their money, and the politicians get to pretend that they are only trying to help others.
- titanomachy 12y ago"There aren't any top physicists working on this project" isn't really enough to dismiss it outright. The number of brilliant physicists is much greater than the number of top physicists, so it's not unheard of for major developments to come from someone who's not yet highly recognized. McGuire's an MIT Ph.D, so it's likely he's not a complete idiot. I hope they have some novel ideas about neutron containment, though, otherwise you're right and this is project is not likely to yield the first economical fusion reactor.
- trhway 12y ago>McGuire's an MIT Ph.D, so it's likely he's not a complete idiot. obviously. The proposed reactor looks exactly like a great PhD thesis with honors - a novel field configuration proposed which allows to reach beta of one. The rest of the whole system is given only cursory treatment. In particular how about a "neutron absorbing blanket" in a business-jet size envelope?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- logicallee 12y ago>I'm not seeing any top physicists working in this program (McGuire is not one). McGuire is a top physicist - he is currently working on a compact fusion reactor at Skunk Works, which came out with the SR-71 Blackbird among other innovations. Oh, did you mean, ones who had already succeeded in their top projects? Well, how do you think they got to succeed - by not doing it?
- scottlocklin 12y ago"Top physicists?" Fusion is an engineering problem. The thing to check here is what plasma temperature/densities they have achieved with their new confinement scheme. They've basically said the results are preliminary, and some of the results are from simulation (which should not be trusted; aka look at how well the NIF simulations worked). This is not particularly interesting. Shielding was mentioned, though not enough, but it's fairly trivial: if you add enough matter with a high neutron cross section (paraffin for example), and build the mechanical components out of things with a low cross section (iron, I think) it's not a problem. Plasma is the problem. It's interesting, but "10 years off" is not much better than the standard "20 years off" promises of fusion research. As others have pointed out, controlled fusion has been 20 years in the future since 1950 or so. "1 year off" would be a lot more noteworthy. As it stands, this is just Lockheed informing us they have a controlled fusion program. Anyway, "nice press release, dudes."
- peterfirefly 12y ago> "Top physicists?" Fusion is an engineering problem." So are refrigerators. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Einstein_refrigerator http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Einstein_refrigerator
- geon 12y ago> It has been suggested that most of the actual inventing was performed by Szilárd, with Einstein merely acting as a consultant and helping with the patent-related paperwork.[1] Plausible, since he had the experience.
- peterfirefly 12y agoAnd Szilárd was not a top-class physicist (and engineer)?
- estefan 12y agolol
- Gravityloss 12y ago
- twocommas 12y ago"They start by solving the easiest problems first, get some funding and hit the wall." Exactly! Just repeat keep repeating that process!
- FranOntanaya 12y agoMaybe the trick is that the reactor design is either cheap enough to be disposable, or just lasts enough to run a submarine for a few months (not necessarily in an economical fashion, but with other desirable advantages) and have it replaced like a car battery.
- jfolkins 12y agohttp://www.economist.com/news/science-and-technology/21625861-lockheed-martin-thinks-it-can-make-fusion-power-reality-within-decade-big-bet-small http://www.economist.com/news/science-and-technology/2162586... "As Tom McGuire, who is leading the Lockheed team, notes, however, the circular magnetic fields which coil around a tokamak’s doughnut become unstable if the plasma’s pressure is too high."